Skip to main content

Open Source Software vs Proprietary Software

A Versus B

Open source software uses a license that meets the Open Source Initiative's 10-point Open Source Definition: it must include source code, allow modifications and derived works, allow free redistribution without royalties, and not discriminate against people or fields of use. Proprietary software, which the GNU Project also calls nonfree, withholds one or more of those freedoms, usually keeping source code private and limiting copying or changes. Open source can still be sold or used commercially. Choose by control, support and total cost.

Open Source Software

Software whose license meets the Open Source Definition: source code, modification and redistribution allowed.

Teams that want to inspect, modify or self-host

Score60%
VS

Proprietary Software

Software whose license withholds one or more of these freedoms.

Organisations that want a vendor-backed product

Score60%
4 attributes4 differences10 pros/cons
TL;DRVoice-ready

Open source software uses a license that meets the Open Source Initiative's 10-point Open Source Definition: it must include source code, allow modifications and derived works, allow free redistribution without royalties, and not discriminate against people or fields of use. Proprietary software, which the GNU Project also calls nonfree, withholds one or more of those freedoms, usually keeping source code private and limiting copying or changes. Open source can still be sold or used commercially. Choose by control, support and total cost.

Deciding factor: Open source for control, auditability and self-hosting; proprietary for a single vendor-backed product.

Key fact: The Open Source Definition has 10 criteria, including source code access and royalty-free redistribution.

Our Verdict

AI-assisted

Open source: license meets the 10-point Open Source Definition; source available, changes and redistribution allowed. Proprietary: license restricts one or more of those freedoms. Read each license before you build on it.

O

Choose Open Source Software if

Teams that want to inspect, modify or self-host

P

Choose Proprietary Software if

Organisations that want a vendor-backed product

Share this verdict

Get notified when Open Source Software vs Proprietary Software changes

One email when prices, specs or our verdict on Open Source Software vs Proprietary Software change. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.

Key Differences at a Glance

  • Source code:Included or freely available vs Usually private
  • Modification:Allowed vs Restricted
  • Redistribution:Allowed without royalty vs Restricted by license
See all 4 differences

Key Differences

4 attributes compared head-to-head

OS
0Open Source Software
Evenly matched4 ties
PS
0Proprietary Software
  • Source code

    Open Source Software

    Included or freely available

    Proprietary Software

    Usually private

  • Modification

    Open Source Software

    Allowed

    Proprietary Software

    Restricted

  • Redistribution

    Open Source Software

    Allowed without royalty

    Proprietary Software

    Restricted by license

  • Commercial use

    Open Source Software

    Allowed

    Proprietary Software

    Set by vendor

Full Comparison

OOpen Source Software
PProprietary Software
Defined by
Open Source Definition (10 criteria)
Any license that withholds these freedoms
Field-of-use restrictions
Not allowed
Common
Self-hosting
Possible
Depends on vendor
Also called
Free software (most programs)
Nonfree software

Pros & Cons

6 pros·4 cons across both

OS
PS
OS

Open Source Software

+3-2

Pros

Source code included or freely available
Modifications and derived works allowed
No royalty for redistribution

Cons

Support may come from the community or paid vendors
Some licenses require sharing changes under the same terms
PS

Proprietary Software

+3-2

Pros

Single vendor responsible for the product
Often bundled with support and hosting
Clear commercial terms

Cons

Source code usually not available
Use, modification or redistribution restricted by the license

Frequently Asked Questions

6 questions

  1. Open source licenses allow anyone to get the source code, modify it and redistribute it. Proprietary licenses restrict one or more of those rights, and the source code is usually private.

  2. Often, but not always. The Open Source Definition bars royalties on redistribution, and open source software can still be sold or offered with paid support.

  3. Yes. Licenses meeting the Open Source Definition cannot restrict fields of use, including business.

  4. A set of 10 criteria from the Open Source Initiative, covering free redistribution, source code, derived works, integrity of source, non-discrimination and technology-neutral licensing.

  5. They are defined differently. The GNU Project defines free software by four essential freedoms; nearly all open source programs also qualify as free software.

  1. Not by definition. Open source code can be audited by anyone; proprietary security depends on the vendor. Evaluate each product's update and disclosure practices.

Analysis: Open Source Software vs Proprietary Software

Open source software uses a license that meets the Open Source Initiative's 10-point Open Source Definition: it must include source code, allow modifications and derived works, allow free redistribution without royalties, and not discriminate against people or fields of use. Proprietary software, which the GNU Project also calls nonfree, withholds one or more of those freedoms, usually keeping source code private and limiting copying or changes. Open source can still be sold or used commercially. Choose by control, support and total cost.

Key takeaways

- Open source licenses must meet the 10 criteria of the Open Source Definition. - Source code must be included or available, and modifications must be allowed. - Redistribution cannot require a royalty or fee. - Proprietary licenses restrict use, study, modification or redistribution. - Open source and free software can be commercial.

Read 8 more paragraphs

What makes software open source

The Open Source Definition sets 10 criteria, including free redistribution, source code, derived works, integrity of the author's source code, no discrimination against persons, groups or fields of endeavour, and technology-neutral licenses. The GNU Project defines free software by four essential freedoms: to run, study and change, redistribute, and distribute modified copies.

Proprietary software

A program that does not give users these freedoms is called nonfree or proprietary. The vendor typically keeps the source code private and sets the terms for installing, copying and modifying it.

Practical trade-offs

1. Open source: inspect and modify the code, self-host, switch vendors; support comes from the community or paid providers. 2. Proprietary: one accountable vendor, bundled support and hosting; less control over the code. 3. Licenses vary: some open source licenses require sharing changes under the same terms.

Who should pick which

Pick open source when you need control, auditability or self-hosting. Pick proprietary when a vendor-backed product with support fits better. MySQL vs PostgreSQL compares two open source databases.

Drafted with AI from web research. How we research
Community feedback

Was this verdict helpful?

Explore More

Related comparisons and categories

Explore Entities

  • Open Source Software
  • Proprietary Software
Last updated

Debate this on r/ThisOrThatDebate (run by the AversusB team)