Is melatonin safe to use long-term?

Yes, melatonin is generally considered safe for long-term use based on current 2026 research. Unlike Ambien, it does not cause dependency, tolerance, or significant side effects with extended use. However, quality varies between brands since it's not FDA-regulated as a pharmaceutical drug. Consult your healthcare provider if using for more than a few months.

Can you become addicted to Ambien?

Yes, Ambien (zolpidem) carries a moderate-to-high risk of physical and psychological dependence, especially with prolonged use beyond the recommended 4 weeks. It is classified as a controlled substance and can lead to tolerance, withdrawal symptoms, and complex sleep behaviors. Medical supervision is essential to safely discontinue Ambien after regular use.

Which is better for jet lag?

Melatonin is the clear winner for jet lag. It works by resetting your circadian rhythm naturally and is specifically recommended for this use. Take 0.5-5 mg 30-60 minutes before desired bedtime at your destination. Ambien is not indicated for jet lag and would not address the underlying circadian desynchronization.

Are there supply shortages for either medication in 2026?

As of early 2026, neither melatonin nor zolpidem (Ambien) are listed in formal FDA or ASHP nationwide shortages. Melatonin is widely available over-the-counter. Ambien (zolpidem) remains accessible by prescription, though some extended-release formulations may have occasional supply fluctuations.

Can I take melatonin with Ambien?

Combining melatonin and Ambien is generally not recommended without medical approval. While not directly contraindicated, taking both increases sedation risk and is unnecessary since they work through different mechanisms. If considering combination therapy, consult your doctor about potential interactions and whether one medication alone would be sufficient.

How does melatonin work differently than Ambien?

Melatonin is a natural hormone that supports your body's existing sleep-wake cycle by signaling that it's time to sleep. Ambien (zolpidem) works by enhancing GABA activity in the brain to force sedation chemically. Melatonin gently supports natural sleep, while Ambien creates sedation—two fundamentally different approaches with different risks and benefits.

Melatonin vs Ambien

Updated March 31, 2026

Melatonin

Natural hormone supplement that regulates sleep-wake cycles with minimal side effects.

People with mild insomnia, jet lag, shift workers, those seeking natural alternatives, long-term sleep support without dependency risks

Check Price

Ambien

Prescription sedative (zolpidem) that enhances brain GABA activity for rapid sleep induction.

People with severe insomnia, acute sleep disruption, those unresponsive to non-pharmaceutical interventions, short-term use only under medical supervision

Short Answer

Melatonin is a natural hormone supplement that supports your body's sleep cycle with minimal side effects, making it ideal for mild insomnia and jet lag. Ambien (zolpidem) is a prescription sedative that works faster and stronger for severe insomnia but carries risks of dependency, side effects, and tolerance. Choose based on severity: melatonin for mild cases, Ambien only under medical supervision for moderate-to-severe insomnia.

Our Verdict

Melatonin is the safer, more accessible choice for mild-to-moderate sleep issues, particularly jet lag and occasional insomnia, with minimal side effects and no addiction risk. Ambien remains superior for severe insomnia requiring immediate, powerful sedation but should only be used short-term under medical supervision due to dependency and tolerance risks. Choose melatonin if you want a gentle, long-term sleep aid; choose Ambien only if a doctor determines you need stronger intervention for a limited period.

Melatonin6.7

8.3Ambien

Choose Melatonin if

People with mild insomnia, jet lag, shift workers, those seeking natural alternatives, long-term sleep support without dependency risks

Track this comparison

Get notified when prices change, new specs ship, or our verdict updates.

Triggers: price change new spec verdict update

No spam. Stop anytime.

Key Differences at a Glance

🔹

Prescription Status: Melatonin wins (Over-the-counter vs Prescription required)

🔹

Mechanism of Action: Supports natural circadian rhythm vs Enhances GABA brain activity for sedation

⚡

Speed of Action: Ambien wins (15-30 minutes vs 30-60 minutes)

See all 8 differences

Key Facts & Figures

Metric	Melatonin	Ambien	Diff
Onset Time(minutes)	30-60 minutes	15-30 minutes	+105%
Duration of Sleep Extension(minutes)	~24 minutes (daytime)	120-180 minutes	-84%
Recommended Maximum Duration(weeks)	Indefinite	4 weeks

Key Differences

Melatonin

Attribute

Ambien

Over-the-counter🏆

Prescription Status

Prescription required

Supports natural circadian rhythm

Mechanism of Action

Enhances GABA brain activity for sedation

30-60 minutes

Speed of Action

15-30 minutes🏆

Related Comparisons

Tylenol vs Advil

health

Almond Milk vs Oat Milk

health

Vegan vs Vegetarian

health

Keto vs Paleo

health

Running vs Walking

health

Wegovy vs Ozempic

health

Yoga vs Pilates

health

Flu Shot vs COVID Vaccine

health

Organic Food vs Non-Organic Food

health

Therapy vs Medication

health

Meditation vs Yoga

health

Contact Lenses vs Glasses

health

Keto vs Carnivore vs Paleo: Which Diet Works Best in 2026?

Choosing between keto, carnivore, and paleo diets can be overwhelming. We break down the key differences, benefits, and drawbacks of each approach to help you find the best diet for your 2026 health goals.

Explore Entities

More Health & Wellness

People Also Compare

Last updated: March 31, 2026AI generated

Prescription Status

Melatonin

Over-the-counter🏆

Ambien

Prescription required

Mechanism of Action

Melatonin

Supports natural circadian rhythm

Ambien

Enhances GABA brain activity for sedation

Speed of Action

Melatonin

30-60 minutes

Ambien

15-30 minutes🏆

Addiction Risk

Melatonin

Very low🏆

Ambien

Moderate to high

Side Effects Profile

Melatonin

Minimal and mild🏆

Ambien

Significant and varied

Long-term Safety

Melatonin

Safe for extended use🏆

Ambien

Recommended for short-term only

Effectiveness for Severe Insomnia

Melatonin

Moderate

Ambien

High🏆

Cost

Melatonin

$5-15/month🏆

Ambien

$20-100/month

Full Comparison

Attribute	Melatonin	Ambien

Onset Time(minutes)	30-60 minutes	15-30 minutes
Duration of Sleep Extension(minutes)	~24 minutes (daytime)	120-180 minutes

Addiction Risk Level	Very Low	Moderate-High
Common Side Effects	Headache, dizziness (rare)	Drowsiness, complex behaviors, amnesia, dependency
Recommended Maximum Duration(weeks)	Indefinite	4 weeks
Tolerance Development Risk	None reported	Common with extended use
Interaction Risk with Other Medications	Low	Moderate-High

Average Monthly Cost(USD)	$5-15	$20-100
Availability Status (2026)	Widely available	Available (no nationwide shortage)

Typical Dosage Range(mg)	0.5-10 mg	5-10 mg

FDA Regulation Status	Dietary supplement (loosely regulated)	FDA-approved prescription drug

Effectiveness for Jet Lag	High (recommended first-line)	Low (not indicated)

Melatonin

Ambien

Onset Time(minutes)

30-60 minutes

15-30 minutes

Duration of Sleep Extension(minutes)

~24 minutes (daytime)

120-180 minutes

Addiction Risk Level

Very Low

Moderate-High

Common Side Effects

Headache, dizziness (rare)

Drowsiness, complex behaviors, amnesia, dependency

Recommended Maximum Duration(weeks)

Indefinite

4 weeks

Tolerance Development Risk

None reported

Common with extended use

Interaction Risk with Other Medications

Low

Moderate-High

Average Monthly Cost(USD)

$5-15

$20-100

Availability Status (2026)

Widely available

Available (no nationwide shortage)

Typical Dosage Range(mg)

0.5-10 mg

5-10 mg

FDA Regulation Status

Dietary supplement (loosely regulated)

FDA-approved prescription drug

Effectiveness for Jet Lag

High (recommended first-line)

Low (not indicated)

Full Comparison

Attribute	Melatonin	Ambien

Onset Time(minutes)	30-60 minutes	15-30 minutes
Duration of Sleep Extension(minutes)	~24 minutes (daytime)	120-180 minutes

Addiction Risk Level	Very Low	Moderate-High
Common Side Effects	Headache, dizziness (rare)	Drowsiness, complex behaviors, amnesia, dependency
Recommended Maximum Duration(weeks)	Indefinite	4 weeks
Tolerance Development Risk	None reported	Common with extended use
Interaction Risk with Other Medications	Low	Moderate-High

Average Monthly Cost(USD)	$5-15	$20-100
Availability Status (2026)	Widely available	Available (no nationwide shortage)

Typical Dosage Range(mg)	0.5-10 mg	5-10 mg

FDA Regulation Status	Dietary supplement (loosely regulated)	FDA-approved prescription drug

Effectiveness for Jet Lag	High (recommended first-line)	Low (not indicated)

Melatonin

Ambien

Onset Time(minutes)

30-60 minutes

15-30 minutes

Duration of Sleep Extension(minutes)

~24 minutes (daytime)

120-180 minutes

Addiction Risk Level

Very Low

Moderate-High

Common Side Effects

Headache, dizziness (rare)

Drowsiness, complex behaviors, amnesia, dependency

Recommended Maximum Duration(weeks)

Indefinite

4 weeks

Tolerance Development Risk

None reported

Common with extended use

Interaction Risk with Other Medications

Low

Moderate-High

Average Monthly Cost(USD)

$5-15

$20-100

Availability Status (2026)

Widely available

Available (no nationwide shortage)

Typical Dosage Range(mg)

0.5-10 mg

5-10 mg

FDA Regulation Status

Dietary supplement (loosely regulated)

FDA-approved prescription drug

Effectiveness for Jet Lag

High (recommended first-line)

Low (not indicated)