HelloFresh is the larger, more established meal kit service with greater recipe variety (100+ weekly options) and wider US coverage, while Dinnerly is a budget-focused alternative under the same parent company offering 40+ recipes weekly at significantly lower prices ($1.47 per serving vs $2.49).
Dinnerly vs HelloFresh — Side-by-side comparison on A Versus B
Budget-friendly meal kit delivery service with simple recipes and lowest per-serving cost.
Market-leading meal kit service with 100+ weekly recipes, faster delivery, and extensive dietary options.
Average Cost Per Serving. Weekly Recipe Variety. US Geographic Coverage. Customer Satisfaction Rating. Prep Time Per Meal. Market Share (US Meal Kits). Nutritional Info Included
Choose Dinnerly if you're budget-conscious and prioritize affordability over recipe variety—it delivers excellent value at nearly 41% lower cost per serving with solid customer ratings. Choose HelloFresh if you want maximum recipe selection, brand recognition, and don't mind paying more for greater flexibility and established reputation as the market leader.
Dinnerly: 20–30 minutes | HelloFresh: 25–40 minutes
Dinnerly: 2-4 person meals | HelloFresh: N/A
Dinnerly: 3 (vegetarian, keto, gluten-free) | HelloFresh: N/A
Dinnerly: 20-30 minutes | HelloFresh: N/A
Dinnerly: 6+ dietary filters | HelloFresh: 8 options
Dinnerly: 2 plans (Standard, Classic) | HelloFresh: N/A
Dinnerly: 8-10 recipes | HelloFresh: 30+ meals
Dinnerly: 20-30 minutes | HelloFresh: 25-35 minutes
Dinnerly: 3 plans | HelloFresh: 10+ plans
Dinnerly: $175 (estimated) | HelloFresh: $215 (estimated)
Dinnerly: 4.3/5 | HelloFresh: 4.1/5 (8,500 reviews)
Dinnerly: 95% recyclable | HelloFresh: 90%
Dinnerly: 9 meals | HelloFresh: 110 meals
Dinnerly: 4-6 servings | HelloFresh: 4-6 servings
Dinnerly: $2.49 (average) | HelloFresh: $4.49 (average)
Dinnerly: 5–7 days | HelloFresh: 2–4 days
Monthly Cost (Family of 4, 3 meals/week)
Dinnerly: $240 (estimated) | HelloFresh: $420 (estimated)
Dinnerly: 12 years (since 2014) | HelloFresh: 15 years (since 2011)
Dinnerly: None (standard meals only) | HelloFresh: 8+ (vegan, keto, pescatarian, low-carb, organic, calorie-controlled, gluten-free, paleo)
Dinnerly: N/A | HelloFresh: 30-40 recipes
Dinnerly: N/A | HelloFresh: Fixed subscription-based
Dinnerly: N/A | HelloFresh: 3-6 person family sizes
Dinnerly: N/A | HelloFresh: Excellent consumer satisfaction
Dinnerly: N/A | HelloFresh: Skip/pause options
Dinnerly: N/A | HelloFresh: Growth trajectory with influencer partnerships
Dinnerly: N/A | HelloFresh: Stable regardless of order frequency
Dinnerly: N/A | HelloFresh: Premium pricing
Dinnerly: N/A | HelloFresh: Standard recyclable materials
Dinnerly: N/A | HelloFresh: Limited swaps
Dinnerly: N/A | HelloFresh: Best Overall Meal Delivery
Dinnerly: N/A | HelloFresh: Established leader
Dinnerly: N/A | HelloFresh: 20-25 options
Dinnerly: N/A | HelloFresh: 30-60 minutes
Dinnerly: N/A | HelloFresh: 15+ countries
Dinnerly: N/A | HelloFresh: Yes, weekly commitment
Dinnerly: N/A | HelloFresh: Carbon-neutral certified
Dinnerly: N/A | HelloFresh: High (choose each week)
Dinnerly: N/A | HelloFresh: 0% organic certified
Dinnerly: N/A | HelloFresh: Partial/Unverified
Dinnerly: N/A | HelloFresh: $120-144 (6 meals)
Dinnerly: N/A | HelloFresh: Not certified
Dinnerly: N/A | HelloFresh: Non-GMO sourced (unverified)
Dinnerly: N/A | HelloFresh: 0-5% certified organic
Dinnerly: N/A | HelloFresh: 25% vegetarian options
Dinnerly: N/A | HelloFresh: No, standard shipping
Dinnerly: N/A | HelloFresh: 4+ million customers
Dinnerly: N/A | HelloFresh: 13 countries
Dinnerly: N/A | HelloFresh: 2-4 servings
Dinnerly: N/A | HelloFresh: 25-35 minutes
Dinnerly: N/A | HelloFresh: 40-50 options
Dinnerly: N/A | HelloFresh: 20-30 minutes
Dinnerly: N/A | HelloFresh: 10+ dietary filters
Dinnerly: N/A | HelloFresh: 550-850 kcal
Dinnerly: N/A | HelloFresh: Calories, macros listed
How to choose between Dinnerly and HelloFresh
Dinnerly vs HelloFresh — Structured Comparison Data
Machine-readable comparison dataset for Dinnerly vs HelloFresh. Contains 109 attribute comparisons, 5 FAQ pairs.
Dinnerly vs HelloFresh — Attribute Category Vocabulary
Taxonomy of attribute categories used to classify comparison data for Dinnerly vs HelloFresh.
How much can I save with Dinnerly vs HelloFresh?
Dinnerly costs $1.47 per serving compared to HelloFresh at $2.49—a difference of $1.02 per serving or approximately $61.00 per month on a typical 2-person, 3-meals-per-week plan. Over a year, choosing Dinnerly saves roughly $732 for that household.
Does HelloFresh have more recipe options?
Yes, HelloFresh offers 100+ weekly recipes across 20+ cuisines including specialty diets (keto, vegan, plant-based, gluten-free), while Dinnerly provides 40-50 simpler recipes focused on straightforward cooking. HelloFresh provides more than double the variety.
Are both services available in my state?
HelloFresh delivers to 100% of the continental US plus Alaska and Hawaii. Dinnerly covers 98% of the continental US, with limited availability in certain rural areas. Check the service's ZIP code lookup tool on their websites to confirm availability in your location.
Dinnerly has a 4.2/5-star rating while HelloFresh has 4.1/5 stars based on aggregated customer reviews across major platforms. Dinnerly customers particularly praise value for money, while HelloFresh users highlight recipe variety and customization options.
How much prep time do these meals require?
Both services require approximately 30 minutes of prep and cooking time. Dinnerly emphasizes efficiency with 6-ingredient maximum recipes, while HelloFresh meals may take slightly longer (30-40 minutes) due to more complex ingredients and techniques in their varied recipe selection.
How to Choose Between Dinnerly and HelloFresh
Average Cost Per Serving: Dinnerly has $1.47, while HelloFresh has $2.49.
Weekly Recipe Variety: Dinnerly has 40-50 options, while HelloFresh has 100+ options.
US Geographic Coverage: Dinnerly has 98% of continental US, while HelloFresh has 100% of continental US.
Customer Satisfaction Rating: Dinnerly has 4.2/5 stars, while HelloFresh has 4.1/5 stars.
Prep Time Per Meal: Dinnerly has 30 minutes, while HelloFresh has 30-40 minutes.
Market Share (US Meal Kits): Dinnerly has 8%, while HelloFresh has 32%.
Nutritional Info Included: Dinnerly has Yes, all recipes, while HelloFresh has Yes, all recipes.