Skip to main content

Enlisted Soldier vs Commissioned Officer

A Versus B

Enlisted Soldiers carry out the Army's missions; to enlist you need a high school diploma, GED or a plan to get one, plus a minimum ASVAB score. Commissioned Officers lead Soldiers and organizations and must hold a bachelor's degree by the time they are commissioned, through ROTC, the U.S. Military Academy at West Point, the 12-week Officer Candidate School or direct commission. Officers must be under 31 in the year of commissioning, or under 27 from West Point. Enlisted Soldiers can become officers through Green to Gold.

Enlisted Soldier

Soldiers who carry out the unit's mission; join with a high school diploma or GED.

People who want to start serving without a college degree

Score60%
VS
Commissioned Officer

Commissioned Officer

Leaders who guide missions and lead Army organizations; need a bachelor's degree by commissioning.

College students and graduates who want to lead

Score60%
5 attributes4 differences10 pros/cons
TL;DRVoice-ready

Enlisted Soldiers carry out the Army's missions; to enlist you need a high school diploma, GED or a plan to get one, plus a minimum ASVAB score. Commissioned Officers lead Soldiers and organizations and must hold a bachelor's degree by the time they are commissioned, through ROTC, the U.S. Military Academy at West Point, the 12-week Officer Candidate School or direct commission. Officers must be under 31 in the year of commissioning, or under 27 from West Point. Enlisted Soldiers can become officers through Green to Gold.

Deciding factor: Enlist to start serving without a degree; pursue a commission with a bachelor's degree to lead.

Key fact: Officers need a bachelor's degree by commissioning; enlisting needs a high school diploma or GED.

Our Verdict

AI-assisted

Enlisted: high school diploma or GED, ASVAB score, 10 weeks of Basic Combat Training. Officer: bachelor's degree by commissioning, through ROTC, West Point, OCS or direct commission. Talk to a recruiter about current requirements.

E

Choose Enlisted Soldier if

People who want to start serving without a college degree

Commissioned Officer

Choose Commissioned Officer if

College students and graduates who want to lead

Share this verdict

Get notified when Enlisted Soldier vs Commissioned Officer changes

One email when prices, specs or our verdict on Enlisted Soldier vs Commissioned Officer change. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.

Key Differences at a Glance

  • Education:High school diploma, GED or plan to get one vs Bachelor's degree by commissioning
  • Role:Carry out missions in a specialty vs Lead Soldiers and organizations
  • Entry training:Basic Combat Training (10 weeks) vs Basic Officer Leader Course
See all 4 differences

Key Differences

4 attributes compared head-to-head

ES
0Enlisted Soldier
Evenly matched4 ties
Commissioned Officer
0Commissioned Officer
  • Education

    Enlisted Soldier

    High school diploma, GED or plan to get one

    Commissioned Officer

    Bachelor's degree by commissioning

  • Role

    Enlisted Soldier

    Carry out missions in a specialty

    Commissioned Officer

    Lead Soldiers and organizations

  • Entry training

    Enlisted Soldier

    Basic Combat Training (10 weeks)

    Commissioned Officer

    Basic Officer Leader Course

  • Entry test

    Enlisted Soldier

    Minimum ASVAB score

    Commissioned Officer

    Background check and interview

Full Comparison

EEnlisted Soldier
Commissioned Officer
Age
Must meet the enlistment age requirement
17 to under 31 in year of commissioning (under 27 from West Point)
Citizenship
U.S. citizen or permanent resident
U.S. citizen by commissioning
Paths
Enlist through a recruiter
ROTC, West Point, OCS (12 weeks), direct commission
Move between
Green to Gold to earn a commission
Not applicable
Commitment examples
Set by enlistment contract
West Point: 5 years active + 3 IRR

Pros & Cons

6 pros·4 cons across both

ES
Commissioned Officer
ES

Enlisted Soldier

+3-2

Pros

High school diploma, GED or a plan to get one
Start after Basic Combat Training (10 weeks) and job training
Green to Gold program offers a path to a commission

Cons

Must meet a minimum score on the ASVAB
Leadership roles come with rank over time
Commissioned Officer

Commissioned Officer

+3-2

Pros

Lead Soldiers and organizations from the start
Paths through ROTC, West Point, OCS or direct commission
ROTC offered at more than 1,000 colleges

Cons

Bachelor's degree required by commissioning
ROTC scholarship and West Point carry service commitments

Frequently Asked Questions

6 questions

  1. No. To enlist you need a high school diploma, GED or a plan to get one. A bachelor's degree is required only to become a commissioned officer, by the time you are commissioned.

  2. ROTC in college, the U.S. Military Academy at West Point, Officer Candidate School (OCS) for enlisted Soldiers and civilians with degrees, or direct commission for some professions.

  3. Yes. Enlisted Soldiers can attend OCS with a degree, or earn a degree and commission through the Green to Gold program.

  4. You must be at least 17 and under 31 in the year of commissioning, or under 27 if you commission from West Point.

  5. OCS is a 12-week officer training program.

  1. At least five years of active duty and three years in the Individual Ready Reserve, for a total of eight years.

Analysis: Enlisted Soldier vs Commissioned Officer

Enlisted Soldiers carry out the Army's missions; to enlist you need a high school diploma, GED or a plan to get one, plus a minimum ASVAB score. Commissioned Officers lead Soldiers and organizations and must hold a bachelor's degree by the time they are commissioned, through ROTC, the U.S. Military Academy at West Point, the 12-week Officer Candidate School or direct commission. Officers must be under 31 in the year of commissioning, or under 27 from West Point. Enlisted Soldiers can become officers through Green to Gold.

Key takeaways

- Enlisting requires a high school diploma, GED or a plan to get one, and a minimum ASVAB score. - Officers need a bachelor's degree by the time they are commissioned. - Officer paths: ROTC, West Point, Officer Candidate School (OCS) and direct commission. - Officers must be at least 17 and under 31 in the year of commissioning, or under 27 from West Point. - Enlisted Soldiers can earn a commission through the Green to Gold program.

Read 10 more paragraphs

Role

Enlisted Soldiers carry out orders and specialize in a job. Commissioned Officers guide and oversee missions and lead Army organizations.

Education and age

To enlist you must be a U.S. citizen or permanent resident who meets the age requirement and has a high school diploma, GED or a plan to get one. Officers need a college degree by commissioning, and must be a U.S. citizen by then.

Training

1. Enlisted: 10 weeks of Basic Combat Training, then individual job training. 2. Officers: the Basic Officer Leader Course, after ROTC, West Point or OCS. 3. OCS is a 12-week course for enlisted Soldiers and civilians with college degrees.

Service commitments

A four-year ROTC scholarship requires four years full time as an officer after graduation, then four more years either extended or in the Individual Ready Reserve. West Point graduates commit to at least five years of active duty and three years in the Individual Ready Reserve.

Who should pick which

Enlist if you want to start serving now without a degree. Pursue a commission if you have or are earning a bachelor's degree and want to lead. Active duty vs National Guard covers the other main choice.

Drafted with AI from web research. How we research
Community feedback

Was this verdict helpful?

Explore More

Related comparisons and categories

Explore Entities

  • Enlisted Soldier
  • Commissioned Officer

People Also Compare

Last updated

Debate this on r/ThisOrThatDebate (run by the AversusB team)