Skip to main content
software

NordVPN vs PIA 2026: Speed vs Privacy

NordVPN offers faster speeds (average 920 Mbps) and broader server coverage (6,400+ servers in 111 countries), while Private Internet Access provides stronger privacy through RAM-only servers and lower pricing at $2.03/month. NordVPN excels for streaming and general browsing, whereas PIA suits privacy-focused users on tight budgets.

NordVPN

NordVPN

Premium VPN service with 6,400+ servers optimized for speed and streaming.

Streaming enthusiasts, international travelers, and users prioritizing speed over extreme privacy

Score71%
VS
PI

Private Internet Access (PIA)

Budget-friendly VPN with advanced privacy features and RAM-only server infrastructure.

Privacy-conscious users, budget-limited customers, and those requiring 10+ simultaneous connections

Score63%

Quick Answer

AI Summary

NordVPN offers faster speeds (average 920 Mbps) and broader server coverage (6,400+ servers in 111 countries), while Private Internet Access provides stronger privacy through RAM-only servers and lower pricing at $2.03/month. NordVPN excels for streaming and general browsing, whereas PIA suits privacy-focused users on tight budgets.

Our Verdict

AI-assisted

Choose NordVPN if you prioritize streaming quality, global server diversity, and consistent fast speeds—it's best for accessing international content and general daily use. Choose Private Internet Access if maximum privacy is your concern, you need 10+ simultaneous connections, or you're budget-conscious and willing to trade some streaming capability for stronger no-logs architecture and RAM-only infrastructure.

Community feedback

Was this verdict helpful?

NordVPN
6.7/10
Private Internet Access (PIA)
8.3/10
P
NordVPN

Choose NordVPN if

Streaming enthusiasts, international travelers, and users prioritizing speed over extreme privacy

P

Choose Private Internet Access (PIA) if

Best pick

Privacy-conscious users, budget-limited customers, and those requiring 10+ simultaneous connections

Track this comparison

Get notified when prices change, new specs ship, or our verdict updates.

Triggers: price change new spec verdict update

No spam. Stop anytime.

Key Differences at a Glance

  • Monthly Subscription Cost:Private Internet Access (PIA) wins($2.03/month (3-year plan) vs $3.99/month (2-year plan))
  • Global Server Count:NordVPN wins(6,400+ servers in 111 countries vs 29,650+ servers in 84 countries)
  • Average Download Speed:NordVPN wins(920 Mbps on 1 Gbps connection vs 780 Mbps on 1 Gbps connection)
See all 7 differences

Key Facts & Figures

102 numeric metrics compared

MetricNordVPNPrivate Internet Access (PIA)Ratio
Peak Download Speed(Mbps)950+ Mbps
Server Locations(countries)111 countries91 countries
Speed Retention Rate(%)92%
Streaming Service Compatibility(platforms)10+
Starting Monthly Price (2-year plan)(USD/month)$3.99
Download Speed Performance Impact(% decrease from baseline)5.20% decrease
Download Speed(Mbps)950 Mbps
Internet Speed Retention Rate(%)92%
Netflix Libraries Accessible(libraries)30+
Total Streaming Services Supported(services)10+
Global Server Count(servers)6,500+
Countries Covered(count)110+ countries
Annual Plan Price(USD)From $69/year
Basic Plan Monthly Cost(USD)$3.09
Server Count(servers)7,200+
Country Coverage(countries)110+
Annual Cost (Best Plan)(USD)$36+
Base Monthly Price (USD)(USD/month)$3.09
Annual Price (First Year)(USD/year)$83.43
Number of Servers(servers)7200+
Simultaneous Connections(devices)10+
Annual Subscription Cost (Best Plan)(USD)$69.99/year (2-year plan)
Devices Supported on Free Tier(devices)0 (Premium only)
Devices Supported on Premium(devices)6 simultaneous connections
Browser Extensions Available(count)7 major browser extensions
Annual Subscription Price(USD)$3.99/month$2.03/month
Total VPN Servers(servers)6,500+10,000+
Annual Subscription Cost(USD)$47.88/year$39.95/year
Maximum Simultaneous Connections(devices)6 devices10 devices
Countries with Presence(countries)111
Latest Security Audit Year2022 (PwC)
Global Server Count(servers)6,400+29,650+
Monthly Cost (Best Plan)(USD)$3.99/month
Monthly Subscription Cost (1-Year Plan)(USD)$3.99/month
Free Tier Monthly Data(GB)None
Average Download Speed (US Servers)(Mbps)580 Mbps
Monthly Price (Best Plan)(USD)$3.99/month
Annual Cost(USD)$47.88
Money-Back Guarantee(days)30 days30 days
Monthly Price (Annual Plan)(USD)$3.99
Total Server Count(servers)5,800+29,650 servers
Annual Plan Price(USD/month)$3.99/month$2.03/month
Global Server Network(servers)6,500+ servers
Money-Back Guarantee Period(days)30 days30 days
Monthly Price (Annual Commitment)(USD)$3.99/month$2.03
Server Count(servers)6,200+ servers35,000+
Server Countries(countries)111
Monthly Subscription Cost (Annual Plan)(USD)$3.99/month$2.03
Total VPN Servers Worldwide(servers)6,500+3,400+
Countries with Server Presence(countries)111 countries84 countries
No-Logs Audit Frequency(audits per year)Annual (PwC)Annual (Deloitte)
Average Download Speed Loss(%)8% slower (NordLynx/WireGuard)18% slower (OpenVPN)
Netflix Streaming Reliability(%)89% success rate (tested 13 regions)62% success rate (tested 13 regions)
Country Coverage(countries)111 countries84 countries
Average Download Speed(Mbps)920 Mbps780 Mbps
Netflix Unblocking Success Rate(percent)98%72%
Simultaneous Device Connections(devices)6 devices10
Customer Rating (Trustpilot)(out of 5.0)4.44.6
Annual Plan Cost (Per Month)(USD)$3.99/month$2.03/month
Number of Servers(servers)5,900+29,650+
Countries Covered(count)111 countries84
Monthly Plan Price(USD)$12.99$11.99/month
Average Connection Speed(Mbps)320 Mbps
Monthly Price (2-Year Plan)(USD)$3.49/month
Total Global Servers(servers)6,500+
Annual Price (1-Year Plan)(USD)$6.99/month
VPN Server Locations(countries)111 countries
Devices Supported Simultaneously(devices)6 simultaneous connections
Free Trial Duration(days)7 days
Monthly Subscription Cost (Best Rate)(USD)$3.99
Total VPN Server Count(servers)6,000
Countries Available(countries)111
Simultaneous Connections(devices)6 devices10 devices
Annual Cost (3-year vs 2-year plans)(USD)$47.88
Monthly Subscription Cost(USD)$11.99
Number of VPN Servers(servers)6,500+29,650+
Countries with Server Coverage(countries)11184
Average Download Speed (500Mbps connection)(Mbps)350
Kill Switch Response Time(milliseconds)200-500ms
Annual Price (Best Plan)(USD per month)$3.99/month
Download Speed (500 mi distance)(Mbps)580 Mbps
Global Server Network Size(servers)6,000+
Countries Served(countries)111
Monthly Subscription (Best Annual Rate)(USD)$3.99/month
Transparency Report Frequency(per year)Annual (1x/year)
Annual Cost (Lowest Available Plan)(USD)$47.88/year
Annual Plan Cost(USD/month)$3.99
Month-to-Month Cost(USD/month)$11.99
Monthly Subscription Price (Long-Term Plan)(USD)$3.99/month
Annual Cost (12-Month Commitment)(USD)$47.88/year
Monthly Subscription (Standard Plan)(USD)$3.99$2.03
Netflix Unblocking Success(%)71%71%
Speed Loss (Average)(percent)8-10%8-10%
Monthly Price (Best Annual Deal)(USD)$2.03/month$2.03/month
Countries with Servers(countries)84 countries84 countries
Average Speed Retention(%)85%85%
Netflix Streaming Compatibility(regions)8 regions8 regions
Annual Cost (3-Year Commitment)(USD)$72.76$72.76
Monthly Cost (Annual Subscription)(USD/month)$2.03/month$2.03/month
Average Download Speed (256-bit AES)(Mbps)300 Mbps300 Mbps
Independent Security Audits (Last 3 Years)(audits)2 (Cure53, VerSprite, 2020-2023)2 (Cure53, VerSprite, 2020-2023)
Simultaneous Connections Per Account(devices)10 devices10 devices

Sourced from publicly available data ·

Key Differences

7 attributes compared head-to-head

NordVPN
3NordVPN
Evenly matched1 tie
PI
3Private Internet Access (PIA)
  • Monthly Subscription Cost

    NordVPN

    $3.99/month (2-year plan)

    Private Internet Access (PIA)

    $2.03/month (3-year plan)(winner)

  • Global Server Count

    NordVPN

    6,400+ servers in 111 countries(winner)

    Private Internet Access (PIA)

    29,650+ servers in 84 countries

  • Average Download Speed

    NordVPN

    920 Mbps on 1 Gbps connection(winner)

    Private Internet Access (PIA)

    780 Mbps on 1 Gbps connection

  • Server Memory Architecture

    NordVPN

    SSD-based servers

    Private Internet Access (PIA)

    RAM-only servers (no data persistence)(winner)

  • Netflix Unblocking Success Rate

    NordVPN

    98% consistent access to global libraries(winner)

    Private Internet Access (PIA)

    72% success rate, frequent blocks

  • Simultaneous Connections

    NordVPN

    6 devices per account

    Private Internet Access (PIA)

    10 devices per account(winner)

  • Kill Switch Reliability

    NordVPN

    Automatic, configurable per app

    Private Internet Access (PIA)

    Automatic with granular DNS leak protection

Full Comparison

NordVPN
PPrivate Internet Access (PIA)
Peak Download Speed(Mbps)
950+ Mbps
Speed Retention Rate(%)
92%
Connection Speed Rating
Fastest
Download Speed Performance Impact(% decrease from baseline)
5.20% decrease
Download Speed(Mbps)
950 Mbps
Show 12 more attributes
Internet Speed Retention Rate(%)
92%
Connection Speed Performance
Faster globally
Average Download Speed(Mbps)
Fast (20-50 Mbps typical)
Average Download Speed (US Servers)(Mbps)
580 Mbps
Average Download Speed Loss(%)
8% slower (NordLynx/WireGuard)
18% slower (OpenVPN)
Average Download Speed(Mbps)
920 Mbps
780 Mbps
Average Connection Speed(Mbps)
320 Mbps
Average Download Speed (500Mbps connection)(Mbps)
350
Download Speed (500 mi distance)(Mbps)
580 Mbps
Speed Loss (Average)(percent)
8-10%
Average Speed Retention(%)
85%
Average Download Speed (256-bit AES)(Mbps)
300 Mbps
Server Locations(countries)
111 countries
91 countries
Number of Servers(servers)
7200+
Server Count(servers)
6,200+ servers
35,000+
Server Storage Type(text)
Mix of disk and RAM
Streaming Service Compatibility(platforms)
10+
Native Streaming Box Apps
Limited
Simultaneous Connections(devices)
10+
Maximum Simultaneous Connections(devices)
6 devices
10 devices
Simultaneous Device Connections(devices)
6 devices
10
Show 5 more attributes
Simultaneous Connections(devices)
6 devices
10 devices
Port Forwarding
Not available
Ad & Malware Blocker Included
Yes (MACE included)
Split Tunneling Support
Yes, full control
Simultaneous Connections Per Account(devices)
10 devices
VPN Protocols Offered
NordLynx, OpenVPN, IKEv2
Encryption Standards Offered(algorithms)
AES-256 (NordLynx)
Primary VPN Protocol
NordLynx (WireGuard-based)
Kill Switch Feature
Yes (Standard)
Encryption Standard
AES-256
Show 24 more attributes
Independent Security Audits
Yes, regular audits
Kill Switch Feature
Yes, on all platforms
Advanced Threat Protection
Yes - Threat Protection Pro
Kill Switch Availability
Yes (All Plans)
Yes (all platforms)
Independent Security Audit(year)
PwC audit 2024
Kill Switch Implementation
Yes, all platforms
Encryption Standard
AES-256
AES-256-GCM
Primary Encryption Standard
WireGuard with ChaCha20
No-Logs Audit Frequency(audits per year)
Annual (PwC)
Annual (Deloitte)
Server Memory Type
SSD-based
RAM-only
Supported Encryption Protocols(protocols)
OpenVPN, WireGuard, ChaCha20, NordLynx
Kill Switch / Leak Protection
Yes (Threat Protection included)
Recent Independent Security Audit
PwC (2024)
Cure53 (2023), Deloitte (2022)
Kill Switch Enabled by Default
Yes
Encryption Type
AES-256 Double VPN (dual layer)
No-Logs Certification
Yes (multiple 2022-2024)
Password Encryption Standard
IKEv2/IPSec or WireGuard
Kill Switch Protection
Yes, all platforms
Yes
Code Openness
Proprietary (audited)
Independent Security Audit (Latest)
Deloitte (2024)
Kill Switch Response Time(milliseconds)
200-500ms
Encryption Protocol
AES-256-GCM
Kill Switch (Auto Disconnect)
Yes, automatic
Independent Security Audits (Last 3 Years)(audits)
2 (Cure53, VerSprite, 2020-2023)
Starting Monthly Price (2-year plan)(USD/month)
$3.99
Free Plan Data Limit(GB/month)
None available
Annual Plan Price(USD)
From $69/year
Basic Plan Monthly Cost(USD)
$3.09
Annual Cost (Best Plan)(USD)
$36+
Show 31 more attributes
Base Monthly Price (USD)(USD/month)
$3.09
Annual Price (First Year)(USD/year)
$83.43
Annual Subscription Cost (Best Plan)(USD)
$69.99/year (2-year plan)
Annual Subscription Cost(USD)
$47.88/year
$39.95/year
Monthly Cost (Best Plan)(USD)
$3.99/month
Monthly Subscription Cost (1-Year Plan)(USD)
$3.99/month
Monthly Price (Best Plan)(USD)
$3.99/month
Annual Cost(USD)
$47.88
Monthly Price (Annual Plan)(USD)
$3.99
Annual Plan Price(USD/month)
$3.99/month
$2.03/month
Monthly Price (Annual Commitment)(USD)
$3.99/month
$2.03
Monthly Subscription Cost (Annual Plan)(USD)
$3.99/month
$2.03
Annual Plan Cost (Per Month)(USD)
$3.99/month
$2.03/month
Monthly Plan Price(USD)
$12.99
$11.99/month
Monthly Price (2-Year Plan)(USD)
$3.49/month
Annual Price (1-Year Plan)(USD)
$6.99/month
Monthly Subscription Cost (Best Rate)(USD)
$3.99
Annual Cost (3-year vs 2-year plans)(USD)
$47.88
Monthly Subscription Cost(USD)
$11.99
Annual Price (Best Plan)(USD per month)
$3.99/month
Monthly Subscription (Best Annual Rate)(USD)
$3.99/month
Annual Cost (Lowest Available Plan)(USD)
$47.88/year
Annual Plan Cost(USD/month)
$3.99
Month-to-Month Cost(USD/month)
$11.99
Monthly Subscription Price (Long-Term Plan)(USD)
$3.99/month
Annual Cost (12-Month Commitment)(USD)
$47.88/year
Monthly Subscription (Standard Plan)(USD)
$3.99
$2.03
Monthly Price (Best Annual Deal)(USD)
$2.03/month
Annual Cost (3-Year Commitment)(USD)
$72.76
Monthly Cost (Annual Subscription)(USD/month)
$2.03/month
Free Trial / Free Tier
No free tier (30-day money-back guarantee)
Logging Policy
Strict no-logs
Jurisdiction Privacy Rating
Excellent - Panama
No-Logs Policy
Verified no-logs
Payment Anonymity Options
Crypto, card, PayPal
No-Logging Audit Verification
Yes (PwC audit 2024)
Show 3 more attributes
No-Logs Policy Jurisdiction
Panama (outside 5/9/14-Eyes)
Log Retention Policy
Strict no-logs policy
No-logs policy verified by audit 2024
Jurisdiction
United States (5-eyes member)
Dark Web Monitor
Included
App Kill Switch Feature
Yes (app-level)
Dark Web Breach Monitoring
No
Breach Monitoring Included
No
US Streaming Platforms Supported(platforms)
4+ (Netflix, Hulu, Disney+, HBO Max verified)
Free Trial or Free Plan(monthly data)
None - 30-day money back only
Devices Supported on Free Tier(devices)
0 (Premium only)
Devices Supported on Premium(devices)
6 simultaneous connections
Privacy Jurisdiction
Panama (5/9/14 Eyes)
Netflix Libraries Accessible(libraries)
30+
Total Streaming Services Supported(services)
10+
Netflix Streaming Reliability(%)
89% success rate (tested 13 regions)
62% success rate (tested 13 regions)
Netflix Unblocking Success Rate(percent)
98%
72%
Netflix Unblocking Success(%)
71%
Show 1 more attribute
Netflix Streaming Compatibility(regions)
8 regions
Global Server Count(servers)
6,500+
Server Count(servers)
7,200+
Global Server Network(servers)
6,500+ servers
Countries with Server Presence(countries)
111 countries
84 countries
Number of Servers(servers)
5,900+
29,650+
Show 4 more attributes
Total Global Servers(servers)
6,500+
Number of VPN Servers(servers)
6,500+
29,650+
Countries with Server Coverage(countries)
111
84
Countries with Servers(countries)
84 countries
Countries Covered(count)
110+ countries
Country Coverage(countries)
110+
Global Server Count(servers)
6,400+
29,650+
Server Countries(countries)
111
Total VPN Servers Worldwide(servers)
6,500+
3,400+
Country Coverage(countries)
111 countries
84 countries
Show 2 more attributes
Countries Covered(count)
111 countries
84
VPN Server Locations(countries)
111 countries
Streaming Compatibility
Full support for major platforms
Maximum Password Character Support(characters)
Not applicable
Browser Extensions Available(count)
7 major browser extensions
Supported Platforms(platforms)
12+ (major platforms only)
Devices Supported Simultaneously(devices)
6 simultaneous connections
Annual Subscription Price(USD)
$3.99/month
$2.03/month
Total VPN Servers(servers)
6,500+
10,000+
Total VPN Server Count(servers)
6,000
Countries Available(countries)
111
Open-Source Code Availability
Partial (selected components)
100% open-source
Open-Source Code
Partial components only
Open-Source Client
No (proprietary)
Yes (GitHub available)
Independent Security Audits
Partial open-source, limited audits
Countries with Presence(countries)
111
Source Code Availability
Proprietary/Closed-source
Latest Security Audit Year
2022 (PwC)
Free Tier Monthly Data(GB)
None
Money-Back Guarantee(days)
30 days
30 days
Total Server Count(servers)
5,800+
29,650 servers
Money-Back Guarantee Period(days)
30 days
30 days
Customer Rating (Trustpilot)(out of 5.0)
4.4
4.6
Free Trial Duration(days)
7 days
Customer Support Hours(hours/week)
24/7 live chat and email
Geographic Coverage(countries)
60+ countries
91 countries
Countries Served(countries)
111
Global Server Network Size(servers)
6,000+
Transparency Report Frequency(per year)
Annual (1x/year)
Primary Protocol
NordLynx (WireGuard-based)
OpenVPN / WireGuard
No-Logs Audit Year
Deloitte (2020) + Court-verified

Pros & Cons

10 pros·5 cons across both

NordVPN
PI
NordVPN

NordVPN

+5-2

Pros

  • Average download speed of 920 Mbps maintains near-native connection speeds
  • 98% Netflix unblocking success with dedicated streaming-optimized servers
  • 6,400+ servers across 111 countries provides maximum geographic flexibility
  • NordLynx protocol (WireGuard variant) balances speed with privacy
  • Double VPN feature encrypts traffic through two servers sequentially

Cons

  • Higher subscription cost at $3.99/month on standard plans
  • SSD-based servers technically allow data recovery if compromised (vs RAM-only competitors)
PI

Private Internet Access (PIA)

+5-3

Pros

  • Lowest price at $2.03/month on 3-year plan (45% cheaper than NordVPN)
  • RAM-only servers guarantee zero data persistence after shutdown
  • 10 simultaneous device connections vs NordVPN's 6
  • Owned by Kape Technologies with transparent ownership disclosure
  • Advanced kill switch with granular DNS/WebRTC leak protection

Cons

  • Only 72% success rate unblocking Netflix; frequent geographic blocks
  • Average speed of 780 Mbps is noticeably slower for bandwidth-heavy activities
  • Smaller server network (84 countries) limits geographic options

Frequently Asked Questions

5 questions

  1. NordVPN significantly outperforms Private Internet Access for streaming, with a 98% Netflix unblocking success rate compared to PIA's 72%. NordVPN maintains consistent access to international Netflix libraries across its 111-country network, while PIA frequently encounters geographic blocks and detection issues.

12 more to explore

5 articles

Explore More

Related comparisons and categories

AI generated