Skip to main content
Skip to main content
entertainment

Nintendo Switch vs PlayStation 5

The Nintendo Switch is a hybrid portable-home console emphasizing versatility and accessibility with 153.10 million units sold, while the PlayStation 5 is a dedicated home console focused on high-performance gaming with 90.20 million units sold. Choose the Switch for portability and Nintendo exclusives, or PS5 for cutting-edge graphics and PlayStation's acclaimed franchises.

Nintendo Switch

Nintendo Switch

Hybrid handheld-home console released March 2017 with detachable Joy-Con controllers.

Casual gamers, families, Nintendo franchise fans, and those who value portability

Score60%
VS
PlayStation 5

PlayStation 5

Fixed-hardware console with custom AMD processor, 4K gaming, and exclusive PlayStation titles.

Hardcore gamers, those seeking premium graphics, PlayStation exclusive fans, and competitive online players

Score55%

Quick Answer

AI Summary

The Nintendo Switch is a hybrid portable-home console emphasizing versatility and accessibility with 153.10 million units sold, while the PlayStation 5 is a dedicated home console focused on high-performance gaming with 90.20 million units sold. Choose the Switch for portability and Nintendo exclusives, or PS5 for cutting-edge graphics and PlayStation's acclaimed franchises.

Our Verdict

AI-assisted

The Nintendo Switch and PlayStation 5 serve different gaming audiences and preferences. The Switch excels in portability, affordability, and family-friendly gaming, while the PS5 dominates in raw performance and cinematic AAA experiences. Your choice depends on whether you prioritize flexibility and fun (Switch) or graphical fidelity and exclusive blockbuster titles (PS5).

Community feedback

Was this verdict helpful?

Nintendo Switch
6.3/10
vs
👑PlayStation 5
8.8/10
Nintendo Switch

Choose Nintendo Switch if

Casual gamers, families, Nintendo franchise fans, and those who value portability

PlayStation 5

Choose PlayStation 5 if

👑 Best pick

Hardcore gamers, those seeking premium graphics, PlayStation exclusive fans, and competitive online players

Track this comparison

Get notified when prices change, new specs ship, or our verdict updates.

Triggers: price change new spec verdict update

No spam. Stop anytime.

Key Differences at a Glance

🔹
Form Factor:Nintendo Switch wins(Hybrid (Portable + Docked) vs Home Console Only)
🔹
Total Units Sold:Nintendo Switch wins(153.10 million vs 90.20 million)
🔹
GPU Teraflops:PlayStation 5 wins(10.28 TFLOPS vs ~1.02 TFLOPS)
See all 8 differences

Key Facts & Figures

117 numeric metrics compared

MetricNintendo SwitchPlayStation 5Ratio
Display Size(inches)7.9 inches
Refresh Rate(Hz)120Hz
GPU Performance(TFLOPS)4 TFLOPS10.28 TFLOPS
-61%
RAM(GB)12GB LPDDR5
Storage Capacity(TB)64GB internal825 GB usable
-92%
Weight(lbs)570g
Battery Life (Normal Use)(hours)6.5-9 hours
Available Games(count)800+ exclusive Nintendo titles
Base Price (USD)(dollars)$299
Global Units Sold (as of 2026)(millions)153.1090.20
+70%
GPU Performance(teraflops)~1.0210.28
-90%
Storage Capacity(GB)64825
-92%
Software Sales Volume(billions of units)1.416Not disclosed
Launch Price (Standard)(USD)$299$499
-40%
Digital Purchase Rate(%)63Estimated 70+
CPU Cores(cores)4 cores (ARM-based)8 cores @ 3.5 GHz
-50%
RAM Capacity(GB)4GB16GB
-75%
Internal Storage(GB)32GB825 GB SSD
-96%
Average Load Time (tested games)(seconds)15-30 seconds5-10 seconds
+200%
Display Size(inches)6.2
Internal Storage(GB)32
Launch Price (USD)($)299
Weight(grams)298
Available Color Options3
GPU Processing Power(TFLOPS)10.3 TFLOPS
Maximum Refresh Rate (Supported)(fps)60 fps
Lifetime Unit Sales (as of 2026)(millions)139+ million
Game Pass Library Size(titles)~100 Game Pass titles~200 titles (PS Plus Extra/Premium)
-50%
MSRP at Launch (2020)(USD)$299
CPU Core Count(cores)4 cores (custom ARM)
Display Size (Handheld Mode)(inches)6.2 inches
GPU Performance Increase(percent faster)Baseline (Maxwell architecture)
Handheld Battery Life(hours)6.5 hours average
Launch Price (MSRP)(USD)$299$499
-40%
Available Game Library(titles)6,500+ games (as of 2025)
Handheld Unit Weight(grams)398g (original model)
SSD Read Speed(MB/s)825 MB/s825 MB/s
Market Share (January 2026)(percent)72.5%72.5%
Game Pass Ultimate Monthly Cost(USD/month)£15/month (PS Plus Extra/Premium)£15/month (PS Plus Extra/Premium)
Available SKUs(count)3 (Standard, Digital, Slim)3 (Standard, Digital, Slim)
Year-over-Year Market Share Change(percentage points)+2.9%+2.9%
Backward Compatibility Rate(%)~95% PS4 compatible~95% PS4 compatible
Annual Subscription Cost (Premium Tier)(USD)$120/year (PS Plus Premium)$120/year (PS Plus Premium)
Exclusive AAA Titles (2024-2026)(count)12+ major exclusives12+ major exclusives
Standard Console Launch Price (MSRP 2026)(USD)$499 (PS5 Standard)$499 (PS5 Standard)
Game Pass Subscription Games(titles)400+ games (PS Plus Extra)400+ games (PS Plus Extra)
Global Sales (2026)(millions)40 million units40 million units
Global Units Sold (64 months)(millions)91.04 million91.04 million
Market Share Percentage(%)72.6%72.6%
Maximum Native 4K Gaming FPS(fps)60-120 fps (PS5 Pro exceeds)60-120 fps (PS5 Pro exceeds)
Backward Compatible Games(estimated titles)200+ compatible titles200+ compatible titles
Storage Expansion Cost(USD per 1TB)$230$230
Game Pass Monthly Cost(USD)PlayStation Plus: $9.99-$17.99PlayStation Plus: $9.99-$17.99
GPU Power(TFLOPS)10.28 TFLOPS10.28 TFLOPS
Backward Compatibility Generations(generations)2 generations2 generations
Native 4K Performance Target(FPS)60 FPS standard, up to 120 FPS60 FPS standard, up to 120 FPS
SSD Storage Speed(GB/s)5.5 GB/s5.5 GB/s
2026 Exclusive Titles Available(games)18 major exclusives18 major exclusives
Market Share 2026(%)72.5%72.5%
Game Pass Value (Monthly Cost)(USD)$9.99/month (PlayStation Plus Essential)$9.99/month (PlayStation Plus Essential)
Digital Console Price (USD)(USD)$599.99$599.99
SSD Transfer Speed(GB/s)825 GB/s825 GB/s
RAM Memory(MB)16GB GDDR616GB GDDR6
Game Pass/Plus Library Size(titles)750+ titles (PlayStation Plus tiers)750+ titles (PlayStation Plus tiers)
Year-over-Year Sales Growth(%)+2.9%+2.9%
GPU Performance Advantage(percent)BaselineBaseline
CPU Performance Advantage(%)BaselineBaseline
SSD Load Time Advantage(percent)30% faster custom SSD30% faster custom SSD
Launch Price (2026 MSRP)(USD)$499$499
Years of Optimization(years)6 years of custom optimization6 years of custom optimization
Base Model Price (USD)(USD)$499$499
Launch MSRP (2026)(USD)$499$499
Exclusive Game Optimization Maturity(years)6 years of proven optimization techniques6 years of proven optimization techniques
CPU Speed(GHz)3.5 GHz variable3.5 GHz variable
Standard Edition Price (USD, 2026)(USD)$649.99$649.99
Digital Edition Price (USD, 2026)(USD)$599.99$599.99
Global Market Share(percent)72.5%72.5%
Standard Price (USD)($)599.99599.99
Standard Price (GBP)(£)519.99519.99
GPU Compute Units(units)3636
Exclusive Franchises (as of 2026)(count)20+20+
SSD Speed (Raw)(GB/s)5.5 GB/s (custom optimized)5.5 GB/s (custom optimized)
Backwards Compatible Games(titles)40 PS4 titles40 PS4 titles
Game Pass Day-1 Titles (Annual)(games)15-20 PS Plus tier15-20 PS Plus tier
Native 4K Maximum Frame Rate(fps)120 fps (capable)120 fps (capable)
Sales Performance (Month 9)(units)Behind by 6.39MBehind by 6.39M
Display Refresh Rate (Max)(Hz)120Hz at 4K120Hz at 4K
VRAM (Estimated)(GB)16GB GDDR616GB GDDR6
RAM Total(GB)16GB GDDR616GB GDDR6
Retail Price (2026)(USD)$499-$549$499-$549
Market Share(percent)72.5%72.5%
Physical Size Reduction vs PS5(percent smaller)Baseline (100%)Baseline (100%)
Standard Storage(GB)825GB usable825GB usable
Max 4K Gaming(fps)120fps (PS5 Pro)120fps (PS5 Pro)
Base Console Price (2026)(USD)$499.99$499.99
Storage Read Speed(GB/s)5,500 MB/s5,500 MB/s
Standard Storage Capacity(GB)825 GB825 GB
RAM (Total)(GB)16 GB GDDR616 GB GDDR6
Base Model MSRP (2026)(USD)$499$499
Maximum Native 4K Resolution(fps)120 fps120 fps
Exclusive Games Available (2026)(titles)40+ exclusives40+ exclusives
Maximum Framerate(fps)120 fps at 4K120 fps at 4K
Game Library Access(titles)~2,000 PS5 optimized~2,000 PS5 optimized
Launch Price (2026)(USD)$499$499
Game Library Size(titles)~500 PS5-exclusive/optimized~500 PS5-exclusive/optimized
Entry-Level Cost(USD)$499$499
Average Game Price Discount(% off)5-15% typical5-15% typical
Online Multiplayer Subscription(USD/year)$80 (PlayStation Plus Extra)$80 (PlayStation Plus Extra)
Setup Time(minutes)5 minutes (unbox, connect, play)5 minutes (unbox, connect, play)
Cross-Platform Play Support(% of multiplayer games)~15% of multiplayer titles~15% of multiplayer titles
Base Purchase Price(USD)$499$499
Native 4K Gaming Performance(FPS)60 FPS60 FPS
Available Game Titles(games)500+ AAA titles500+ AAA titles
Online Multiplayer Cost(USD/year)$70/year (PlayStation Plus)$70/year (PlayStation Plus)
GPU Memory (VRAM)(GB)10 GB (unified architecture)10 GB (unified architecture)
Setup Time to First Game(minutes)30 minutes30 minutes
Exclusive AAA Franchises(franchises)40+ (God of War, Spider-Man, Horizon)40+ (God of War, Spider-Man, Horizon)

Sourced from publicly available data · Jun 2026

Key Differences

8 attributes compared head-to-head

Nintendo Switch
3Nintendo Switch
Nintendo Switch leads3 ties
PlayStation 5
2PlayStation 5
38%25%
  • Form Factor

    Nintendo Switch

    Hybrid (Portable + Docked)🏆

    PlayStation 5

    Home Console Only

  • Total Units Sold

    Nintendo Switch

    153.10 million🏆

    PlayStation 5

    90.20 million

  • GPU Teraflops

    Nintendo Switch

    ~1.02 TFLOPS

    PlayStation 5

    10.28 TFLOPS🏆

  • Launch Year

    Nintendo Switch

    2017

    PlayStation 5

    2020

  • Price Point (Launch)

    Nintendo Switch

    $299-349🏆

    PlayStation 5

    $499

  • Exclusive Game Library

    Nintendo Switch

    Mario, Zelda, Pokemon

    PlayStation 5

    God of War, Spider-Man, Gran Turismo

  • Storage Capacity

    Nintendo Switch

    32GB-64GB

    PlayStation 5

    825GB SSD🏆

  • Market Positioning

    Nintendo Switch

    Mass Market Appeal

    PlayStation 5

    Hardcore/Performance Gamers

Full Comparison

Nintendo Switch
PlayStation 5
Display Size(inches)
7.9 inches
Display Resolution(pixels)
4K HDR capable
Refresh Rate(Hz)
120Hz
Native Resolution (Docked)(pixels)
1080p
4K (2160p)
Maximum Docked Resolution(pixels)
1920×1080 (1080p)
Show 4 more attributes
Native Gaming Resolution Target
4K/1080p
Display Refresh Rate (Max)(Hz)
120Hz at 4K
Native Resolution Target(pixels)
3840x2160 (4K)
Maximum Resolution (Docked/TV Mode)(pixels)
4K (3840x2160)
GPU Performance(TFLOPS)
4 TFLOPS
10.28 TFLOPS
RAM Capacity(GB)
4GB
16GB
GPU Processing Power(TFLOPS)
10.3 TFLOPS
RAM(GB)
12GB LPDDR5
Storage Capacity(TB)
64GB internal
825 GB usable
Internal Storage(GB)
32GB
825 GB SSD
SSD Technology(Generation)
Custom ultra-fast SSD (faster)
SSD Speed (Raw)(GB/s)
5.5 GB/s (custom optimized)
Standard Storage(GB)
825GB usable
Show 1 more attribute
Standard Storage Capacity(GB)
825 GB
Weight(lbs)
570g
Battery Life (Normal Use)(hours)
6.5-9 hours
Handheld Gaming Capability
Yes, native handheld mode
Handheld Unit Weight(grams)
398g (original model)
Available Games(count)
800+ exclusive Nintendo titles
Game Pass Library Size(titles)
~100 Game Pass titles
~200 titles (PS Plus Extra/Premium)
Processor
Custom ARM-based SoC
GPU Performance(teraflops)
~1.02
10.28
Average Load Time (tested games)(seconds)
15-30 seconds
5-10 seconds
Battery Life (Gaming)(hours)
4.5-9 hours
CPU Core Count(cores)
4 cores (custom ARM)
Show 13 more attributes
SSD Read Speed(MB/s)
825 MB/s
Maximum Native 4K Gaming FPS(fps)
60-120 fps (PS5 Pro exceeds)
GPU Power(TFLOPS)
10.28 TFLOPS
RAM Memory(MB)
16GB GDDR6
GPU Performance Advantage(percent)
Baseline
SSD Load Time Advantage(percent)
30% faster custom SSD
Native 4K Gaming Capability
Yes, 4K/60FPS capable
GPU Compute Units(units)
36
UE5 Performance on Demanding Titles(stability)
Stable native 4K
Storage Read Speed(GB/s)
5,500 MB/s
Maximum Framerate(fps)
120 fps at 4K
Native Performance (Standard Mode)(resolution/fps)
4K/60fps or 1440p/120fps
Native 4K Gaming Performance(FPS)
60 FPS
Base Price (USD)(dollars)
$299
Launch Price (Standard)(USD)
$299
$499
MSRP at Launch (2020)(USD)
$299
Launch Price (MSRP)(USD)
$299
$499
Standard Console Launch Price (MSRP 2026)(USD)
$499 (PS5 Standard)
Show 4 more attributes
Digital Console Price (USD)(USD)
$599.99
Standard Edition Price (USD, 2026)(USD)
$649.99
Digital Edition Price (USD, 2026)(USD)
$599.99
Base Model MSRP (2026)(USD)
$499
Operating System(OS)
Proprietary Nintendo OS
Available Game Library(titles)
6,500+ games (as of 2025)
Backward Compatibility with Previous Gen(percent compatible)
N/A (original generation)
Global Units Sold (as of 2026)(millions)
153.10
90.20
Storage Capacity(GB)
64
825
Display Size(inches)
6.2
Display Type
LCD
Internal Storage(GB)
32
SSD Storage Speed(GB/s)
5.5 GB/s
Show 2 more attributes
CPU Speed(GHz)
3.5 GHz variable
RAM Total(GB)
16GB GDDR6
Software Sales Volume(billions of units)
1.416
Not disclosed
Portability
Fully Portable
Home Console Only
Controller Haptic Technology(specification)
Advanced haptic feedback + adaptive triggers
Backward Compatibility(scope)
Limited
Backward Compatibility Support
Good (PS4/PS3 select)
Cross-Platform Play Support(% of multiplayer games)
~15% of multiplayer titles
Digital Purchase Rate(%)
63
Estimated 70+
Exclusive Game Franchises
Mario, Zelda, Pokemon, Animal Crossing
God of War, Spider-Man, Gran Turismo, Returnal
CPU Cores(cores)
4 cores (ARM-based)
8 cores @ 3.5 GHz
Portability(weight)
Yes (7-inch screen, detachable controllers)
No (requires TV and power outlet)
Launch Price (USD)($)
299
Launch Price (2026 MSRP)(USD)
$499
Base Model Price (USD)(USD)
$499
Standard Price (USD)($)
599.99
Standard Price (GBP)(£)
519.99
Show 3 more attributes
Launch Price (2026)(USD)
$499
Entry-Level Cost(USD)
$499
Average Game Price Discount(% off)
5-15% typical
Weight(grams)
298
Available Color Options
3
Physical Size Reduction vs PS5(percent smaller)
Baseline (100%)
Game Compatibility(titles)
2000+
Backward Compatibility Generations(generations)
2 generations
2026 Exclusive Titles Available(games)
18 major exclusives
Backward Compatibility Support(text)
Limited PS4 backward compatibility
Backwards Compatible Games(titles)
40 PS4 titles
Show 1 more attribute
Available Game Titles(games)
500+ AAA titles
Native Resolution (Docked/Primary)(pixels)
1440p standard
Maximum Refresh Rate (Supported)(fps)
60 fps
Maximum Resolution(pixels)
4K (2160p) at 120fps
Native 4K Gaming Support
Native 4K capable
Max 4K Gaming(fps)
120fps (PS5 Pro)
Lifetime Unit Sales (as of 2026)(millions)
139+ million
Market Share (January 2026)(percent)
72.5%
Year-over-Year Market Share Change(percentage points)
+2.9%
Global Units Sold (64 months)(millions)
91.04 million
Market Share Percentage(%)
72.6%
Show 1 more attribute
Sales Performance (Month 9)(units)
Behind by 6.39M
Display Size (Handheld Mode)(inches)
6.2 inches
GPU Performance Increase(percent faster)
Baseline (Maxwell architecture)
SSD Transfer Speed(GB/s)
825 GB/s
Handheld Display Size(inches)
None (stationary)
VRAM (Estimated)(GB)
16GB GDDR6
Handheld Battery Life(hours)
6.5 hours average
Game Pass Ultimate Monthly Cost(USD/month)
£15/month (PS Plus Extra/Premium)
Storage Expansion Cost(USD per 1TB)
$230
Launch MSRP (2026)(USD)
$499
Retail Price (2026)(USD)
$499-$549
Noise Level Rating(classification)
Standard noise levels
Available SKUs(count)
3 (Standard, Digital, Slim)
Backward Compatibility Rate(%)
~95% PS4 compatible
Annual Subscription Cost (Premium Tier)(USD)
$120/year (PS Plus Premium)
Exclusive AAA Titles (2024-2026)(count)
12+ major exclusives
Exclusive AAA Games (2026)(major releases)
Horizon: Zenith Chronicles, Ghost of Tsushima: Revelations, Marvel titles
Backward Compatible Games(estimated titles)
200+ compatible titles
Exclusive Games Available (2026)(titles)
40+ exclusives
Game Pass Included Games(titles)
Limited (PlayStation Plus Extra tier)
Upcoming Performance Enhancement(text)
PSSR2 AI upscaling (2026, free)
Game Pass Subscription Games(titles)
400+ games (PS Plus Extra)
Game Pass Day-1 Titles (Annual)(games)
15-20 PS Plus tier
Game Pass Integration(feature)
PlayStation Plus Extra/Premium
Online Multiplayer Subscription(USD/year)
$80 (PlayStation Plus Extra)
Global Sales (2026)(millions)
40 million units
Market Share 2026(%)
72.5%
Backwards Compatibility Range(generations)
2-3 generations (PS2-PS4 selective)
Backwards Compatible Generations(generations)
Select PS4 titles only (1 generation)
Game Pass Monthly Cost(USD)
PlayStation Plus: $9.99-$17.99
Maximum Resolution & Frame Rate(pixels & fps)
4K @ 120fps
2025-2026 AAA Exclusive Titles(games)
6-8 major titles
Game Library Access(titles)
~2,000 PS5 optimized
Game Library Size(titles)
~500 PS5-exclusive/optimized
Exclusive AAA Franchises(franchises)
40+ (God of War, Spider-Man, Horizon)
Maximum Resolution Output(pixels)
4K (3840×2160)
Native 4K Performance Target(FPS)
60 FPS standard, up to 120 FPS
Multi-Platform Game Performance Edge(consistency)
Closes gap through optimization
Native 4K Maximum Frame Rate(fps)
120 fps (capable)
Maximum Native 4K Resolution(fps)
120 fps
Ray Tracing Support
Hardware-accelerated, full support
Game Pass Value (Monthly Cost)(USD)
$9.99/month (PlayStation Plus Essential)
Game Pass/Plus Library Size(titles)
750+ titles (PlayStation Plus tiers)
Year-over-Year Sales Growth(%)
+2.9%
CPU Performance Advantage(%)
Baseline
Years of Optimization(years)
6 years of custom optimization
SSD Speed Advantage(relative)
Custom SSD (faster)
Exclusive Game Optimization Maturity(years)
6 years of proven optimization techniques
Global Market Share(percent)
72.5%
Market Share(percent)
72.5%
Exclusive Franchises (as of 2026)(count)
20+
HDR Support
Yes
3D Audio Technology
Precision 3D Audio (evolved)
Haptic Feedback
Advanced adaptive triggers
Base Console Price (2026)(USD)
$499.99
Base Purchase Price(USD)
$499
Online Multiplayer Cost(USD/year)
$70/year (PlayStation Plus)
Space Marine 2 Performance(comparative)
Slightly lower frame consistency
Controller Haptic Feedback(feature)
Yes - DualSense haptic triggers
RAM (Total)(GB)
16 GB GDDR6
Setup Time(minutes)
5 minutes (unbox, connect, play)
GPU Memory (VRAM)(GB)
10 GB (unified architecture)
Setup Time to First Game(minutes)
30 minutes

Visual Comparison

Side-by-side comparison of numeric attributes

Pros & Cons

12 pros·9 cons across both

Nintendo Switch
PlayStation 5
Nintendo Switch

Nintendo Switch

+6-4
60% positive

Pros

  • Hybrid portability - play anywhere
  • Most games ever sold on a single platform (1.416 billion software units)
  • Affordable entry price point
  • Nintendo's iconic exclusive franchises
  • Extended battery life models available
  • Third-best-selling console of all time

Cons

  • Significantly lower graphical performance
  • Limited online features compared to PS5
  • Smaller storage capacity
  • Aging hardware by 2026 standards
PlayStation 5

PlayStation 5

+6-5
55% positive

Pros

  • Powerful GPU delivering 10.28 teraflops
  • Ultra-fast SSD with near-instant loading times
  • World-class exclusive franchises (God of War, Spider-Man)
  • Innovative DualSense controller haptics
  • Robust online multiplayer infrastructure
  • PS5 Pro variant for enhanced performance

Cons

  • Expensive upfront cost ($499+)
  • No portability - home console only
  • Requires internet for many features
  • Limited backwards compatibility
  • Smaller total unit sales than Switch

Frequently Asked Questions

5 questions

  1. The Nintendo Switch is the clear winner for portable gaming, as it's specifically designed as a hybrid console that can be played handheld, tabletop, or docked. The PS5 is exclusively a home console and cannot be played portably.

  2. Yes. The PS5's GPU delivers 10.28 teraflops compared to the Switch's ~1.02 teraflops, providing roughly 10x more raw graphical power. This results in substantially higher resolution, frame rates, and visual fidelity on PS5 titles, though Switch games prioritize art style and gameplay innovation.

  3. The Switch's portability, lower price point ($299 vs $499), family-friendly game library, and seven-year head start on the PS5 contributed to higher overall sales. By 2026, the Switch had sold 153.10 million units compared to PS5's 90.20 million units, making it the third best-selling console of all time.

  4. Both consoles have exceptional exclusives that appeal to different audiences. Nintendo dominates with franchises like Mario, Zelda, and Pokemon, while PlayStation excels with story-driven AAA titles like God of War: Ragnarok and Spider-Man. Your preference depends on gaming taste rather than objective quality.

  5. Nintendo forecasts 15 million Switch 2 units and 45 million software units sold by March 31, 2026. While the Switch 2 will offer improved hardware, it will likely remain positioned as a hybrid console prioritizing portability rather than direct raw-power competition with the PS5's performance-focused approach.

Related Comparisons

Related Articles

5 articles

Explore More

Related comparisons and categories

Last updated: April 25, 2026AI generated