Five Guys vs Shake Shack 2026: Price, Quality & Menu
Five Guys offers customizable burgers with fresh-cut fries at premium prices ($15-18 per burger), while Shake Shack focuses on smaller, signature burgers with unique toppings at slightly lower prices ($9-13 per burger). Five Guys prioritizes ingredient customization; Shake Shack emphasizes curated menu innovation.
Five Guys
Premium customizable burger chain with fresh-cut fries and extensive topping options.
Customers who prioritize customization, portion size, and quality ingredients over cost and speed; those who want exactly their ideal burger built from scratch.
Shake Shack
Fast-casual burger chain known for innovative signature burgers and efficient service.
Diners seeking quality burgers with chef-designed combinations, faster service, and better value; those who prefer curated experiences over unlimited customization.
Quick Answer
AI SummaryFive Guys offers customizable burgers with fresh-cut fries at premium prices ($15-18 per burger), while Shake Shack focuses on smaller, signature burgers with unique toppings at slightly lower prices ($9-13 per burger). Five Guys prioritizes ingredient customization; Shake Shack emphasizes curated menu innovation.
Our Verdict
AI-assistedChoose Five Guys if you value maximum customization, fresh-cut fries, and don't mind paying premium prices for ingredient control and portion size. Choose Shake Shack if you prefer curated, chef-designed burgers, faster service, lower costs, and enjoy trying seasonal menu innovations without decision paralysis.
Was this verdict helpful?
Choose Five Guys if
Best pickCustomers who prioritize customization, portion size, and quality ingredients over cost and speed; those who want exactly their ideal burger built from scratch.
Choose Shake Shack if
Diners seeking quality burgers with chef-designed combinations, faster service, and better value; those who prefer curated experiences over unlimited customization.
Track this comparison
Get notified when prices change, new specs ship, or our verdict updates.
Triggers: price change new spec verdict update
No spam. Stop anytime.
Key Differences at a Glance
- Average Burger Price:✓ Shake Shack wins($11.25 vs $16.50)
- Customization Options:✓ Five Guys wins(15+ topping combinations per burger vs 5-7 signature menu items only)
- Fries Offering:✓ Five Guys wins(Fresh-cut daily, 10+ seasoning options vs Crinkle-cut, limited toppings)
Key Facts & Figures
40 numeric metrics compared
| Metric | Five Guys | Shake Shack | Ratio |
|---|---|---|---|
| Classic Cheeseburger Price(USD) | $12.99 | — | — |
| 2026 YouGov Quality Ranking(Percentile (% voting for top burger)) | 1st place - 15.5% | — | — |
| Global Locations(number of restaurants) | 1,500+ | — | — |
| Menu Item Categories(primary daypart focus) | 3 (burgers, hot dogs, fries) | — | — |
| Price Per Ounce of Beef(USD per oz) | $1.95/oz | — | — |
| Total Locations(count) | 1,500+ | — | — |
| States/Regions Present(count) | 40+ states plus international | — | — |
| Menu Items(count) | 15+ customizable options | — | — |
| Average Wait Time(minutes) | 12-15 minutes | — | — |
| Drive-Thru Availability(%) | 25% | — | — |
| Founded Year | 2000 | — | — |
| Number of Global Locations(locations) | Five Guys | Shake Shack | |
| Average Burger Price(USD) | Five Guys | Shake Shack | |
| Topping Customization Options(toppings) | Five Guys | Shake Shack | |
| Founding Year(year) | Five Guys | Shake Shack | |
| Average Fries Portion Size(oz) | Five Guys | Shake Shack | |
| Service Speed (Avg Wait)(minutes) | Five Guys | Shake Shack | |
| Menu Item Count(items) | Five Guys | Shake Shack | |
| Average Burger Price(USD) | $15.49 | — | — |
| Average Wait Time(minutes) | 12-15 minutes | — | — |
| Customization Options per Burger(toppings) | 15+ toppings | — | — |
| Menu Item Count(items) | 12 core items | — | — |
| US Locations(locations) | 1,700+ | — | — |
| Customer Satisfaction Rating(percent) | 4.5/5 | — | — |
| Average Meal Cost (Burger + Fries + Drink)(USD) | $22.99 | — | — |
| Single Burger Base Price(USD) | $16.00 | — | — |
| Number of Global Locations(restaurants) | 1,700+ | — | — |
| Average Customer Rating(stars) | 4.5/5.0 | — | — |
| Average Service Wait Time(minutes) | 13 minutes | — | — |
| Topping Customization Options(count) | 15+ toppings | 5-7 toppings per burger | |
| Drive-Thru Availability(percent of locations) | 5% | — | — |
| Price Per Pound of Beef(USD) | $4.80/lb | — | — |
| Average Service Time(minutes) | 10-15 minutes | — | — |
| Available Toppings(count) | 25+ | — | — |
| US Restaurant Locations(count) | 1,500+ | — | — |
| Single Burger Price(USD) | $16.50 | $11.25 | |
| Double Burger Price(USD) | $20.99 | $14.99 | |
| Single Patty Weight(oz) | 4.3 oz | 4.0 oz | |
| Average Peak Hour Wait Time(minutes) | 15 minutes | 10 minutes | |
| Global Locations (2026)(stores) | 1,650 | 520 |
Sourced from publicly available data ·
Key Differences
7 attributes compared head-to-head
- $16.50Average Burger Price$11.25(winner)
- 15+ topping combinations per burger(winner)Customization Options5-7 signature menu items only
- Fresh-cut daily, 10+ seasoning options(winner)Fries OfferingCrinkle-cut, limited toppings
- 1,650+ locations worldwide(winner)Global Locations (2026)520+ locations worldwide
- Single: 4.3 oz patty | Double: 8.6 oz(winner)Burger SizeSingle: 4.0 oz patty | Double: 8.0 oz
- 12-18 minutes peak hoursTypical Wait Time8-12 minutes peak hours(winner)
- Base menu stable; limited seasonal itemsMenu Innovation FrequencyQuarterly rotating specialty burgers(winner)
- Average Burger Price
Five Guys
$16.50
Shake Shack
$11.25(winner)
- Customization Options
Five Guys
15+ topping combinations per burger(winner)
Shake Shack
5-7 signature menu items only
- Fries Offering
Five Guys
Fresh-cut daily, 10+ seasoning options(winner)
Shake Shack
Crinkle-cut, limited toppings
- Global Locations (2026)
Five Guys
1,650+ locations worldwide(winner)
Shake Shack
520+ locations worldwide
- Burger Size
Five Guys
Single: 4.3 oz patty | Double: 8.6 oz(winner)
Shake Shack
Single: 4.0 oz patty | Double: 8.0 oz
- Typical Wait Time
Five Guys
12-18 minutes peak hours
Shake Shack
8-12 minutes peak hours(winner)
- Menu Innovation Frequency
Five Guys
Base menu stable; limited seasonal items
Shake Shack
Quarterly rotating specialty burgers(winner)
Full Comparison
| Attribute | Five Guys | Shake Shack |
|---|---|---|
| Classic Cheeseburger Price(USD) | $12.99 | — |
| Average Burger Price(USD) | $15.49 | — |
| Average Meal Cost (Burger + Fries + Drink)(USD) | $22.99 | — |
| Single Burger Base Price(USD) | $16.00 | — |
| Single Burger Price(USD) | $16.50 | $11.25(winner) |
Show 1 more attributeDouble Burger Price(USD) $20.99 $14.99 | ||
| 2026 YouGov Quality Ranking(Percentile (% voting for top burger)) | 1st place - 15.5% | — |
| Global Locations(number of restaurants) | 1,500+ | — |
| Beef Freshness | Fresh never-frozen daily | — |
| Beef Sourcing Method | Fresh, never frozen | — |
| Beef Fat Content Ratio(%) | 80/20 blend | — |
| Customization Options | Patty count, proteins, toppings, sauces | — |
| Menu Item Categories(primary daypart focus) | 3 (burgers, hot dogs, fries) | — |
| Price Per Ounce of Beef(USD per oz) | $1.95/oz | — |
| Price Per Pound of Beef(USD) | $4.80/lb | — |
| Total Locations(count) | 1,500+ | — |
| Number of Global Locations(locations) | Five Guys(winner) | Shake Shack |
| States/Regions Present(count) | 40+ states plus international | — |
| Menu Items(count) | 15+ customizable options | — |
| Average Wait Time(minutes) | 12-15 minutes | — |
| Average Service Wait Time(minutes) | 13 minutes | — |
| Customer Satisfaction Rating(relative ranking) | 4.4 | — |
| Drive-Thru Availability(%) | 25% | — |
| Drive-Thru Availability(percent of locations) | 5% | — |
| Average Service Time(minutes) | 10-15 minutes | — |
| Founded Year | 2000 | — |
| Average Burger Price(USD) | Five Guys | Shake Shack(winner) |
| Topping Customization Options(toppings) | Five Guys(winner) | Shake Shack |
| Menu Item Count(items) | Five Guys(winner) | Shake Shack |
| Topping Customization Options(count) | 15+ toppings(winner) | 5-7 toppings per burger |
| Founding Year(year) | Five Guys(winner) | Shake Shack |
| Average Fries Portion Size(oz) | Five Guys(winner) | Shake Shack |
| Alcohol Beverage Offering | Five Guys | Shake Shack |
| Service Speed (Avg Wait)(minutes) | Five Guys | Shake Shack(winner) |
| Average Wait Time(minutes) | 12-15 minutes | — |
| Average Peak Hour Wait Time(minutes) | 15 minutes | 10 minutes(winner) |
| Customization Options per Burger(toppings) | 15+ toppings | — |
| Menu Item Count(items) | 12 core items | — |
| US Locations(locations) | 1,700+ | — |
| US Restaurant Locations(count) | 1,500+ | — |
| Customer Satisfaction Rating(percent) | 4.5/5 | — |
| Beef Sourcing Quality | Fresh, never frozen, daily ground | — |
| Number of Global Locations(restaurants) | 1,700+ | — |
| Average Customer Rating(stars) | 4.5/5.0 | — |
| Available Toppings(count) | 25+ | — |
| Single Patty Weight(oz) | 4.3 oz(winner) | 4.0 oz |
| Fries: Fresh-Cut Daily | Yes | No (frozen crinkle-cut) |
| Global Locations (2026)(stores) | 1,650(winner) | 520 |
| Menu Rotation Frequency | Annual seasonal items | Quarterly specialty burgers |
Five GuysShake ShackShow 1 more attribute
Pros & Cons
10 pros·6 cons across both
Five Guys
Pros
- Unlimited topping combinations at no extra charge (15+ toppings available)
- Fresh-cut fries made daily with 10+ seasoning options (cajun, BBQ, ranch, etc.)
- Larger burger patties (4.3 oz single vs 4.0 oz competitors)
- 1,650+ locations globally with strong international presence
- High-quality beef sourced from regional suppliers
Cons
- Highest price point ($16.50 average burger) limits frequency of visits
- Long wait times during peak hours (12-18 minutes) due to made-to-order preparation
- Static menu with minimal innovation or seasonal offerings
Shake Shack
Pros
- Lower prices ($11.25 average burger) make it more accessible for frequent visits
- Faster service (8-12 minute average wait) with streamlined ordering process
- Quarterly rotating specialty burgers featuring creative ingredients and flavor combinations
- Cleaner, more upscale dining atmosphere with premium positioning
- 520+ locations with expanding US and international footprint
Cons
- Limited customization—mostly pre-designed menu items with minimal modifications allowed
- Smaller burger patties (4.0 oz) compared to Five Guys
- Crinkle-cut fries lack variety compared to competitors' seasonings and fresh-cut options
Frequently Asked Questions
5 questions
Shake Shack is significantly cheaper, with single burgers averaging $11.25 versus Five Guys at $16.50—a difference of $5.25 (32% more expensive at Five Guys). This makes Shake Shack more accessible for budget-conscious diners, though Five Guys offers larger patties (4.3 oz vs 4.0 oz) to justify the premium.
Resources & Learn More
Curated sources to dive deeper
Where to Buy
As an affiliate, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you. Learn more about our affiliate disclosure
Wikipedia
Related Comparisons
12 more to explore
Shake Shack vs Five Guys
productsBurger King vs Five Guys
food_and_drinkWendy's vs Five Guys
food_and_drinkFive Guys vs In-N-Out
Fast Casual RestaurantsBurger King vs Five Guys
food_and_drinkWendy's vs Five Guys
food_and_drinkSubway vs Jimmy John's
food_and_drinkKFC vs Popeyes Louisiana Kitchen
food_and_drinkCoca-Cola vs LaCroix
food_and_drinkPepsi vs Mountain Dew
food_and_drinkChick-fil-A vs McDonald's
food_and_drinkMcDonald's vs Wendy's
food_and_drink
Explore More
Related comparisons and categories