Skip to main content
sports

49ers vs Browns: 2025 NFL Comparison

The San Francisco 49ers have won significantly more games historically (586 wins vs 395), made more Super Bowl appearances (6 vs 2), and currently have a stronger roster with a 12-5 record compared to the Browns' 3-14 record as of 2025. The 49ers are an elite NFC West contender while the Browns remain in rebuilding mode.

Cleveland Browns

Cleveland Browns

NFL franchise based in Cleveland, Ohio, competing in the AFC North division since 1946.

Long-suffering loyal fans seeking eventual turnaround and rebuilding-phase optimism

Score63%
VS
San Francisco 49ers

San Francisco 49ers

NFL franchise based in San Francisco, California, competing in the NFC West division since 1946.

Fans seeking immediate playoff contention and consistent championship-caliber football

Score71%

Quick Answer

AI Summary

The San Francisco 49ers have won significantly more games historically (586 wins vs 395), made more Super Bowl appearances (6 vs 2), and currently have a stronger roster with a 12-5 record compared to the Browns' 3-14 record as of 2025. The 49ers are an elite NFC West contender while the Browns remain in rebuilding mode.

Our Verdict

AI-assisted

The San Francisco 49ers are decisively the stronger franchise, with 5 Super Bowl championships, a .525 all-time winning percentage, and consistent playoff success. The Browns have not won a championship since 1964 and are currently in the midst of a significant rebuilding phase with a 3-14 record. Choose the 49ers if you want to follow a consistently competitive, elite NFC team with a proven quarterback and coach. Choose the Browns if you're a loyal supporter committed to building through a difficult rebuilding period, though near-term success is unlikely.

Community feedback

Was this verdict helpful?

Cleveland Browns
5.7/10
San Francisco 49ers
9.3/10
Cleveland Browns

Choose Cleveland Browns if

Long-suffering loyal fans seeking eventual turnaround and rebuilding-phase optimism

San Francisco 49ers

Choose San Francisco 49ers if

Best pick

Fans seeking immediate playoff contention and consistent championship-caliber football

Track this comparison

Get notified when prices change, new specs ship, or our verdict updates.

Triggers: price change new spec verdict update

No spam. Stop anytime.

Key Differences at a Glance

  • All-Time Win-Loss Record:San Francisco 49ers wins(586-529-16 (.525 winning percentage) vs 395-506-7 (.438 winning percentage))
  • Super Bowl Appearances:San Francisco 49ers wins(6 (1982, 1985, 1989, 1995, 2020, 2024) vs 2 (1980, 1987))
  • Super Bowl Wins:San Francisco 49ers wins(5 championships (1982, 1985, 1989, 1995, 2024) vs 0 championships)
See all 7 differences

Key Facts & Figures

108 numeric metrics compared

MetricCleveland BrownsSan Francisco 49ersRatio
Turnovers(count)20
Yards Per Play(yards)4.23.9
Fumbles Lost(count)20
Interceptions Thrown(count)00
Total Turnovers (Fumbles + INTs)(count)20
2026 Roster Building Moves(deals)Standard approach14 reserve/future deals
Home Win Percentage vs This Opponent(%)27.3%
Away Win Percentage vs This Opponent(%)44.4%
Average Points Per Game vs This Opponent(PPG)18.1
All-Time Head-to-Head Wins(wins)Cleveland Browns
Franchise Total Wins(wins)Cleveland Browns
Leading Running Back Rushing Yards (2025)(yards)Cleveland Browns
Current Head Coach Tenure(seasons)Cleveland Browns
All-Time Head-to-Head Win Percentage(%)35.5%64.5%
2025 Regular Season Wins(wins)11
2025 Points Per Game(PPG)22.4
All-Time Win Percentage(percentage)64.7%
Primary Running Back Rushing Yards (2025)(yards)827 (Quinshon Judkins)
Super Bowl Titles(championships)0
Starting QB 2025 Passing Yards(yards)~2,000 yards
Starting QB Touchdowns (2025)(TDs)~15 TDs
Super Bowl Championships(titles)05 (1988, 1989, 1994, 1995, 2021)
Playoff Appearances (Last 10 Years)(appearances)3 appearances
Passer Rating (2025)(rating)~82
Years Since Super Bowl Win(years)61 years (1964)
Points For Per Game(PPG)16.7
Points Against Per Game(PPG)478
Super Bowl Championships(titles)0 championships5 championships
Playoff Appearances (2001-2026)(appearances)213
QB Passing Yards (2024 Season)(yards)3,964 (Deshaun Watson)4,694 (Brock Purdy)
QB Touchdown-to-Interception Ratio (2024)(ratio)1.69 (27 TDs / 16 INTs)3.44 (31 TDs / 9 INTs)
Head Coach Current Tenure(seasons)6 seasons (Kevin Stefanski, since 2020)8 seasons (Kyle Shanahan, since 2017)
Division Titles (All-Time)(titles)819
Playoff Appearances (1996-2024)(appearances)6
AFC North Division Titles (1996-2024)(titles)8
Starting QB Contract (2024-25 Season)(USD millions guaranteed)$230M (Watson)
Offensive Points Per Game (2023-24 Season)(PPG)21.5
Rushing Yards Per Game (2023-24 Season)(yards)118.2
Super Bowl Wins(titles)0
Years Since Last Championship(years)77 years (1964)
Division Titles (2015-2025)(titles)2
Playoff Appearances (2021-2025)(appearances)2
Win Percentage (2020-2025)(%)56.3%
Current QB Annual Salary Cap Hit(USD millions)$57.5M (Deshaun Watson)
Team Valuation (2025)(USD billions)$3.2B
Super Bowl Titles0
Division Titles (2015-2024)(titles)2
Playoff Appearances (2015-2024)(appearances)3 (2020, 2022, 2023)
NFL Championships Pre-1966(championships)8
All-Time Winning Percentage(%).438 (395-506-7).525 (586-529-16)
Hall of Famers(players)8 Hall of Famers14 Hall of Famers
Current QB Passer Rating (2025)(rating)82.4 (Deshaun Watson)107.2 (Brock Purdy)
Years Since Last Super Bowl Appearance(years)38 years (1987)1 year (2024 won)
Playoff Appearances (2015-2025)(appearances)2 appearances7 appearances
QB Guaranteed Contract Value(USD millions)$230M (Deshaun Watson)
Available Salary Cap Space (2024)(USD millions)$8.2M
Years in Current City(years)76 years (since 1950)
Division Championships (Last 20 Years)(titles)2 (2020, 2022)
Super Bowl Appearances(appearances)0 appearances6
All-Time Regular Season Win Percentage(%).447 (515-638-11)
Division Titles(titles)8 titles
Playoff Appearances(appearances)6 appearances
Head-to-Head Series Record (all-time)(wins)7 wins (16 games)
Franchise Established(year)1946
Conference Championships (pre-Super Bowl era & modern)(titles)8 total
Head Coach Tenure(seasons)5 seasons (Kevin Stefanski, 2020-present)7 seasons (Kyle Shanahan, 2017-present)
2025 Defense Ranking (Yards Allowed/Game)(yards/game)364.5 yards (22nd)
2025 Offense Ranking (Yards Per Game)(yards/game)379.8 yards (7th)
Playoff Appearances (Last 10 Seasons)(appearances)3 appearances (2020, 2021, 2023)
Modern Era Hall of Famers(players)2 (Jim Brown, Otto Graham)
Head Coach Regular Season Win Percentage(percent)54.0% (Stefanski)
Total League Championships8
Pro Football Hall of Famers22
Years in NFL(years)77 years (since 1946)
Stadium Capacity(seats)67,431
AFC North Division Titles (all-time)(titles)8
Playoff Appearances (since 1999)(appearances)8
Winning Percentage (last 10 seasons: 2015-2024)(%)46.3%
Current Head Coach Tenure(seasons)5 seasons (Stefanski)
Active Pro Bowl Quarterbacks(players)1 (Deshaun Watson - 3x Pro Bowler career)
2024 Regular Season Wins(wins)9
Starting QB Passer Rating(rating points)92.1
Offensive Yards Per Game(yards)354.1
Defensive Points Allowed Per Game(points)23.4
Head Coach Tenure (Years)(years)3
Pro Bowl Selections (2024)(players)3
Playoff Appearances (2020-2024)(appearances)25 consecutive
Points Per Game (Offense)(PPG)26.326.3
Points Allowed Per Game (Defense)(PPG)18.218.2
Rushing Yards Per Game(yards)134.2134.2
Passing Yards Per Game(yards)259.8259.8
Playoff Appearances (Last 5 Years)(seasons)44
Head Coach Winning Percentage(%)71.4%71.4%
Franchise Super Bowl Wins(total)55
2025 Season Wins(wins)1212
Average Passing Yards Per Game (2025)(yards)234.2234.2
Average Rushing Yards Per Game (2025)(yards)148.7148.7
Points Allowed Per Game (2025)(points)18.918.9
Head Coach Win Percentage(percent)63.2%63.2%
Playoff Wins (Last 3 Seasons)(wins)66
Team Payroll (2025 Approx)(millions)$267M$267M
Super Bowl Appearances (2019-2024)(appearances)33
Hall of Famers (All-Time)(inductees)1414
Franchise Valuation (2024)(billions USD)$8.1B$8.1B
Most Recent Super Bowl Victory(year)19951995
Current Head Coach Winning Percentage(percentage)Kyle Shanahan .606 (54-35)Kyle Shanahan .606 (54-35)
Division Titles Won(titles)1616
Conference Championship Appearances(total)1919

Sourced from publicly available data ·

Key Differences

7 attributes compared head-to-head

Cleveland Browns
0Cleveland Browns
San Francisco 49ers leads1 tie
San Francisco 49ers
6San Francisco 49ers
  • All-Time Win-Loss Record

    Cleveland Browns

    395-506-7 (.438 winning percentage)

    San Francisco 49ers

    586-529-16 (.525 winning percentage)(winner)

  • Super Bowl Appearances

    Cleveland Browns

    2 (1980, 1987)

    San Francisco 49ers

    6 (1982, 1985, 1989, 1995, 2020, 2024)(winner)

  • Super Bowl Wins

    Cleveland Browns

    0 championships

    San Francisco 49ers

    5 championships (1982, 1985, 1989, 1995, 2024)(winner)

  • 2025 Season Record

    Cleveland Browns

    3-14 (Last Place AFC North)

    San Francisco 49ers

    12-5 (NFC West Leader)(winner)

  • Playoff Appearances (Last 10 Years)

    Cleveland Browns

    2 appearances (2020, 2023)

    San Francisco 49ers

    7 appearances (2019, 2021, 2022, 2023, 2024, 2025)(winner)

  • Hall of Fame Players

    Cleveland Browns

    8 (Jim Brown, Otto Graham, Paul Brown, Len Ford, Dante Lavelli, Lou Groza, Bernie Kosar, Dick Modzelewski)

    San Francisco 49ers

    14 (Joe Montana, Jerry Rice, Steve Young, Steve Largent, Ronnie Lott, Rod Walsh, John Taylor, Tai Streets, Terrell Owens, Eric Wright, Bryant Young, Patrick Willis, Richard Sherman, Justin Smith)(winner)

  • Head Coach Tenure Stability

    Cleveland Browns

    Kevin Stefanski 4 years (hired 2020)

    San Francisco 49ers

    Kyle Shanahan 7 years (hired 2017)

Full Comparison

Cleveland Browns
San Francisco 49ers
Turnovers(count)
2
0
Fumbles Lost(count)
2
0
Total Turnovers (Fumbles + INTs)(count)
2
0
Fumbles (Total-Lost)(count)
4-2
0-0
Yards Per Play(yards)
4.2
3.9
QB Touchdown-to-Interception Ratio (2024)(ratio)
1.69 (27 TDs / 16 INTs)
3.44 (31 TDs / 9 INTs)
Offensive Yards Per Game(yards)
354.1
Interceptions Thrown(count)
0
0
2026 Roster Building Moves(deals)
Standard approach
14 reserve/future deals
Game Execution Rating(score)
Fair - Turnover issues
Excellent - Clean execution
Home Win Percentage vs This Opponent(%)
27.3%
Away Win Percentage vs This Opponent(%)
44.4%
All-Time Head-to-Head Win Percentage(%)
35.5%
64.5%
Average Points Per Game vs This Opponent(PPG)
18.1
Leading Running Back Rushing Yards (2025)(yards)
Cleveland Browns
2025 Starting QB Passing Yards(yards)
Deshaun Gabriel 110 yards
Brock Purdy 2,167 yards
Starting QB 2025 Passing Yards(yards)
~2,000 yards
Starting QB Touchdowns (2025)(TDs)
~15 TDs
All-Time Head-to-Head Wins(wins)
Cleveland Browns
Franchise Total Wins(wins)
Cleveland Browns
Years in NFL(seasons)
77 seasons overall
80 seasons overall
All-Time Win Percentage(percentage)
64.7%
Hall of Famers(players)
8 Hall of Famers
14 Hall of Famers
Years in NFL(years)
77 years (since 1946)
2025 Season Starting QB Experience(years)
Cleveland Browns
Elite Wide Receiver Presence
Cleveland Browns
Current Head Coach Tenure(seasons)
Cleveland Browns
Head Coach Tenure (Years)(years)
3
Points Per Game (2025 H2H)(PPG)
20.2
19.0
Home Win Percentage (H2H)(%)
46.7%
75.0%
Primary RB Rushing Yards (2025)(yards)
Quinshon Judkins 827 yards
Christian McCaffrey depth role
2025 Regular Season Wins(wins)
11
2025 Regular Season Record(Wins-Losses)
Below .500
2025 Season Record(wins-losses)
3-14
2024 Regular Season Wins(wins)
9
2025 Points Per Game(PPG)
22.4
Points For Per Game(PPG)
16.7
QB Passing Yards (2024 Season)(yards)
3,964 (Deshaun Watson)
4,694 (Brock Purdy)
Quarterback TD:INT Ratio (2025)(ratio)
19:10
Primary Running Back Rushing Yards (2025)(yards)
827 (Quinshon Judkins)
Franchise Era(years)
73rd season (2025)
Quarterback Competition Level
Multiple starters (Watson, Gabriel, Flacco)
Active Pro Bowl Quarterbacks(players)
1 (Deshaun Watson - 3x Pro Bowler career)
Defense Ranking(ranking)
32nd
Points Against Per Game(PPG)
478
All-Time Head-to-Head Record(wins)
6-9
Head-to-Head Record (Browns vs Ravens)(wins-losses)
13-33
Super Bowl Titles(championships)
0
2025 Head-to-Head Result(final score)
Lost 29-31
Super Bowl Championships(titles)
0
5 (1988, 1989, 1994, 1995, 2021)
Super Bowl Appearances(appearances)
0 appearances
6
Division Titles(titles)
8 titles
Conference Championships (pre-Super Bowl era & modern)(titles)
8 total
AFC North Division Titles (all-time)(titles)
8
Playoff Appearances (Last 10 Years)(appearances)
3 appearances
2024 Season Record(wins-losses)
3-14 (5th place, AFC North)
12-5 (4th seed, NFC)
Division Titles (2015-2024)(titles)
2
Playoff Appearances (2015-2024)(appearances)
3 (2020, 2022, 2023)
2023 Regular Season Record(wins-losses)
11-6
Show 2 more attributes
Playoff Appearances (since 1999)(appearances)
8
Winning Percentage (last 10 seasons: 2015-2024)(%)
46.3%
Head-to-Head December 14, 2025(points)
Lost 3-31
QB Completion Percentage (2025)(%)
~55%
69.4% (Brock Purdy)
Passer Rating (2025)(rating)
~82
Years Since Super Bowl Win(years)
61 years (1964)
Years Since Last Super Bowl Appearance(years)
38 years (1987)
1 year (2024 won)
Super Bowl Championships(titles)
0 championships
5 championships
Super Bowl Wins(titles)
0
Years Since Last Championship(years)
77 years (1964)
Playoff Appearances (2001-2026)(appearances)
2
13
Head Coach Current Tenure(seasons)
6 seasons (Kevin Stefanski, since 2020)
8 seasons (Kyle Shanahan, since 2017)
Current Head Coach Tenure(seasons)
5 seasons (Stefanski)
Division Titles (All-Time)(titles)
8
19
Super Bowl Titles
0
NFL Championships Pre-1966(championships)
8
Total League Championships
8
Most Recent Super Bowl Win(year)
Never
All-Time Head-to-Head Record (Since 1996)(wins-losses)
29-35
Playoff Appearances (1996-2024)(appearances)
6
Offensive Points Per Game (2023-24 Season)(PPG)
21.5
Rushing Yards Per Game (2023-24 Season)(yards)
118.2
2025 Win-Loss Record(wins-losses)
13-4
Show 1 more attribute
2025 Season Wins(wins)
12
AFC North Division Titles (1996-2024)(titles)
8
Starting QB Contract (2024-25 Season)(USD millions guaranteed)
$230M (Watson)
Team Payroll (2025 Approx)(millions)
$267M
All-Time Head-to-Head Record(wins-losses)
28-32 (since 1996)
Division Titles (2015-2025)(titles)
2
Playoff Appearances (2021-2025)(appearances)
2
Playoff Appearances (2015-2025)(appearances)
2 appearances
7 appearances
Playoff Appearances (2020-2024)(appearances)
2
5 consecutive
Super Bowl Appearances (2019-2024)(appearances)
3
Show 1 more attribute
Most Recent Super Bowl Victory(year)
1995
Win Percentage (2020-2025)(%)
56.3%
Current QB Annual Salary Cap Hit(USD millions)
$57.5M (Deshaun Watson)
Team Valuation (2025)(USD billions)
$3.2B
All-Time Win-Loss Record (Franchise)(wins-losses)
544-689-10 (.441 win percentage)
All-Time Winning Percentage(%)
.438 (395-506-7)
.525 (586-529-16)
Head-to-Head Record (All-Time)(wins-losses)
42-81-1 vs Steelers
Years Since Last Super Bowl Win(years)
Never won
2025 Season Record(wins-losses)
3-14 (.176)
12-5 (.706)
Current QB Passer Rating (2025)(rating)
82.4 (Deshaun Watson)
107.2 (Brock Purdy)
Starting QB Passer Rating(rating points)
92.1
Division Standing(rank)
4th Place AFC North
1st Place NFC West
QB Guaranteed Contract Value(USD millions)
$230M (Deshaun Watson)
Available Salary Cap Space (2024)(USD millions)
$8.2M
Years in Current City(years)
76 years (since 1950)
Division Championships (Last 20 Years)(titles)
2 (2020, 2022)
Division Titles Won(titles)
16
All-Time Regular Season Win Percentage(%)
.447 (515-638-11)
Playoff Appearances(appearances)
6 appearances
Playoff Appearances (Last 10 Seasons)(appearances)
3 appearances (2020, 2021, 2023)
Head-to-Head Series Record (all-time)(wins)
7 wins (16 games)
Franchise Established(year)
1946
Franchise Super Bowl Wins(total)
5
Head Coach Tenure(seasons)
5 seasons (Kevin Stefanski, 2020-present)
7 seasons (Kyle Shanahan, 2017-present)
Head Coach Regular Season Win Percentage(percent)
54.0% (Stefanski)
2025 Defense Ranking (Yards Allowed/Game)(yards/game)
364.5 yards (22nd)
2025 Offense Ranking (Yards Per Game)(yards/game)
379.8 yards (7th)
Modern Era Hall of Famers(players)
2 (Jim Brown, Otto Graham)
Pro Football Hall of Famers
22
Stadium Capacity(seats)
67,431
2024 Regular Season Record(wins-losses)
11-6 (missed playoffs)
12-5 (.706 winning %)
Defensive Points Allowed Per Game(points)
23.4
Pro Bowl Selections (2024)(players)
3
Points Per Game (Offense)(PPG)
26.3
Points Allowed Per Game (Defense)(PPG)
18.2
Points Allowed Per Game (2025)(points)
18.9
Rushing Yards Per Game(yards)
134.2
Passing Yards Per Game(yards)
259.8
Average Passing Yards Per Game (2025)(yards)
234.2
Average Rushing Yards Per Game (2025)(yards)
148.7
Playoff Appearances (Last 5 Years)(seasons)
4
Head Coach Winning Percentage(%)
71.4%
Head Coach Win Percentage(percent)
63.2%
Playoff Wins (Last 3 Seasons)(wins)
6
Hall of Famers (All-Time)(inductees)
14
Franchise Valuation (2024)(billions USD)
$8.1B
All-Time Regular Season Record(wins-losses)
641-618
Conference Championship Appearances(total)
19
Current Head Coach Winning Percentage(percentage)
Kyle Shanahan .606 (54-35)

Pros & Cons

10 pros·5 cons across both

Cleveland Browns
San Francisco 49ers
Cleveland Browns

Cleveland Browns

+5-3

Pros

  • Historic franchise with 8 Hall of Famers and legendary figures like Jim Brown
  • Strong community support and passionate fan base in Ohio
  • Recently made 2023 playoff appearance with playoff win over Pittsburgh
  • Young QB Deshaun Watson on rookie deal has high upside potential
  • Play in NFL's most competitive division (AFC North)

Cons

  • 0 Super Bowl championships despite 77-year history; last championship in 1964
  • 3-14 record in 2025 season with worst record in AFC North
  • Deshaun Watson dealing with consistency issues and turnovers
San Francisco 49ers

San Francisco 49ers

+5-2

Pros

  • 5 Super Bowl championships (1982, 1985, 1989, 1995, 2024) with strong winning tradition
  • 12-5 record in 2025 leading NFC West with playoff contention certainty
  • QB Brock Purdy with strong 2024-2025 performance and 23:8 TD-to-INT ratio
  • Dominant defense led by All-Pro passes rushers Nick Bosa and Fred Warner
  • Made 7 playoff appearances in last 10 years with consistent excellence

Cons

  • High salary cap constraints limiting roster flexibility for free agency moves
  • Injuries to key defensive players disrupting depth chart consistency

Frequently Asked Questions

5 questions

  1. The Browns and 49ers have played each other 8 times in the regular season since 1992, with the 49ers holding a 5-3 series advantage. They are in different conferences (AFC North vs NFC West) so matchups occur only every 4 years when divisions rotate.

12 more to explore

5 articles

Explore More

Related comparisons and categories

AI generated