Five Guys vs In-N-Out 2026: Price, Menu & Quality
Five Guys charges significantly higher prices ($15-18 per burger) with customizable toppings and fresh-cut fries, while In-N-Out offers lower prices ($3-5 per burger) with a limited menu and cult-like efficiency. Five Guys operates in 45+ states and UK, while In-N-Out remains regional to the West Coast with 400 locations.
Five Guys Burgers and Fries
Premium customizable burger chain with fresh-cut fries and expanding global presence
Customers seeking customizable gourmet burgers, anyone willing to pay premium prices for quality ingredients, people in most U.S. states seeking regional burger chains
In-N-Out Burger
Iconic West Coast fast-casual chain known for simplicity, speed, and exceptional value pricing
West Coast residents seeking value and consistency, families on budget, speed-conscious customers, nostalgia seekers, anyone prioritizing simplicity over customization
Quick Answer
AI SummaryFive Guys charges significantly higher prices ($15-18 per burger) with customizable toppings and fresh-cut fries, while In-N-Out offers lower prices ($3-5 per burger) with a limited menu and cult-like efficiency. Five Guys operates in 45+ states and UK, while In-N-Out remains regional to the West Coast with 400 locations.
Our Verdict
AI-assistedChoose Five Guys if you value customization, premium ingredients, and accessibility across most of the country with gourmet burger experience. Choose In-N-Out if you prioritize exceptional value, fast service, regional exclusivity appeal, and simplicity with proven cult following that has maintained quality over 75 years.
Was this verdict helpful?
Choose Five Guys Burgers and Fries if
Customers seeking customizable gourmet burgers, anyone willing to pay premium prices for quality ingredients, people in most U.S. states seeking regional burger chains
Choose In-N-Out Burger if
Best pickWest Coast residents seeking value and consistency, families on budget, speed-conscious customers, nostalgia seekers, anyone prioritizing simplicity over customization
Track this comparison
Get notified when prices change, new specs ship, or our verdict updates.
Triggers: price change new spec verdict update
No spam. Stop anytime.
Key Differences at a Glance
- Average Burger Price:✓ In-N-Out Burger wins($3.99 vs $15.49)
- Menu Items:✓ Five Guys Burgers and Fries wins(50+ customization options vs 5 main burger options)
- Geographic Presence:✓ Five Guys Burgers and Fries wins(45+ U.S. states + UK vs 7 West Coast states only)
Key Facts & Figures
8 numeric metrics compared
| Metric | Five Guys Burgers and Fries | In-N-Out Burger | Ratio |
|---|---|---|---|
| Single Cheeseburger Price(USD) | $15.49 | $3.99 | |
| Price Difference Multiple(x) | 3.9x more expensive | baseline | |
| Number of Menu Burger Options(options) | 50+ customizable combinations | 5 standard options | |
| Average Calories per Burger(kcal) | 563 calories | 390 calories | |
| Total Restaurant Locations(locations) | 1,500+ | 400 | |
| States of Operation(states) | 45+ U.S. states + international | 7 states | |
| Average Drive-Through Wait Time(minutes) | 12 minutes | 7 minutes | |
| Brand Age(years) | 24 years (founded 2002) | 75 years (founded 1948) |
Sourced from publicly available data ·
Key Differences
7 attributes compared head-to-head
- $15.49Average Burger Price$3.99(winner)
- 50+ customization options(winner)Menu Items5 main burger options
- 45+ U.S. states + UK(winner)Geographic Presence7 West Coast states only
- 1,500+ globally(winner)Number of Locations400 locations
- 563 caloriesCalorie Count (Single Burger)390 calories(winner)
- 10-15 minutesAverage Customer Wait Time5-10 minutes(winner)
- Fresh-cut daily in-storeFries Preparation MethodFresh-cut daily in-store
- Average Burger Price
Five Guys Burgers and Fries
$15.49
In-N-Out Burger
$3.99(winner)
- Menu Items
Five Guys Burgers and Fries
50+ customization options(winner)
In-N-Out Burger
5 main burger options
- Geographic Presence
Five Guys Burgers and Fries
45+ U.S. states + UK(winner)
In-N-Out Burger
7 West Coast states only
- Number of Locations
Five Guys Burgers and Fries
1,500+ globally(winner)
In-N-Out Burger
400 locations
- Calorie Count (Single Burger)
Five Guys Burgers and Fries
563 calories
In-N-Out Burger
390 calories(winner)
- Average Customer Wait Time
Five Guys Burgers and Fries
10-15 minutes
In-N-Out Burger
5-10 minutes(winner)
- Fries Preparation Method
Five Guys Burgers and Fries
Fresh-cut daily in-store
In-N-Out Burger
Fresh-cut daily in-store
Full Comparison
| Attribute | Five Guys Burgers and Fries | In-N-Out Burger |
|---|---|---|
| Single Cheeseburger Price(USD) | $15.49 | $3.99(winner) |
| Price Difference Multiple(x) | 3.9x more expensive | baseline(winner) |
| Number of Menu Burger Options(options) | 50+ customizable combinations(winner) | 5 standard options |
| Average Calories per Burger(kcal) | 563 calories | 390 calories(winner) |
| Total Restaurant Locations(locations) | 1,500+(winner) | 400 |
| States of Operation(states) | 45+ U.S. states + international(winner) | 7 states |
| Average Drive-Through Wait Time(minutes) | 12 minutes | 7 minutes(winner) |
| Brand Age(years) | 24 years (founded 2002) | 75 years (founded 1948)(winner) |
Five Guys Burgers and FriesIn-N-Out BurgerPros & Cons
10 pros·6 cons across both
Five Guys Burgers and Fries
Pros
- Unlimited free toppings (lettuce, tomato, onion, pickles, mushrooms, jalapeños, etc.)
- Fresh-cut fries made from potatoes received daily
- High-quality beef with no freezers (never frozen)
- Extensive national and international expansion (1,500+ locations)
- Customizable portions and burger styles (regular, little, Cajun seasoning)
Cons
- Significantly higher prices ($15-18 per burger compared to $3-4 competitors)
- Inconsistent quality across franchises depending on management
- Longer wait times during peak hours (10-15 minutes average)
In-N-Out Burger
Pros
- Unmatched value pricing: Single burger $3.99, Double $4.99 (unchanged for 25+ years)
- Fastest service in segment (5-10 minute average wait time)
- Limited menu ensures consistency and operational excellence across all 400 locations
- Fresh beef delivered daily, never frozen, consistent 75-year track record
- Cult-like brand loyalty with secret menu items creating community engagement
Cons
- Geographic limitation to California, Nevada, Texas, Utah, Arizona, Colorado, Oregon only
- Minimal customization options (no toppings beyond standard offerings)
- Lower calorie count may indicate smaller portion sizes (390 calories vs 563)
Frequently Asked Questions
5 questions
In-N-Out offers dramatically better value with a cheeseburger at $3.99 vs Five Guys at $15.49 (3.9x cheaper). In-N-Out maintains these prices through limited menu focus and operational efficiency, while Five Guys charges premium prices for customization and gourmet ingredients. For budget-conscious customers, In-N-Out is unmatched.
Resources & Learn More
Curated sources to dive deeper
Where to Buy
As an affiliate, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you. Learn more about our affiliate disclosure
Wikipedia
Related Comparisons
12 more to explore
Subway vs Jimmy John's
food_and_drinkKFC vs Popeyes Louisiana Kitchen
food_and_drinkCoca-Cola vs LaCroix
food_and_drinkPepsi vs Mountain Dew
food_and_drinkBurger King vs Five Guys
food_and_drinkChick-fil-A vs McDonald's
food_and_drinkMcDonald's vs Wendy's
food_and_drinkBurger King vs Wendy's
food_and_drinkHelloFresh vs Home Chef
food_and_drinkFactor vs HelloFresh
food_and_drinkStarbucks vs Peet's Coffee
food_and_drinkStarbucks vs Dutch Bros
food_and_drink
Explore More
Related comparisons and categories