Skip to main content

Carnival vs Royal Caribbean

A Versus B

Carnival Cruise Line, founded in 1972, runs 29 ships from 13 U.S. homeports on cruises from a weekend to a week or two, and opened its Celebration Key destination on Grand Bahama in summer 2025. Royal Caribbean, part of Royal Caribbean Group, runs 30 ships, including the Icon Class (Icon of the Seas debuted January 2024) and Oasis Class, and owns Perfect Day CocoCay and Royal Beach Clubs. Choose by ship style, departure port and itinerary length; compare current fares for your dates.

Carnival

Carnival

Carnival Cruise Line, founded 1972, with 29 ships and 13 U.S. homeports.

Short and week-long cruises from many U.S. ports

Score60%
VS

Royal Caribbean

Royal Caribbean International, part of Royal Caribbean Group, with 30 ships.

Big-ship resort-style cruises and private destinations

Score60%
5 attributes4 differences10 pros/cons
2Sources
12Data Points
TL;DRVoice-ready

Carnival Cruise Line, founded in 1972, runs 29 ships from 13 U.S. homeports on cruises from a weekend to a week or two, and opened its Celebration Key destination on Grand Bahama in summer 2025. Royal Caribbean, part of Royal Caribbean Group, runs 30 ships, including the Icon Class (Icon of the Seas debuted January 2024) and Oasis Class, and owns Perfect Day CocoCay and Royal Beach Clubs. Choose by ship style, departure port and itinerary length; compare current fares for your dates.

Deciding factor: Carnival for many U.S. ports and short cruises; Royal Caribbean for Icon and Oasis Class ships and private destinations.

Key fact: Carnival lists 29 ships; Royal Caribbean lists 30.

Our Verdict

AI-assisted

Carnival: 29 ships, 13 U.S. homeports, Celebration Key. Royal Caribbean: 30 ships, Icon and Oasis Class, Perfect Day CocoCay and Royal Beach Clubs. Compare fares and inclusions for your dates.

Carnival

Choose Carnival if

Short and week-long cruises from many U.S. ports

R

Choose Royal Caribbean if

Big-ship resort-style cruises and private destinations

Share this verdict

Get notified when Carnival vs Royal Caribbean changes

One email when prices, specs or our verdict on Carnival vs Royal Caribbean change. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.

Key Differences at a Glance

  • Ships:29 vs 30
  • Founded or heritage:1972 vs More than 50 years
  • Private destination:Celebration Key (Grand Bahama) vs Perfect Day CocoCay, Royal Beach Clubs
See all 4 differences

Key Differences

4 attributes compared head-to-head

Carnival
0Carnival
Evenly matched4 ties
RC
0Royal Caribbean
  • Ships

    Carnival

    29

    Royal Caribbean

    30

  • Founded or heritage

    Carnival

    1972

    Royal Caribbean

    More than 50 years

  • Private destination

    Carnival

    Celebration Key (Grand Bahama)

    Royal Caribbean

    Perfect Day CocoCay, Royal Beach Clubs

  • Reach

    Carnival

    13 U.S. homeports, 2 in Australia

    Royal Caribbean

    300+ destinations in 80 countries

Full Comparison

Carnival
RRoyal Caribbean
Fleet
29 ships
30 ships
Newest classes
Excel Class (Festivale 2027, Tropicale 2028)
Icon Class (Icon of the Seas, 2024); Hero of the Seas 2027
Cruise lengths
A weekend to a week or two
Varies by ship and region
Private destinations
Celebration Key (2025)
Perfect Day CocoCay (2019); Royal Beach Clubs from 2025
Parent
Carnival Cruise Line
Royal Caribbean Group (NYSE: RCL)

Pros & Cons

6 pros·4 cons across both

Carnival
RC
Carnival

Carnival

+3-2

Pros

29 ships with cruises from a weekend to a week or two
13 domestic homeports on every U.S. coast
Celebration Key private destination on Grand Bahama

Cons

Fewer ships than Royal Caribbean
Five new ships still to come through 2033
RC

Royal Caribbean

+3-2

Pros

Icon and Oasis Class ships with themed neighborhoods
Perfect Day CocoCay and Royal Beach Clubs
More than 300 destinations in 80 countries

Cons

Largest ships sail fewer itineraries
Some destinations are newer or still launching

Frequently Asked Questions

6 questions

  1. Royal Caribbean lists 30 ships and Carnival lists 29. Its newest ships belong to the Icon Class, which began in January 2024.

  2. Carnival lists 13 domestic homeports on every U.S. coast, two in Australia, and seasonal sailings in other regions.

  3. Carnival opened Celebration Key on Grand Bahama in summer 2025. Royal Caribbean has Perfect Day CocoCay in The Bahamas and Royal Beach Clubs in Paradise Island and Santorini, with Lelepa planned for October 2027.

  4. Royal Caribbean's first Icon Class ship, which debuted in January 2024. Star of the Seas and Legend of the Seas followed, and Hero of the Seas is due in 2027.

  5. Fares depend on ship, cabin, dates and promotions, so compare quotes for the same itinerary length and cabin type.

  1. Carnival offers short cruises from many U.S. ports; Royal Caribbean offers resort-style ships and private destinations. Choose by port, length and onboard style.

Analysis: Carnival vs Royal Caribbean

Carnival Cruise Line, founded in 1972, runs 29 ships from 13 U.S. homeports on cruises from a weekend to a week or two, and opened its Celebration Key destination on Grand Bahama in summer 2025. Royal Caribbean, part of Royal Caribbean Group, runs 30 ships, including the Icon Class (Icon of the Seas debuted January 2024) and Oasis Class, and owns Perfect Day CocoCay and Royal Beach Clubs. Choose by ship style, departure port and itinerary length; compare current fares for your dates.

Key takeaways

- Carnival: 29 ships, 13 U.S. homeports, founded 1972. - Royal Caribbean: 30 ships, more than 300 destinations in 80 countries. - Carnival's private destination is Celebration Key on Grand Bahama (summer 2025). - Royal Caribbean's are Perfect Day CocoCay (2019) and Royal Beach Clubs in Paradise Island and Santorini. - Both are adding ships: Carnival five through 2033; Royal Caribbean Hero of the Seas in 2027 and more.

Read 8 more paragraphs

Fleet

Carnival operates 29 ships, with fourth and fifth Excel Class ships (Carnival Festivale in 2027, Carnival Tropicale in 2028) among five new ships through 2033. Royal Caribbean has 30 ships. Its Icon Class began with Icon of the Seas in January 2024, followed by Star of the Seas and Legend of the Seas; Hero of the Seas is due in 2027 and a new Oasis Class ship in 2028.

Where they sail

Carnival sails from every U.S. coast with 13 domestic homeports, two in Australia, and seasonal sailings in other regions. Royal Caribbean visits more than 300 destinations in 80 countries on all seven continents.

Private destinations

1. Carnival: Celebration Key on Grand Bahama, opened summer 2025. 2. Royal Caribbean: Perfect Day CocoCay (2019), Royal Beach Club Paradise Island (December 2025), Royal Beach Club Santorini (April 2026), Royal Beach Club Lelepa (October 2027).

Who should pick which

Pick Carnival for many U.S. departure ports and cruises from a weekend up. Pick Royal Caribbean for Icon and Oasis Class ships and its private destinations. Compare fares, cabin types and what is included for your dates.

Drafted with AI from web research. How we research
Community feedback

Was this verdict helpful?

Explore More

Related comparisons and categories

Explore Entities

  • Carnival
  • Royal Caribbean

People Also Compare

Last updated

Debate this on r/ThisOrThatDebate (run by the AversusB team)