Cloudflare vs CloudFront
type: Article
description: Cloudflare is a standalone CDN and security platform with competitive pricing starting at $20/month, while AWS CloudFront is tightly integrated with AWS services and charges per GB transferred with no minimum fee. Cloudflare excels for independent websites seeking simplicity, while CloudFront wins for enterprises already in the AWS ecosystem.
language: en-US
date published: 2026-07-09T14:39:38.376Z
date created: 2026-07-09T14:39:38.376Z
date modified: 2026-07-09T14:39:38.749Z
content reference time: 2026-07-09T14:39:38.749Z
author: A Versus B
publisher: A Versus B
about: Cloudflare
about: AWS CloudFront
abstract: Cloudflare is a standalone CDN and security platform with competitive pricing starting at $20/month, while AWS CloudFront is tightly integrated with AWS services and charges per GB transferred with no minimum fee. Cloudflare excels for independent websites seeking simplicity, while CloudFront wins for enterprises already in the AWS ecosystem.
text: Pricing Model. DDoS Protection Included. WAF Features. Global Edge Nodes. Average Latency (US-EU). AWS Integration. Setup Time
conclusion text: Choose Cloudflare if you need predictable monthly costs, built-in DDoS/WAF protection, and want a platform independent of AWS. Choose CloudFront if you're already operating within AWS with heavy data transfer needs, require maximum global latency performance, or need tight integration with Lambda@Edge and other AWS services.
additional property: .com Domain Registration Price
  type: PropertyValue
  value: Cloudflare: $10.20 | AWS CloudFront: N/A
additional property: Annual Savings (100 domain portfolio)
  type: PropertyValue
  value: Cloudflare: $130+ | AWS CloudFront: N/A
additional property: User Interface Complexity
  type: PropertyValue
  value: Cloudflare: Developer-focused | AWS CloudFront: N/A
additional property: DNS Provider Flexibility
  type: PropertyValue
  value: Cloudflare: Cloudflare DNS primary | AWS CloudFront: N/A
additional property: Integrated Security Services
  type: PropertyValue
  value: Cloudflare: DDoS, threat intelligence, WARP, Magic | AWS CloudFront: N/A
additional property: Customer Support Response
  type: PropertyValue
  value: Cloudflare: Community & documentation | AWS CloudFront: N/A
additional property: .com Renewal Price
  type: PropertyValue
  value: Cloudflare: $10.20 (at-cost) | AWS CloudFront: N/A
additional property: Ideal for Enterprise Scale
  type: PropertyValue
  value: Cloudflare: Excellent for enterprise | AWS CloudFront: N/A
additional property: Customer Satisfaction Rating
  type: PropertyValue
  value: Cloudflare: 4.5 stars | AWS CloudFront: N/A
additional property: Review Count
  type: PropertyValue
  value: Cloudflare: 476 reviews | AWS CloudFront: N/A
additional property: Fortune 500 Adoption
  type: PropertyValue
  value: Cloudflare: 30% | AWS CloudFront: N/A
additional property: Performance Optimization Score
  type: PropertyValue
  value: Cloudflare: Industry standard | AWS CloudFront: N/A
additional property: Pricing Accessibility
  type: PropertyValue
  value: Cloudflare: Highly accessible with strong freemium | AWS CloudFront: N/A
additional property: AI Integration Commitment
  type: PropertyValue
  value: Cloudflare: 74% planning to expand | AWS CloudFront: N/A
additional property: Developer Tool Specialization
  type: PropertyValue
  value: Cloudflare: Comprehensive and standardized | AWS CloudFront: N/A
additional property: Global Network Coverage
  type: PropertyValue
  value: Cloudflare: Superior and broader distribution | AWS CloudFront: N/A
additional property: Customer Satisfaction
  type: PropertyValue
  value: Cloudflare: 4.5 stars | AWS CloudFront: N/A
additional property: Paying Customers
  type: PropertyValue
  value: Cloudflare: 265,000+ | AWS CloudFront: N/A
additional property: Annual Revenue Growth (YoY)
  type: PropertyValue
  value: Cloudflare: 31% (Q3 2025: $562M) | AWS CloudFront: N/A
additional property: Net Income Achievement
  type: PropertyValue
  value: Cloudflare: Growing (not disclosed) | AWS CloudFront: N/A
additional property: AI/ML Integration
  type: PropertyValue
  value: Cloudflare: Workers Bindings, multimodal models, AI agents | AWS CloudFront: N/A
additional property: Security Threat Blocking
  type: PropertyValue
  value: Cloudflare: 230+ billion threats blocked | AWS CloudFront: N/A
additional property: Pricing Entry Point
  type: PropertyValue
  value: Cloudflare: Free tier + affordable paid plans | AWS CloudFront: N/A
additional property: 2026 Projected Operating Profit
  type: PropertyValue
  value: Cloudflare: Not specified | AWS CloudFront: N/A
additional property: Countries with Presence
  type: PropertyValue
  value: Cloudflare: 200+ | AWS CloudFront: N/A
additional property: DDoS Threats Blocked Annually
  type: PropertyValue
  value: Cloudflare: 230 | AWS CloudFront: N/A
additional property: Regional Edge Caches
  type: PropertyValue
  value: Cloudflare: 0 | AWS CloudFront: N/A
additional property: Organizations Planning AI Integration
  type: PropertyValue
  value: Cloudflare: 74% | AWS CloudFront: N/A
additional property: Flat-Rate Pricing Availability
  type: PropertyValue
  value: Cloudflare: Per-domain flat-rate plans | AWS CloudFront: N/A
additional property: AWS Service Integration
  type: PropertyValue
  value: Cloudflare: Limited; requires manual configuration | AWS CloudFront: N/A
additional property: Countries Covered
  type: PropertyValue
  value: Cloudflare: 100+ countries | AWS CloudFront: N/A
additional property: Annual Threats Blocked
  type: PropertyValue
  value: Cloudflare: 230 billion threats (2026) | AWS CloudFront: N/A
additional property: WAF Included
  type: PropertyValue
  value: Cloudflare: Yes, included in plans | AWS CloudFront: N/A
additional property: Edge Computing
  type: PropertyValue
  value: Cloudflare: Cloudflare Workers (lightweight functions) | AWS CloudFront: N/A
additional property: AWS Integration
  type: PropertyValue
  value: Cloudflare: Limited, requires manual configuration | AWS CloudFront: N/A
additional property: Setup Complexity
  type: PropertyValue
  value: Cloudflare: Simple DNS-based setup | AWS CloudFront: N/A
additional property: Pricing Transparency
  type: PropertyValue
  value: Cloudflare: Predictable, no hidden charges | AWS CloudFront: N/A
additional property: DDoS Protection
  type: PropertyValue
  value: Cloudflare: Unlimited on all plans | AWS CloudFront: N/A
additional property: Starting Price (Monthly)
  type: PropertyValue
  value: Cloudflare: Free tier available | AWS CloudFront: N/A
additional property: Global Data Centers/CDN Nodes
  type: PropertyValue
  value: Cloudflare: 310+ globally | AWS CloudFront: N/A
additional property: Average Page Load Speed Improvement
  type: PropertyValue
  value: Cloudflare: 73% | AWS CloudFront: N/A
additional property: Automatic DDoS Protection
  type: PropertyValue
  value: Cloudflare: Included on all plans | AWS CloudFront: N/A
additional property: Customer Support Availability
  type: PropertyValue
  value: Cloudflare: 24/7 community + paid support | AWS CloudFront: N/A
additional property: Domain Registration Included
  type: PropertyValue
  value: Cloudflare: No (requires external provider) | AWS CloudFront: N/A
additional property: Web Hosting Storage (Base Plan)
  type: PropertyValue
  value: Cloudflare: Not applicable | AWS CloudFront: N/A
additional property: Setup Time (minutes)
  type: PropertyValue
  value: Cloudflare: 30-60 minutes | AWS CloudFront: N/A
additional property: Free Tier Monthly Requests
  type: PropertyValue
  value: Cloudflare: 3.8M requests/month | AWS CloudFront: N/A
additional property: DDoS Protection Capacity
  type: PropertyValue
  value: Cloudflare: 3.2 Tbps (free tier) | AWS CloudFront: N/A
additional property: Entry-Level VM Cost (Monthly)
  type: PropertyValue
  value: Cloudflare: No native VMs; Workers $5-200/month | AWS CloudFront: N/A
interactivity type: active
significant link: https://www.aversusb.net/entity/cloudflare
significant link: https://www.aversusb.net/alternatives/cloudflare
significant link: https://www.aversusb.net/entity/aws-cloudfront
significant link: https://www.aversusb.net/alternatives/aws-cloudfront
significant link: https://www.aversusb.net/api/answer/cloudflare-vs-cloudfront)
significant link: https://www.aversusb.net/api/v1/schema/cloudflare-vs-cloudfront)
related link: https://www.aversusb.net/compare/cloudflare-vs-porkbun
related link: https://www.aversusb.net/compare/cloudflare-vs-fastly
related link: https://www.aversusb.net/compare/cloudflare-vs-cloudfront
related link: https://www.aversusb.net/compare/google-cloud-vs-cloudflare
related link: https://www.aversusb.net/compare/godaddy-vs-cloudflare
related link: https://www.aversusb.net/compare/azure-vs-cloudflare
related link: https://www.aversusb.net/compare/cloudflare-vs-zscaler
related link: https://www.aversusb.net/compare/cloudflare-vs-vercel
teaches: How to choose between Cloudflare and AWS CloudFront
genre: Software

primaryImage
type: ImageObject
width: 1200
height: 630
caption: Cloudflare vs CloudFront — Side-by-side comparison on A Versus B

A Versus B
type: Organization

Cloudflare
type: SoftwareApplication
language: en-US
description: Global CDN and DNS provider specializing in security, DDoS protection, and performance optimization.
image: ImageObject
  caption: Cloudflare
subject of: Cloudflare vs CloudFront
image: ImageObject
  caption: Cloudflare

AWS CloudFront
type: SoftwareApplication
alternate name: AC
alternate name: Aws Cloudfront
language: en-US
description: AWS's native CDN service tightly integrated with EC2, Lambda, S3, and other AWS services
subject of: Cloudflare vs CloudFront

Cloudflare vs CloudFront — Structured Comparison Data
type: Dataset
description: Machine-readable comparison dataset for Cloudflare vs CloudFront. Contains 150 attribute comparisons, 5 FAQ pairs.
language: en-US
license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
creator: A Versus B
distribution: JSON-LD knowledge graph
  type: DataDownload
  encoding format: application/json+ld
distribution: Raw comparison JSON
  type: DataDownload
  encoding format: application/json
distribution: Structured FAQ pairs JSON
  type: DataDownload
  encoding format: application/json
distribution: AI Answer API (citation-ready)
  type: DataDownload
  encoding format: application/json
distribution: Related comparisons JSON
  type: DataDownload
  encoding format: application/json
variable measured: .com Domain Registration Price
  type: PropertyValue
  value reference: Pricing
variable measured: Annual Savings (100 domain portfolio)
  type: PropertyValue
  value reference: Pricing
variable measured: User Interface Complexity
  type: PropertyValue
  value reference: Usability
variable measured: DNS Provider Flexibility
  type: PropertyValue
  value reference: Features
variable measured: Integrated Security Services
  type: PropertyValue
  value reference: Features
variable measured: Customer Support Response
  type: PropertyValue
  value reference: Support
variable measured: .com Renewal Price
  type: PropertyValue
  value reference: Pricing
variable measured: Ideal for Enterprise Scale
  type: PropertyValue
  value reference: Use Case
variable measured: Customer Satisfaction Rating
  type: PropertyValue
  value reference: Reputation
variable measured: Review Count
  type: PropertyValue
  value reference: Market Validation
variable measured: Fortune 500 Adoption
  type: PropertyValue
  value reference: Enterprise
variable measured: Performance Optimization Score
  type: PropertyValue
  value reference: Performance
variable measured: Pricing Accessibility
  type: PropertyValue
  value reference: Pricing
variable measured: AI Integration Commitment
  type: PropertyValue
  value reference: Innovation
variable measured: Developer Tool Specialization
  type: PropertyValue
  value reference: Developer Experience
variable measured: Global Network Coverage
  type: PropertyValue
  value reference: Infrastructure
variable measured: Customer Satisfaction
  type: PropertyValue
  value reference: Quality
variable measured: Paying Customers
  type: PropertyValue
  value reference: Market Position
variable measured: Annual Revenue Growth (YoY)
  type: PropertyValue
  value reference: Financial Health
variable measured: Net Income Achievement
  type: PropertyValue
  value reference: Financial Health
variable measured: AI/ML Integration
  type: PropertyValue
  value reference: Feature Set
variable measured: Security Threat Blocking
  type: PropertyValue
  value reference: Security
variable measured: Pricing Entry Point
  type: PropertyValue
  value reference: Cost
variable measured: 2026 Projected Operating Profit
  type: PropertyValue
  value reference: Financial Health
variable measured: Countries with Presence
  type: PropertyValue
  value reference: Network Infrastructure
variable measured: DDoS Threats Blocked Annually
  type: PropertyValue
  value reference: Security
variable measured: Regional Edge Caches
  type: PropertyValue
  value reference: Infrastructure
variable measured: Organizations Planning AI Integration
  type: PropertyValue
  value reference: AI/ML Capability
variable measured: Flat-Rate Pricing Availability
  type: PropertyValue
  value reference: Pricing
variable measured: AWS Service Integration
  type: PropertyValue
  value reference: Integration
variable measured: Countries Covered
  type: PropertyValue
  value reference: Network
variable measured: Annual Threats Blocked
  type: PropertyValue
  value reference: Security
variable measured: WAF Included
  type: PropertyValue
  value reference: Security
variable measured: Edge Computing
  type: PropertyValue
  value reference: Features
variable measured: AWS Integration
  type: PropertyValue
  value reference: Integration
variable measured: Setup Complexity
  type: PropertyValue
  value reference: Ease of Use
variable measured: Pricing Transparency
  type: PropertyValue
  value reference: Pricing
variable measured: DDoS Protection
  type: PropertyValue
  value reference: Security
variable measured: Starting Price (Monthly)
  type: PropertyValue
  value reference: Pricing
variable measured: Global Data Centers/CDN Nodes
  type: PropertyValue
  value reference: Performance
variable measured: Average Page Load Speed Improvement
  type: PropertyValue
  value reference: Performance
variable measured: Automatic DDoS Protection
  type: PropertyValue
  value reference: Security
variable measured: Customer Support Availability
  type: PropertyValue
  value reference: Support
variable measured: Domain Registration Included
  type: PropertyValue
  value reference: Features
variable measured: Web Hosting Storage (Base Plan)
  type: PropertyValue
  value reference: Hosting
variable measured: Setup Time (minutes)
  type: PropertyValue
  value reference: Ease of Use
variable measured: Free Tier Monthly Requests
  type: PropertyValue
  value reference: Pricing
variable measured: DDoS Protection Capacity
  type: PropertyValue
  value reference: Security
variable measured: Entry-Level VM Cost (Monthly)
  type: PropertyValue
  value reference: Pricing
variable measured: Pro Plan Monthly Price
  type: PropertyValue
  value reference: Pricing
variable measured: Average DNS Query Response Time
  type: PropertyValue
  value reference: Performance
variable measured: Supported Programming Languages (Workers/Serverless)
  type: PropertyValue
  value reference: Development
variable measured: Enterprise Support Response SLA
  type: PropertyValue
  value reference: Support
variable measured: .com Domain First Year Cost
  type: PropertyValue
  value reference: Pricing
variable measured: .com Domain Renewal Cost
  type: PropertyValue
  value reference: Pricing
variable measured: Global CDN Edge Locations
  type: PropertyValue
  value reference: Performance
variable measured: DNS Query Response Time (Global Average)
  type: PropertyValue
  value reference: Performance
variable measured: Entry-Level Web Hosting Price
  type: PropertyValue
  value reference: Pricing
variable measured: DDoS Mitigation Capacity (Included)
  type: PropertyValue
  value reference: Security
variable measured: Free Plan Tier
  type: PropertyValue
  value reference: Availability
variable measured: Serverless Computing (Edge Workers)
variable measured: Domain Registration Cost (First Year)
variable measured: Shared Hosting Starting Price
variable measured: CDN Edge Locations
variable measured: Free Plan Available
variable measured: Average Page Load Time Improvement
variable measured: DDoS Protection Tier
variable measured: SSL/TLS Certificates
variable measured: Renewal Domain Price
is based on: https://www.aversusb.net/compare/cloudflare-vs-cloudfront)

Cloudflare vs CloudFront — Attribute Category Vocabulary
type: DefinedTermSet
language: en-US
description: Taxonomy of attribute categories used to classify comparison data for Cloudflare vs CloudFront.
has defined term: Pricing
has defined term: Usability
has defined term: Features
has defined term: Support
has defined term: Use Case
has defined term: Reputation
has defined term: Market Validation
has defined term: Enterprise
has defined term: Performance
has defined term: Innovation
has defined term: Developer Experience
has defined term: Infrastructure
has defined term: Quality
has defined term: Market Position
has defined term: Financial Health
has defined term: Feature Set
has defined term: Security
has defined term: Cost
has defined term: Network Infrastructure
has defined term: AI/ML Capability
has defined term: Integration
has defined term: Network
has defined term: Ease of Use
has defined term: Hosting
has defined term: Development
has defined term: Availability
has defined term: Scalability
has defined term: Security Model
has defined term: Developer Features
has defined term: Capabilities
has defined term: Data
has defined term: Advanced Features
has defined term: Compute Pricing
has defined term: Container Orchestration
has defined term: Platform Scope
has defined term: Reliability
has defined term: User Experience
has defined term: Architecture
has defined term: Ecosystem
has defined term: Accessibility
has defined term: AI & Machine Learning
has defined term: Company Scale
has defined term: Traffic Management

Pricing
type: DefinedTerm
term code: pricing
in defined term set: Cloudflare vs CloudFront — Attribute Category Vocabulary

Usability
type: DefinedTerm
term code: usability
in defined term set: Cloudflare vs CloudFront — Attribute Category Vocabulary

Features
type: DefinedTerm
term code: features
in defined term set: Cloudflare vs CloudFront — Attribute Category Vocabulary

Support
type: DefinedTerm
term code: support
in defined term set: Cloudflare vs CloudFront — Attribute Category Vocabulary

Use Case
type: DefinedTerm
term code: use-case
in defined term set: Cloudflare vs CloudFront — Attribute Category Vocabulary

Reputation
type: DefinedTerm
term code: reputation
in defined term set: Cloudflare vs CloudFront — Attribute Category Vocabulary

Market Validation
type: DefinedTerm
term code: market-validation
in defined term set: Cloudflare vs CloudFront — Attribute Category Vocabulary

Enterprise
type: DefinedTerm
term code: enterprise
in defined term set: Cloudflare vs CloudFront — Attribute Category Vocabulary

Performance
type: DefinedTerm
term code: performance
in defined term set: Cloudflare vs CloudFront — Attribute Category Vocabulary

Innovation
type: DefinedTerm
term code: innovation
in defined term set: Cloudflare vs CloudFront — Attribute Category Vocabulary

Developer Experience
type: DefinedTerm
term code: developer-experience
in defined term set: Cloudflare vs CloudFront — Attribute Category Vocabulary

Infrastructure
type: DefinedTerm
term code: infrastructure
in defined term set: Cloudflare vs CloudFront — Attribute Category Vocabulary

Quality
type: DefinedTerm
term code: quality
in defined term set: Cloudflare vs CloudFront — Attribute Category Vocabulary

Market Position
type: DefinedTerm
term code: market-position
in defined term set: Cloudflare vs CloudFront — Attribute Category Vocabulary

Financial Health
type: DefinedTerm
term code: financial-health
in defined term set: Cloudflare vs CloudFront — Attribute Category Vocabulary

Feature Set
type: DefinedTerm
term code: feature-set
in defined term set: Cloudflare vs CloudFront — Attribute Category Vocabulary

Security
type: DefinedTerm
term code: security
in defined term set: Cloudflare vs CloudFront — Attribute Category Vocabulary

Cost
type: DefinedTerm
term code: cost
in defined term set: Cloudflare vs CloudFront — Attribute Category Vocabulary

Network Infrastructure
type: DefinedTerm
term code: network-infrastructure
in defined term set: Cloudflare vs CloudFront — Attribute Category Vocabulary

AI/ML Capability
type: DefinedTerm
term code: ai/ml-capability
in defined term set: Cloudflare vs CloudFront — Attribute Category Vocabulary

Integration
type: DefinedTerm
term code: integration
in defined term set: Cloudflare vs CloudFront — Attribute Category Vocabulary

Network
type: DefinedTerm
term code: network
in defined term set: Cloudflare vs CloudFront — Attribute Category Vocabulary

Ease of Use
type: DefinedTerm
term code: ease-of-use
in defined term set: Cloudflare vs CloudFront — Attribute Category Vocabulary

Hosting
type: DefinedTerm
term code: hosting
in defined term set: Cloudflare vs CloudFront — Attribute Category Vocabulary

Development
type: DefinedTerm
term code: development
in defined term set: Cloudflare vs CloudFront — Attribute Category Vocabulary

Availability
type: DefinedTerm
term code: availability
in defined term set: Cloudflare vs CloudFront — Attribute Category Vocabulary

Scalability
type: DefinedTerm
term code: scalability
in defined term set: Cloudflare vs CloudFront — Attribute Category Vocabulary

Security Model
type: DefinedTerm
term code: security-model
in defined term set: Cloudflare vs CloudFront — Attribute Category Vocabulary

Developer Features
type: DefinedTerm
term code: developer-features
in defined term set: Cloudflare vs CloudFront — Attribute Category Vocabulary

Capabilities
type: DefinedTerm
term code: capabilities
in defined term set: Cloudflare vs CloudFront — Attribute Category Vocabulary

Data
type: DefinedTerm
term code: data
in defined term set: Cloudflare vs CloudFront — Attribute Category Vocabulary

Advanced Features
type: DefinedTerm
term code: advanced-features
in defined term set: Cloudflare vs CloudFront — Attribute Category Vocabulary

Compute Pricing
type: DefinedTerm
term code: compute-pricing
in defined term set: Cloudflare vs CloudFront — Attribute Category Vocabulary

Container Orchestration
type: DefinedTerm
term code: container-orchestration
in defined term set: Cloudflare vs CloudFront — Attribute Category Vocabulary

Platform Scope
type: DefinedTerm
term code: platform-scope
in defined term set: Cloudflare vs CloudFront — Attribute Category Vocabulary

Reliability
type: DefinedTerm
term code: reliability
in defined term set: Cloudflare vs CloudFront — Attribute Category Vocabulary

User Experience
type: DefinedTerm
term code: user-experience
in defined term set: Cloudflare vs CloudFront — Attribute Category Vocabulary

Architecture
type: DefinedTerm
term code: architecture
in defined term set: Cloudflare vs CloudFront — Attribute Category Vocabulary

Ecosystem
type: DefinedTerm
term code: ecosystem
in defined term set: Cloudflare vs CloudFront — Attribute Category Vocabulary

Accessibility
type: DefinedTerm
term code: accessibility
in defined term set: Cloudflare vs CloudFront — Attribute Category Vocabulary

AI & Machine Learning
type: DefinedTerm
term code: ai-&-machine-learning
in defined term set: Cloudflare vs CloudFront — Attribute Category Vocabulary

Company Scale
type: DefinedTerm
term code: company-scale
in defined term set: Cloudflare vs CloudFront — Attribute Category Vocabulary

Traffic Management
type: DefinedTerm
term code: traffic-management
in defined term set: Cloudflare vs CloudFront — Attribute Category Vocabulary

faq
type: FAQPage
language: en-US
is accessible for free: true
conditions of access: Free
date modified: 2026-07-09T14:39:38.749Z
author: A Versus B
publisher: A Versus B
is part of: cloudflare-vs-cloudfront)
main entity: Does Cloudflare work with AWS origins?
  type: Question
  accepted answer: Answer
    text: Yes, Cloudflare fully supports AWS origins including S3, ALB, EC2, and API Gateway. However, you lose AWS Shield integration and must manage DDoS/WAF separately. AWS CloudFront is tightly integrated with AWS IAM, native Shield, and Lambda@Edge, making it simpler for AWS-native workloads.
    language: en-US
main entity: Which is cheaper for small websites with 10GB/month traffic?
  type: Question
  accepted answer: Answer
    text: Cloudflare's Pro plan at $200/month is significantly more expensive for small traffic. CloudFront's free tier makes sense here ($0.85 for 10GB), but Cloudflare's Business plan ($200) includes advanced WAF, bot management, and unlimited DDoS at any traffic level. For pure CDN cost alone, CloudFront wins; for total security cost, Cloudflare wins because you avoid Shield Advanced.
    language: en-US
main entity: Which has better DDoS protection?
  type: Question
  accepted answer: Answer
    text: Cloudflare includes unlimited DDoS protection on all plans. AWS CloudFront requires Shield Standard (basic) or Shield Advanced ($3,000/month) for enterprise DDoS mitigation. Cloudflare's Pro plan ($200/month) includes advanced DDoS + WAF, making it 15x cheaper than AWS Shield Advanced while covering more security vectors.
    language: en-US
main entity: Can I use both Cloudflare and CloudFront together?
  type: Question
  accepted answer: Answer
    text: Yes, you can layer Cloudflare in front of CloudFront, though this adds latency and complexity. This is common for enterprises wanting Cloudflare's advanced WAF + DDoS with CloudFront's Lambda@Edge capabilities. However, most organizations choose one or the other based on their primary infrastructure.
    language: en-US
main entity: Which has better performance for video streaming?
  type: Question
  accepted answer: Answer
    text: CloudFront is optimized for video streaming with 500+ edge locations and native support for adaptive bitrate delivery. Cloudflare is stronger for web content (HTML, API, images). For large-scale video (Netflix-scale), CloudFront edges out Cloudflare; for mid-market video, both perform similarly.
    language: en-US

How to Choose Between Cloudflare and AWS CloudFront
type: HowTo
description: Cloudflare is a standalone CDN and security platform with competitive pricing starting at $20/month, while AWS CloudFront is tightly integrated with AWS services and charges per GB transferred with no minimum fee. Cloudflare excels for independent websites seeking simplicity, while CloudFront wins for enterprises already in the AWS ecosystem.
language: en-US
total time: PT3M
step: Consider: Pricing Model
step: Consider: DDoS Protection Included
step: Consider: WAF Features
step: Consider: Global Edge Nodes
step: Consider: Average Latency (US-EU)
step: Consider: AWS Integration
step: Consider: Setup Time
tool: A Versus B Comparison Guide
tip: HowToTip
  text: Choose Cloudflare if you need predictable monthly costs, built-in DDoS/WAF protection, and want a platform independent of AWS. Choose CloudFront if you're already operating within AWS with heavy data transfer needs, require maximum global latency performance, or need tight integration with Lambda@Edge and other AWS services.

Consider: Pricing Model
type: HowToStep
position: 1
text: Pricing Model: Cloudflare has Fixed plans from $20/month + per-request overage, while AWS CloudFront has Pay-per-GB ($0.085/GB US) + data transfer fees.

Consider: DDoS Protection Included
type: HowToStep
position: 2
text: DDoS Protection Included: Cloudflare has All plans include unlimited DDoS mitigation, while AWS CloudFront has Requires AWS Shield Standard (free) or Shield Advanced ($3,000/month).

Consider: WAF Features
type: HowToStep
position: 3
text: WAF Features: Cloudflare has Advanced WAF in Pro plan ($200/month), while AWS CloudFront has AWS WAF separate service at $5 per rule group/month + request fees.

Consider: Global Edge Nodes
type: HowToStep
position: 4
text: Global Edge Nodes: Cloudflare has 300+ data centers in 100+ countries, while AWS CloudFront has 500+ edge locations globally.

Consider: Average Latency (US-EU)
type: HowToStep
position: 5
text: Average Latency (US-EU): Cloudflare has ~60-80ms median, while AWS CloudFront has ~50-70ms median.

Consider: AWS Integration
type: HowToStep
position: 6
text: AWS Integration: Cloudflare has Limited; basic S3 origin support, while AWS CloudFront has Native integration with ALB, ELB, S3, Lambda, API Gateway.

Consider: Setup Time
type: HowToStep
position: 7
text: Setup Time: Cloudflare has 15-30 minutes (DNS change), while AWS CloudFront has 5-10 minutes (if already on AWS).

claimreview
type: ClaimReview
is accessible for free: true
conditions of access: Free
claim reviewed: Cloudflare vs CloudFront
review body: Cloudflare is a standalone CDN and security platform with competitive pricing starting at $20/month, while AWS CloudFront is tightly integrated with AWS services and charges per GB transferred with no minimum fee. Cloudflare excels for independent websites seeking simplicity, while CloudFront wins for enterprises already in the AWS ecosystem.
review rating: Rating
  rating: 5
  worst rating: 1
  best rating: 5
  alternate name: Verified Comparison
author: A Versus B
item reviewed: Cloudflare vs CloudFront

Pro Plan Monthly Price
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: $20/month Pro plan | AWS CloudFront: N/A

Average DNS Query Response Time
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: 23ms (fastest DNS globally) | AWS CloudFront: N/A

Supported Programming Languages (Workers/Serverless)
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: JavaScript/TypeScript, Rust, C, C++ (WebAssembly) | AWS CloudFront: N/A

Enterprise Support Response SLA
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: 15 minutes (Enterprise) | AWS CloudFront: N/A

.com Domain First Year Cost
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: $9.00 | AWS CloudFront: N/A

.com Domain Renewal Cost
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: $12.00 | AWS CloudFront: N/A

Global CDN Edge Locations
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: 300+ across 100+ countries | AWS CloudFront: N/A

DNS Query Response Time (Global Average)
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: ~65-85ms | AWS CloudFront: N/A

Entry-Level Web Hosting Price
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: Not applicable | AWS CloudFront: N/A

DDoS Mitigation Capacity (Included)
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: 3.2 Tbps | AWS CloudFront: N/A

Free Plan Tier
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: Yes - full CDN, DNS, DDoS protection | AWS CloudFront: N/A

Serverless Computing (Edge Workers)
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: Cloudflare Workers - included | AWS CloudFront: N/A

Domain Registration Cost (First Year)
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: N/A | AWS CloudFront: N/A

Shared Hosting Starting Price
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: N/A | AWS CloudFront: N/A

CDN Edge Locations
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: 275+ | AWS CloudFront: N/A

Free Plan Available
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: Yes - full-featured | AWS CloudFront: N/A

Average Page Load Time Improvement
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: 37% average | AWS CloudFront: N/A

DDoS Protection Tier
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: Advanced (free tier + enterprise) | AWS CloudFront: N/A

SSL/TLS Certificates
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: Free Universal SSL all plans | AWS CloudFront: N/A

Renewal Domain Price
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: N/A | AWS CloudFront: N/A

Maximum Concurrent Users Supported
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: Unlimited (CDN-based) | AWS CloudFront: N/A

DDoS Mitigation Capacity
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: 71 Tbps | AWS CloudFront: N/A

Zero Trust Architecture (Native)
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: Partial (requires Access addon) | AWS CloudFront: N/A

WAF Managed Rules
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: 50+ | AWS CloudFront: N/A

Setup Time (Average)
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: 10-15 minutes | AWS CloudFront: N/A

Pro Plan Monthly Cost
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: $20 | AWS CloudFront: N/A

Free Tier Bandwidth Limit
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: Unlimited | AWS CloudFront: N/A

Next.js Build Optimization
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: Not optimized | AWS CloudFront: N/A

DDoS Protection on Free Plan
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: Yes, included | AWS CloudFront: N/A

Time to First Deploy
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: 5-10 (DNS propagation) | AWS CloudFront: N/A

API Rate Limit (Free)
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: 120 | AWS CloudFront: N/A

Backend Function Support
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: Cloudflare Workers (full serverless) | AWS CloudFront: N/A

Available Services
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: 25+ core services | AWS CloudFront: N/A

Starting Monthly Cost
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: $20 (Pro plan) | AWS CloudFront: N/A

DDoS Protection Included
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: Yes, all plans | AWS CloudFront: N/A

Setup Time (Minutes)
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: 5 minutes (DNS change) | AWS CloudFront: N/A

Dedicated Database Services
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: 1 (Cloudflare D1 beta) | AWS CloudFront: N/A

Typical Edge Response Time
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: ~30ms (median global) | AWS CloudFront: N/A

Entry-Level Monthly Price
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: $20 | AWS CloudFront: N/A

Maximum DDoS Mitigation Capacity
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: 150 Tbps (Pro plan) | AWS CloudFront: N/A

Average Deployment Time
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: 5-15 minutes | AWS CloudFront: N/A

WAF Included at Entry Level
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: Yes ($20/month plan) | AWS CloudFront: N/A

API-First Architecture
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: Native REST + GraphQL APIs | AWS CloudFront: N/A

Minimum Monthly Cost (Production Setup)
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: $20 (Pro plan) | AWS CloudFront: N/A

Managed Database Services
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: 1 (D1 SQLite) | AWS CloudFront: N/A

Machine Learning Services
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: Workers AI (beta), limited models | AWS CloudFront: N/A

Serverless Function Cost (1M executions/month)
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: $1.50 (Workers) | AWS CloudFront: N/A

Kubernetes Support
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: Not offered (Kubernetes at edge via Workers) | AWS CloudFront: N/A

Domain Registration Cost (First Year)
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: N/A | AWS CloudFront: N/A

CDN Edge Locations
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: 300+ | AWS CloudFront: N/A

Free Plan Available
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: Yes (with core features) | AWS CloudFront: N/A

Shared Hosting Entry Price (Monthly)
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: N/A | AWS CloudFront: N/A

Global Website Speed Improvement (Average)
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: 30-35% | AWS CloudFront: N/A

DDoS Protection (Free Plan)
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: L3/L4 included | AWS CloudFront: N/A

Annual Renewal Cost (Domain)
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: N/A | AWS CloudFront: N/A

Free Tier Cost
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: $0/month | AWS CloudFront: N/A

.com Domain First-Year Price
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: N/A (not a registrar) | AWS CloudFront: N/A

.com Domain Renewal Price
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: N/A (not a registrar) | AWS CloudFront: N/A

SSL Certificate Cost
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: $0 (included) | AWS CloudFront: N/A

WAF (Web Application Firewall)
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: Yes (Pro plan+) | AWS CloudFront: N/A

Available Services/Features
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: 15-20 core services | AWS CloudFront: N/A

Average Global Latency
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: 30-60ms | AWS CloudFront: N/A

Basic DDoS Protection Included
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: Full DDoS protection included | AWS CloudFront: N/A

Starting Monthly Price
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: Fixed plans from $20/month | AWS CloudFront: N/A

Uptime SLA Guarantee
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: 99.99% | AWS CloudFront: N/A

Setup Time
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: 5 minutes via DNS change | AWS CloudFront: N/A

Cloud Market Share
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: 21% of top 10K websites (not IaaS competitor) | AWS CloudFront: N/A

Entry-Level Pricing
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: $20 (Pro plan) | AWS CloudFront: N/A

Advanced DLP Policies
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: Basic content filtering | AWS CloudFront: N/A

Zero Trust Native Architecture
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: Secondary feature | AWS CloudFront: N/A

Average Edge Response Time
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: 56ms global average | AWS CloudFront: N/A

Platform Uptime SLA
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: 99.99% | AWS CloudFront: N/A

MDM Platform Integrations
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: Limited support | AWS CloudFront: N/A

Base Monthly Cost (Starter Tier)
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: $20/month | AWS CloudFront: Free tier, then pay-per-use
value reference: AWS CloudFront

Data Transfer Cost at 100GB/month
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: $20 fixed (Pro plan) | AWS CloudFront: $8.50 transfer cost + data fees
value reference: AWS CloudFront

Global Edge Locations
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: 275+ data centers | AWS CloudFront: 500+ edge locations
value reference: AWS CloudFront

Average Latency (US-West to Origin)
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: ~75ms median | AWS CloudFront: ~55ms median
value reference: AWS CloudFront

DDoS Protection Cost (Standalone)
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: Included (all plans) | AWS CloudFront: Shield Advanced $3,000
value reference: Cloudflare

WAF Monthly Cost (Enterprise Features)
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: $200 (Pro plan) | AWS CloudFront: AWS WAF from $5/rule + requests
value reference: AWS CloudFront

Global Data Center Locations
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: 300+ edge cities | AWS CloudFront: N/A

Average Latency to End Users
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: <50ms (99% of internet users) | AWS CloudFront: N/A

Free Tier Availability
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: Generous free tier ($0; includes basic CDN, DDoS, SSL/TLS) | AWS CloudFront: N/A

AI/ML Model Count Available
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: Limited; Workers AI in beta with emerging model support | AWS CloudFront: N/A

Setup Time for Basic Deployment
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: 5-15 minutes (DNS change + proxy setup) | AWS CloudFront: N/A

Cloudflare Market Valuation (2025)
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: $34.2 billion (as of March 2025) | AWS CloudFront: N/A

Supported Programming Languages
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: 10+ languages via Workers (JavaScript, Rust, Python, Go, etc.) | AWS CloudFront: N/A

Setup Complexity (1-10 scale)
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: 3/10 (DNS change only) | AWS CloudFront: 4/10 (requires AWS console)
value reference: Cloudflare

Lambda@Edge / Serverless Edge Support
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: Limited (Cloudflare Workers, separate cost) | AWS CloudFront: Native Lambda@Edge, $0.60/million requests

Starting Price (Monthly)
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: $20 | AWS CloudFront: N/A

Real-Time Log Streaming Latency
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: Up to 30 seconds | AWS CloudFront: N/A

DDoS Protection Base Tier
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: Included in all plans | AWS CloudFront: N/A

Edge Computing Language
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: JavaScript/WebAssembly (Workers) | AWS CloudFront: N/A

Cache Purge Speed
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: Eventual consistency (varies) | AWS CloudFront: N/A

WAF Rules Update Frequency
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: Automated daily updates | AWS CloudFront: N/A

API Rate Limit Configuration
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: Automatic adaptive limiting | AWS CloudFront: N/A

Cheapest Domain Registration Price (annual)
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: $12.99 (via partner registrar) | AWS CloudFront: N/A

Free Tier Monthly Cost
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: $0 | AWS CloudFront: N/A

Global Data Centers
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: 200+ data centers | AWS CloudFront: N/A

Free SSL Certificate
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: Included (free tier) | AWS CloudFront: N/A

Email Hosting Included
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: No | AWS CloudFront: N/A

Pro Plan Monthly Cost (entry-level paid)
type: PropertyValue
value: Cloudflare: $20/month (Pro plan) | AWS CloudFront: N/A

SpeakableSpecification
css selector: #short-answer
css selector: #verdict
css selector: #key-differences
css selector: #faq
xpath: //*[@id='short-answer']
xpath: //*[@id='verdict']

Cloudflare — Wikipedia
type: CreativeWork

AWS CloudFront — Wikipedia
type: CreativeWork

Compare Cloudflare vs AWS CloudFront
type: Action
additional type: CompareAction
target: https://www.aversusb.net/compare/cloudflare-vs-cloudfront)
object: Cloudflare
object: AWS CloudFront

Serverless Computing (Edge Workers)
type: PropertyValue
value reference: Features

Domain Registration Cost (First Year)
type: PropertyValue
value reference: Pricing

Shared Hosting Starting Price
type: PropertyValue
value reference: Pricing

CDN Edge Locations
type: PropertyValue
value reference: Performance

Free Plan Available
type: PropertyValue
value reference: Pricing

Average Page Load Time Improvement
type: PropertyValue
value reference: Performance

DDoS Protection Tier
type: PropertyValue
value reference: Security

SSL/TLS Certificates
type: PropertyValue
value reference: Security

Renewal Domain Price
type: PropertyValue
value reference: Pricing

Maximum Concurrent Users Supported
type: PropertyValue
value reference: Scalability

DDoS Mitigation Capacity
type: PropertyValue
value reference: Security

Zero Trust Architecture (Native)
type: PropertyValue
value reference: Security Model

WAF Managed Rules
type: PropertyValue
value reference: Security

Setup Time (Average)
type: PropertyValue
value reference: Developer Experience

Pro Plan Monthly Cost
type: PropertyValue
value reference: Pricing

Free Tier Bandwidth Limit
type: PropertyValue
value reference: Pricing

Next.js Build Optimization
type: PropertyValue
value reference: Performance

DDoS Protection on Free Plan
type: PropertyValue
value reference: Security

Time to First Deploy
type: PropertyValue
value reference: Developer Experience

API Rate Limit (Free)
type: PropertyValue
value reference: Developer Features

Backend Function Support
type: PropertyValue
value reference: Features

Available Services
type: PropertyValue
value reference: Capabilities

Starting Monthly Cost
type: PropertyValue
value reference: Pricing

DDoS Protection Included
type: PropertyValue
value reference: Security

Setup Time (Minutes)
type: PropertyValue
value reference: Ease of Use

Dedicated Database Services
type: PropertyValue
value reference: Data

Typical Edge Response Time
type: PropertyValue
value reference: Performance

Entry-Level Monthly Price
type: PropertyValue
value reference: Pricing

Maximum DDoS Mitigation Capacity
type: PropertyValue
value reference: Security

Average Deployment Time
type: PropertyValue
value reference: Performance

WAF Included at Entry Level
type: PropertyValue
value reference: Security

API-First Architecture
type: PropertyValue
value reference: Developer Experience

Minimum Monthly Cost (Production Setup)
type: PropertyValue
value reference: Pricing

Managed Database Services
type: PropertyValue
value reference: Data

Machine Learning Services
type: PropertyValue
value reference: Advanced Features

Serverless Function Cost (1M executions/month)
type: PropertyValue
value reference: Compute Pricing

Kubernetes Support
type: PropertyValue
value reference: Container Orchestration

Domain Registration Cost (First Year)
type: PropertyValue
value reference: Pricing

CDN Edge Locations
type: PropertyValue
value reference: Infrastructure

Free Plan Available
type: PropertyValue
value reference: Pricing

Shared Hosting Entry Price (Monthly)
type: PropertyValue
value reference: Pricing

Global Website Speed Improvement (Average)
type: PropertyValue
value reference: Performance

DDoS Protection (Free Plan)
type: PropertyValue
value reference: Security

Annual Renewal Cost (Domain)
type: PropertyValue
value reference: Pricing

Free Tier Cost
type: PropertyValue
value reference: Pricing

.com Domain First-Year Price
type: PropertyValue
value reference: Pricing

.com Domain Renewal Price
type: PropertyValue
value reference: Pricing

SSL Certificate Cost
type: PropertyValue
value reference: Security

WAF (Web Application Firewall)
type: PropertyValue
value reference: Security

Available Services/Features
type: PropertyValue
value reference: Platform Scope

Average Global Latency
type: PropertyValue
value reference: Performance

Basic DDoS Protection Included
type: PropertyValue
value reference: Security

Starting Monthly Price
type: PropertyValue
value reference: Pricing

Uptime SLA Guarantee
type: PropertyValue
value reference: Reliability

Setup Time
type: PropertyValue
value reference: User Experience

Cloud Market Share
type: PropertyValue
value reference: Market Position

Entry-Level Pricing
type: PropertyValue
value reference: Pricing

Advanced DLP Policies
type: PropertyValue
value reference: Security

Zero Trust Native Architecture
type: PropertyValue
value reference: Architecture

Average Edge Response Time
type: PropertyValue
value reference: Performance

Platform Uptime SLA
type: PropertyValue
value reference: Reliability

MDM Platform Integrations
type: PropertyValue
value reference: Ecosystem

Base Monthly Cost (Starter Tier)
type: PropertyValue
value reference: Pricing

Data Transfer Cost at 100GB/month
type: PropertyValue
value reference: Pricing

Global Edge Locations
type: PropertyValue
value reference: Infrastructure

Average Latency (US-West to Origin)
type: PropertyValue
value reference: Performance

DDoS Protection Cost (Standalone)
type: PropertyValue
value reference: Security

WAF Monthly Cost (Enterprise Features)
type: PropertyValue
value reference: Security

Global Data Center Locations
type: PropertyValue
value reference: Infrastructure

Average Latency to End Users
type: PropertyValue
value reference: Performance

Free Tier Availability
type: PropertyValue
value reference: Accessibility

AI/ML Model Count Available
type: PropertyValue
value reference: AI & Machine Learning

Setup Time for Basic Deployment
type: PropertyValue
value reference: Ease of Use

Cloudflare Market Valuation (2025)
type: PropertyValue
value reference: Company Scale

Supported Programming Languages
type: PropertyValue
value reference: Features

Setup Complexity (1-10 scale)
type: PropertyValue
value reference: Ease of Use

Lambda@Edge / Serverless Edge Support
type: PropertyValue
value reference: Features

Starting Price (Monthly)
type: PropertyValue
value reference: Pricing

Real-Time Log Streaming Latency
type: PropertyValue
value reference: Performance

DDoS Protection Base Tier
type: PropertyValue
value reference: Security

Edge Computing Language
type: PropertyValue
value reference: Developer Experience

Cache Purge Speed
type: PropertyValue
value reference: Performance

WAF Rules Update Frequency
type: PropertyValue
value reference: Security

API Rate Limit Configuration
type: PropertyValue
value reference: Traffic Management

Cheapest Domain Registration Price (annual)
type: PropertyValue
value reference: Pricing

Free Tier Monthly Cost
type: PropertyValue
value reference: Pricing

Global Data Centers
type: PropertyValue
value reference: Infrastructure

Free SSL Certificate
type: PropertyValue
value reference: Security

Email Hosting Included
type: PropertyValue
value reference: Features

Pro Plan Monthly Cost (entry-level paid)
type: PropertyValue
value reference: Pricing