The Cleveland Browns have a more recent playoff appearance (2020) and superior recent regular season performance, while the New York Giants last made the playoffs in 2016 and have struggled more consistently over the past decade. The Browns have outperformed the Giants in win-loss records since 2018.
Cleveland Browns vs New York Giants — Side-by-side comparison on A Versus B
The Browns have momentum with a more recent playoff run (2020) and better recent regular season records, making them the choice for fans seeking recent success and playoff potential. The Giants have superior historical credentials with 4 Super Bowl victories and deeper franchise pedigree, appealing to those valuing legacy and past championship experience. Both teams finished 3-14 in 2024, signaling current rebuilding phases.
Compare Cleveland Browns vs New York Giants
AFC North defensive specialist team with balanced roster and strong pass defense
NFC East franchise based in East Rutherford, New Jersey; founded 1925.
Cleveland Browns vs New York Giants — Comparison Data
Structured comparison data for Cleveland Browns vs New York Giants with 163 attributes.
Average Points Per Game vs This Opponent
Leading Running Back Rushing Yards (2025)
Primary Running Back Rushing Yards (2025)
QB Touchdown-to-Interception Ratio (2024)
All-Time Head-to-Head Record (Since 1996)
Offensive Points Per Game (2023-24 Season)
Conference Championships (pre-Super Bowl era & modern)
2025 Defense Ranking (Yards Allowed/Game)
Head Coach Regular Season Win Percentage
Winning Percentage (last 10 seasons: 2015-2024)
Division Titles (Last 25 Years: 1999-2024)
Regular Season Win Percentage (2020-2026)
Starting Quarterback MVP Awards (Career)
Consecutive Playoff Appearances (2020-2026)
Postseason Win Percentage (Last 25 Years)
Cleveland Browns vs New York Giants — Attribute Category Vocabulary
Taxonomy of attribute categories used to classify comparison data for Cleveland Browns vs New York Giants.
When did the Browns last make the playoffs?
The Cleveland Browns last made the playoffs in the 2020 NFL season, ending an 18-year playoff drought. They lost to the Kansas City Chiefs in the divisional round.
How many Super Bowls have the Giants won?
The New York Giants have won 4 Super Bowl championships: Super Bowl XXI (1986), Super Bowl XXV (1990), Super Bowl XXVIII (1992 season, played 1993), and Super Bowl XXXIV (1998 season, played 1999).
Which team is in a better division for playoff contention?
The Browns play in the more competitive AFC North (Baltimore Ravens, Pittsburgh Steelers, Cincinnati Bengals), while Giants are in the NFC East (Dallas Cowboys, Philadelphia Eagles, Washington). The AFC North is historically stronger, but both divisions offer playoff pathways.
What is Deshaun Watson's status with the Browns?
Deshaun Watson signed a 5-year, $230 million fully guaranteed contract with the Browns in 2022, making him one of the highest-paid QBs in NFL history. He has appeared in 22 games (2023-2024) with mixed results as the team has struggled.
Why haven't the Browns won a Super Bowl despite reaching the AFC Championship?
The Browns' last AFC Championship was in 1965 before the Super Bowl era began. Despite competitive teams in 1986-1989, injuries and playoff luck prevented them from reaching Super Bowls. The franchise has had historical organizational challenges and quarterback inconsistencies that prevented sustained championship runs.