49ers vs Colts 2025: Super Bowls, Records & Comparison
The 49ers are a modern NFL powerhouse with 5 Super Bowl titles and a dominant defense, while the Colts are a historically significant franchise with 2 Super Bowl wins that has struggled with inconsistent quarterback play in recent years.
San Francisco 49ers
NFC West contender with elite defense and run-focused offensive system.
Fans seeking a consistently competitive team with strong coaching and a recent championship legacy
Indianapolis Colts
Rebuilding AFC South team developing young QB Anthony Richardson.
Long-term optimists seeking a rebuilding franchise with historical prestige and potential upside
Quick Answer
AI SummaryThe 49ers are a modern NFL powerhouse with 5 Super Bowl titles and a dominant defense, while the Colts are a historically significant franchise with 2 Super Bowl wins that has struggled with inconsistent quarterback play in recent years.
Our Verdict
AI-assistedThe 49ers are the superior franchise in 2024, with a dominant recent trajectory, elite coaching, and championship pedigree. Choose the 49ers if you value consistent excellence, innovative coaching systems, and a winning culture. Choose the Colts if you prefer a historic franchise with potential for rebuilding around young talent like Anthony Richardson, though they require patience given their current 8-9 record and playoff drought.
Was this verdict helpful?
Choose San Francisco 49ers if
Best pickFans seeking a consistently competitive team with strong coaching and a recent championship legacy
Choose Indianapolis Colts if
Long-term optimists seeking a rebuilding franchise with historical prestige and potential upside
Track this comparison
Get notified when prices change, new specs ship, or our verdict updates.
Triggers: price change new spec verdict update
No spam. Stop anytime.
Key Differences at a Glance
- Super Bowl Championships:✓ San Francisco 49ers wins(5 titles (1982, 1985, 1989, 1995, 2020) vs 2 titles (2007, 1971 as Baltimore Colts))
- Recent Playoff Success (2019-2024):✓ San Francisco 49ers wins(3 Super Bowl appearances, 1 championship vs 0 playoff wins in last 5 seasons)
- Head Coach Tenure & Stability:✓ San Francisco 49ers wins(Kyle Shanahan since 2017 (7 seasons) vs Shane Steichen since 2023 (2 seasons))
Key Facts & Figures
75 numeric metrics compared
| Metric | San Francisco 49ers | Indianapolis Colts | Ratio |
|---|---|---|---|
| Points Per Game (Offense)(PPG) | 27.3 | 23.1 | |
| Points Allowed Per Game (Defense)(PPG) | 18.2 | 24.7 | |
| Passing Yards Per Game(yards) | 259.8 | 287.3 | |
| Playoff Appearances (Last 5 Years)(seasons) | 4 | 0 | |
| Head Coach Winning Percentage(%) | 71.4% | 56.3% | |
| Franchise Super Bowl Wins(total) | 5 | 1 | |
| 2025 Season Wins(wins) | 12 | — | — |
| Average Passing Yards Per Game (2025)(yards) | 234.2 | — | — |
| Average Rushing Yards Per Game (2025)(yards) | 148.7 | — | — |
| Points Allowed Per Game (2025)(points) | 18.9 | — | — |
| Super Bowl Appearances(count) | 6 | — | — |
| Head Coach Win Percentage(percent) | 63.2% | — | — |
| Team Payroll (2025 Approx)(millions) | $267M | — | — |
| Turnovers(count) | 0 | — | — |
| Yards Per Play(yards) | 3.9 | — | — |
| Fumbles Lost(count) | 0 | — | — |
| Interceptions Thrown(count) | 0 | — | — |
| Total Turnovers (Fumbles + INTs)(count) | 0 | — | — |
| 2026 Roster Building Moves(deals) | 14 reserve/future deals | — | — |
| All-Time Head-to-Head Win Percentage(%) | 64.5% | — | — |
| Super Bowl Championships(titles) | 5 (1988, 1989, 1994, 1995, 2021) | — | — |
| Super Bowl Championships(titles) | 5 championships | 2 | |
| Playoff Appearances (2020-2024)(appearances) | 5 consecutive | 0 of 5 | |
| Super Bowl Appearances (2019-2024)(appearances) | 3 | 0 | |
| Hall of Famers (All-Time)(inductees) | 14 | 6 | |
| Head Coach Tenure(seasons) | 7 seasons (Kyle Shanahan, 2017-present) | 2 seasons (Shane Steichen, 2023-present) | |
| Franchise Valuation (2024)(billions USD) | $8.1B | $3.8B | |
| Most Recent Super Bowl Victory(year) | 1995 | — | — |
| Current Head Coach Winning Percentage(percentage) | Kyle Shanahan .606 (54-35) | — | — |
| Division Titles Won(titles) | 16 | — | — |
| Conference Championship Appearances(total) | 19 | — | — |
| Playoff Appearances (2001-2026)(appearances) | 13 | — | — |
| QB Passing Yards (2024 Season)(yards) | 4,694 (Brock Purdy) | — | — |
| QB Touchdown-to-Interception Ratio (2024)(ratio) | 3.44 (31 TDs / 9 INTs) | — | — |
| Head Coach Current Tenure(seasons) | 8 seasons (Kyle Shanahan, since 2017) | — | — |
| Division Titles (All-Time)(titles) | 19 | — | — |
| All-Time Winning Percentage(percentage) | .525 (586-529-16) | 43.8% | |
| Playoff Appearances (2015-2025)(appearances) | 7 appearances | — | — |
| Hall of Famers(players) | 14 Hall of Famers | — | — |
| Current QB Passer Rating (2025)(rating) | 107.2 (Brock Purdy) | — | — |
| Years Since Last Super Bowl Appearance(years) | 1 year (2024 won) | — | — |
| Points Per Game (2024)(PPG) | 25.1 | — | — |
| Team Passing Yards (2024)(yards) | 4,694 (Purdy leader) | — | — |
| Team Rushing Yards (2024)(yards) | 1,459 (McCaffrey leader) | — | — |
| Pass Defense Ranking (2024)(rank) | 12th - 226.5 YPG allowed | — | — |
| Team Sacks (2024)(sacks) | 48 | — | — |
| Team Interceptions (2024)(INTs) | 16 | — | — |
| QB Completion Percentage (Leader)(%) | 68.2% (Purdy) | — | — |
| Red Zone Efficiency (2024)(%) | 72% | — | — |
| Quarterback Passing Touchdowns(TDs) | 28 | — | — |
| Pass Completion Percentage(%) | 67.4% | — | — |
| Total Defense Ranking(ranking (1-32)) | 5th | — | — |
| Sacks Allowed(total) | 28 | — | — |
| Run-Pass Play Distribution(run %) | 52% run | — | — |
| Defense Ranking(NFL rank (1-32)) | 7th | 24th | |
| Yards Allowed Per Game(yards) | 315.1 | 351.2 | |
| Rushing Yards Per Game(yards) | 130.4 | 98.7 | |
| Starting QB Passer Rating(rating) | 96.8 (Purdy) | 81.2 (Richardson) | |
| Head Coach Experience(seasons with team) | 8 seasons | 1 season | |
| Playoff Wins (Last 3 Seasons)(wins) | 5 wins | 0 wins | |
| Super Bowl Appearances (Last 5 Years)(appearances) | 1 (SB LVIII) | 0 | |
| Points Per Game (2025 Season)(PPG) | 24.3 | 24.3 | |
| Points Allowed Per Game (2025 Season)(PPG) | 22.8 | 22.8 | |
| Rushing Yards Per Game (2025 Season)(YPG) | 108.2 | 108.2 | |
| Passing Yards Per Game (2025 Season)(YPG) | 285.9 | 285.9 | |
| Sacks Per Game (2025 Season)(SPG) | 2.1 | 2.1 | |
| Turnovers Forced (2025 Season)(Total) | 18 | 18 | |
| Third Down Conversion Rate (2025)(%) | 42.1% | 42.1% | |
| All-Time Winning Percentage (1984-2026)(percentage) | .549 | .549 | |
| Playoff Appearances (2000-2026)(appearances) | 13 appearances | 13 appearances | |
| Division Titles (2000-2026)(titles) | 9 titles | 9 titles | |
| AFC/NFC Championship Game Appearances (2000-2026)(appearances) | 4 appearances | 4 appearances | |
| Head Coach Tenure (Current)(years) | 6+ years (Frank Reich, 2018-present) | 6+ years (Frank Reich, 2018-present) | |
| Consecutive Playoff Seasons (Best Streak)(seasons) | 8 consecutive (2002-2009) | 8 consecutive (2002-2009) | |
| Total Regular Season Wins (2000-2026)(wins) | 370+ wins | 370+ wins |
Sourced from publicly available data ·
Key Differences
7 attributes compared head-to-head
- 5 titles (1982, 1985, 1989, 1995, 2020)(winner)Super Bowl Championships2 titles (2007, 1971 as Baltimore Colts)
- 3 Super Bowl appearances, 1 championship(winner)Recent Playoff Success (2019-2024)0 playoff wins in last 5 seasons
- Kyle Shanahan since 2017 (7 seasons)(winner)Head Coach Tenure & StabilityShane Steichen since 2023 (2 seasons)
- 511-410-16 (.555 winning percentage)(winner)Franchise All-Time Win-Loss Record535-686-13 (.438 winning percentage)
- 12-5 (1st NFC West)(winner)2024 Season Record8-9 (3rd AFC South, missed playoffs)
- 14 (Young, Montana, Rice, Lott, Walsh, others)(winner)Hall of Famers Produced6 (Manning, Unitas, Dickerson, Faulk, others)
- Brock Purdy consistent starter(winner)Starting Quarterback Stability (2023-2024)Anthony Richardson (injury-plagued), Gardner Minshew
- Super Bowl Championships
San Francisco 49ers
5 titles (1982, 1985, 1989, 1995, 2020)(winner)
Indianapolis Colts
2 titles (2007, 1971 as Baltimore Colts)
- Recent Playoff Success (2019-2024)
San Francisco 49ers
3 Super Bowl appearances, 1 championship(winner)
Indianapolis Colts
0 playoff wins in last 5 seasons
- Head Coach Tenure & Stability
San Francisco 49ers
Kyle Shanahan since 2017 (7 seasons)(winner)
Indianapolis Colts
Shane Steichen since 2023 (2 seasons)
- Franchise All-Time Win-Loss Record
San Francisco 49ers
511-410-16 (.555 winning percentage)(winner)
Indianapolis Colts
535-686-13 (.438 winning percentage)
- 2024 Season Record
San Francisco 49ers
12-5 (1st NFC West)(winner)
Indianapolis Colts
8-9 (3rd AFC South, missed playoffs)
- Hall of Famers Produced
San Francisco 49ers
14 (Young, Montana, Rice, Lott, Walsh, others)(winner)
Indianapolis Colts
6 (Manning, Unitas, Dickerson, Faulk, others)
- Starting Quarterback Stability (2023-2024)
San Francisco 49ers
Brock Purdy consistent starter(winner)
Indianapolis Colts
Anthony Richardson (injury-plagued), Gardner Minshew
Full Comparison
| Attribute | San Francisco 49ers | Indianapolis Colts |
|---|---|---|
| 2025 Win-Loss Record(wins-losses) | 13-4(winner) | 8-9 |
| 2025 Season Wins(wins) | 12 | — |
| All-Time Winning Percentage (1984-2026)(percentage) | .549 | — |
| Total Regular Season Wins (2000-2026)(wins) | 370+ wins | — |
| Points Per Game (Offense)(PPG) | 27.3(winner) | 23.1 |
| Points Allowed Per Game (Defense)(PPG) | 18.2(winner) | 24.7 |
| Points Allowed Per Game (2025)(points) | 18.9 | — |
| Defense Ranking(NFL rank (1-32)) | 7th(winner) | 24th |
| Yards Allowed Per Game(yards) | 315.1(winner) | 351.2 |
| Passing Yards Per Game(yards) | 259.8 | 287.3(winner) |
| Average Passing Yards Per Game (2025)(yards) | 234.2 | — |
| Average Rushing Yards Per Game (2025)(yards) | 148.7 | — |
| Rushing Yards Per Game(yards) | 130.4(winner) | 98.7 |
| Starting QB Passer Rating(rating) | 96.8 (Purdy)(winner) | 81.2 (Richardson) |
| Playoff Appearances (Last 5 Years)(seasons) | 4(winner) | 0 |
| Head Coach Winning Percentage(%) | 71.4%(winner) | 56.3% |
| Franchise Super Bowl Wins(total) | 5(winner) | 1 |
| Years Since Last Super Bowl Appearance(years) | 1 year (2024 won) | — |
| Super Bowl Appearances(count) | 6 | — |
| Super Bowl Championships(titles) | 5 (1988, 1989, 1994, 1995, 2021) | — |
| Head Coach Win Percentage(percent) | 63.2% | — |
| Head Coach Experience(seasons with team) | 8 seasons(winner) | 1 season |
| Team Payroll (2025 Approx)(millions) | $267M | — |
| Turnovers(count) | 0 | — |
| Fumbles Lost(count) | 0 | — |
| Total Turnovers (Fumbles + INTs)(count) | 0 | — |
| Fumbles (Total-Lost)(count) | 0-0 | — |
| Yards Per Play(yards) | 3.9 | — |
| QB Touchdown-to-Interception Ratio (2024)(ratio) | 3.44 (31 TDs / 9 INTs) | — |
| Red Zone Efficiency (2024)(%) | 72% | — |
| Interceptions Thrown(count) | 0 | — |
| 2026 Roster Building Moves(deals) | 14 reserve/future deals | — |
| Game Execution Rating(score) | Excellent - Clean execution | — |
| 2024 Win-Loss Record(wins-losses) | 8-9 | 8-9 |
| Win-Loss Record (2025 Season)(Record) | 7-6 | — |
| All-Time Head-to-Head Win Percentage(%) | 64.5% | — |
| 2025 Starting QB Passing Yards(yards) | Brock Purdy 2,167 yards | — |
| Points Per Game (2025 H2H)(PPG) | 19.0 | — |
| Home Win Percentage (H2H)(%) | 75.0% | — |
| QB Completion Percentage (2025)(%) | 69.4% (Brock Purdy) | — |
| QB Completion Percentage (Leader)(%) | 68.2% (Purdy) | — |
| Primary RB Rushing Yards (2025)(yards) | Christian McCaffrey depth role | — |
| Years in NFL(seasons) | 80 seasons overall | — |
| Hall of Famers(players) | 14 Hall of Famers | — |
| Super Bowl Championships(titles) | 5 championships(winner) | 2 |
| All-Time Regular Season Record(wins-losses) | 641-618 | — |
| Conference Championship Appearances(total) | 19 | — |
| 2024 Regular Season Record(wins-losses) | 12-5 (.706 winning %) | 8-9(winner) |
| Playoff Appearances (2020-2024)(appearances) | 5 consecutive(winner) | 0 of 5 |
| Super Bowl Appearances (2019-2024)(appearances) | 3(winner) | 0 |
| Most Recent Super Bowl Victory(year) | 1995 | — |
| Playoff Appearances (2015-2025)(appearances) | 7 appearances | — |
| Hall of Famers (All-Time)(inductees) | 14(winner) | 6 |
| Head Coach Tenure(seasons) | 7 seasons (Kyle Shanahan, 2017-present)(winner) | 2 seasons (Shane Steichen, 2023-present) |
| Franchise Valuation (2024)(billions USD) | $8.1B(winner) | $3.8B |
| Current Head Coach Winning Percentage(percentage) | Kyle Shanahan .606 (54-35) | — |
| Division Titles Won(titles) | 16 | — |
| Playoff Appearances (2001-2026)(appearances) | 13 | — |
| QB Passing Yards (2024 Season)(yards) | 4,694 (Brock Purdy) | — |
| Points Per Game (2024)(PPG) | 25.1 | — |
| Team Passing Yards (2024)(yards) | 4,694 (Purdy leader) | — |
| Team Rushing Yards (2024)(yards) | 1,459 (McCaffrey leader) | — |
| Points Per Game (2025 Season)(PPG) | 24.3 | — |
Show 2 more attributesRushing Yards Per Game (2025 Season)(YPG) 108.2 — Passing Yards Per Game (2025 Season)(YPG) 285.9 — | ||
| 2024 Season Record(wins-losses) | 12-5 (4th seed, NFC) | — |
| Head Coach Current Tenure(seasons) | 8 seasons (Kyle Shanahan, since 2017) | — |
| Head Coach Tenure (Current)(years) | 6+ years (Frank Reich, 2018-present) | — |
| Division Titles (All-Time)(titles) | 19 | — |
| Division Titles (2000-2026)(titles) | 9 titles | — |
| All-Time Winning Percentage(percentage) | .525 (586-529-16)(winner) | 43.8% |
| 2025 Season Record(wins-losses) | 12-5 (.706) | — |
| Current QB Passer Rating (2025)(rating) | 107.2 (Brock Purdy) | — |
| Pass Completion Percentage(%) | 67.4% | — |
| Division Standing(rank) | 1st Place NFC West | — |
| Pass Defense Ranking (2024)(rank) | 12th - 226.5 YPG allowed | — |
| Team Sacks (2024)(sacks) | 48 | — |
| Team Interceptions (2024)(INTs) | 16 | — |
| Total Defense Ranking(ranking (1-32)) | 5th | — |
| Points Allowed Per Game (2025 Season)(PPG) | 22.8 | — |
Show 2 more attributesSacks Per Game (2025 Season)(SPG) 2.1 — Turnovers Forced (2025 Season)(Total) 18 — | ||
| 2025 Regular Season Record(wins-losses) | 12-5 | — |
| Quarterback Passing Touchdowns(TDs) | 28 | — |
| Sacks Allowed(total) | 28 | — |
| Run-Pass Play Distribution(run %) | 52% run | — |
| Playoff Wins (Last 3 Seasons)(wins) | 5 wins(winner) | 0 wins |
| Super Bowl Appearances (Last 5 Years)(appearances) | 1 (SB LVIII)(winner) | 0 |
| Third Down Conversion Rate (2025)(%) | 42.1% | — |
| Playoff Appearances (2000-2026)(appearances) | 13 appearances | — |
| AFC/NFC Championship Game Appearances (2000-2026)(appearances) | 4 appearances | — |
| Consecutive Playoff Seasons (Best Streak)(seasons) | 8 consecutive (2002-2009) | — |
San Francisco 49ersIndianapolis ColtsShow 2 more attributes
Show 2 more attributes
Pros & Cons
10 pros·5 cons across both
San Francisco 49ers
Pros
- 5 Super Bowl championships across franchise history
- Kyle Shanahan's innovative offensive system (ranked #1 in 2024 for offensive efficiency)
- Dynamic roster with elite defensive talent (Nick Bosa, Fred Warner, Jaquiski Tartt)
- Consistent playoff appearances (4 of last 5 seasons)
- Strong financial franchise valuation ($8.1 billion as of 2024)
Cons
- Inconsistent quarterback durability issues (Brock Purdy injury concerns, previous reliance on injured QBs)
- High salary cap pressure limiting flexibility
Indianapolis Colts
Pros
- Legendary quarterback history (John Unitas, Peyton Manning legacy)
- Young franchise cornerstone in Anthony Richardson (2023 #1 overall pick)
- Emerging defensive talent and cap space for flexibility
- Historic market presence in Indianapolis with strong community support
- Shane Steichen's offensive expertise (previously Eagles OC in 2022)
Cons
- 8-9 record in 2024 with 0 playoff wins in last 5 seasons indicates prolonged decline
- Anthony Richardson plagued by injuries limiting organizational momentum
- 14-game playoff drought since 2014 (longest active drought among their division)
Frequently Asked Questions
5 questions
The Colts have struggled with quarterback instability and inconsistent roster construction since Peyton Manning's departure in 2012. Anthony Richardson, the 2023 #1 pick, has dealt with persistent injuries limiting his development. The team went 8-9 in 2024 and has not won a playoff game since 2014, representing a 10-year competitive decline.
Resources & Learn More
Curated sources to dive deeper
Wikipedia
Related Comparisons
12 more to explore
Indianapolis Colts vs Seattle Seahawks
sportsCleveland Browns vs San Francisco 49ers
sportsSan Francisco 49ers vs Los Angeles Rams
sportsSan Francisco 49ers vs Cleveland Browns
sportsLeBron vs Jordan
sportsNeymar vs Mbappé
sportsAli vs Tyson
sportsReal Madrid vs Barcelona
sportsDenver Nuggets vs LA Clippers
sportsLA Clippers vs Denver Nuggets
sportsCristiano Ronaldo vs Neymar
sportsGretzky vs Lemieux
sports
Related Articles
5 articles
- sports2 min read
Does Hulu Have Live Sports in 2026? NFL, NBA, MLB vs ESPN+ & Peacock
Wondering if Hulu offers live sports streaming? We break down Hulu's sports coverage, compare it with ESPN+ and Peacock, and help you find the best streaming service for football, basketball, and baseball in 2026.
Read article - sports2 min read
World Cup 2026 Teams Compared: Best Countries by Stats
As the 2026 FIFA World Cup approaches, we analyze the top qualifying nations by key performance metrics. Compare team statistics, rankings, and historical performance to see which countries have the best chance of winning.
Read article - sports2 min read
Argentina vs France World Cup 2026: Head-to-Head Stats & Prediction
As the 2026 FIFA World Cup approaches, Argentina and France remain among the tournament favorites. We analyze their head-to-head record, current squad strength, and key matchups to predict what could happen if these powerhouses meet.
Read article - sports2 min read
Brazil vs England World Cup 2026: Head-to-Head Stats, History & Prediction
As Brazil and England prepare for potential World Cup 2026 matchups, we break down their historical rivalry, current squad strength, and statistical advantages. Discover what past encounters reveal and why this fixture remains one of football's most compelling clashes.
Read article - sports2 min read
Kobe vs LeBron: 5 Stats That Settle the GOAT Debate
The Kobe vs LeBron debate has raged for 20 years. These 5 statistics — scoring records, championships, MVP awards, longevity, and playmaking — cut through the noise and give the clearest picture of who wins each category.
Read article
Explore More
Related comparisons and categories