The Cleveland Browns have a superior recent win-loss record (9-8 in 2024 vs 3-14 for Tennessee) and a more accomplished quarterback in Deshaun Watson, while the Tennessee Titans are in a full rebuild phase with a new regime. The Browns are playoff contenders while the Titans are among the NFL's worst teams.
Cleveland Browns vs Tennessee Titans — Side-by-side comparison on A Versus B
AFC North playoff contender with Deshaun Watson at quarterback
Rebuilding AFC South team in first year under new head coach
2024 Regular Season Record. Playoff Appearances (Last 5 Years). Starting QB Passer Rating (2024). Offensive Yards Per Game (2024). Franchise Super Bowl Wins. Head Coach Tenure Start. Pro Bowl Players on Roster (2024)
The Cleveland Browns are a significantly stronger franchise in 2026, with a winning record, playoff experience, and a star quarterback anchoring their roster. The Tennessee Titans are in a rebuild under a new coaching staff and finished among the league's worst. Choose the Browns if evaluating current NFL playoff contention and roster strength; choose the Titans only if analyzing long-term rebuild potential with draft capital.
Cleveland Browns: 2 | Tennessee Titans: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 4.2 | Tennessee Titans: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 0 | Tennessee Titans: N/A
Cleveland Browns: Standard approach | Tennessee Titans: N/A
Cleveland Browns: Fair - Turnover issues | Tennessee Titans: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 4-2 | Tennessee Titans: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 27.3% | Tennessee Titans: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 44.4% | Tennessee Titans: N/A
Average Points Per Game vs This Opponent
Cleveland Browns: 18.1 | Tennessee Titans: N/A
Cleveland Browns: Cleveland Browns | Tennessee Titans: N/A
Leading Running Back Rushing Yards (2025)
Cleveland Browns: 35.5% | Tennessee Titans: N/A
Cleveland Browns: Deshaun Gabriel 110 yards | Tennessee Titans: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 20.2 | Tennessee Titans: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 46.7% | Tennessee Titans: N/A
Cleveland Browns: Quinshon Judkins 827 yards | Tennessee Titans: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 77 seasons overall | Tennessee Titans: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 11 | Tennessee Titans: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 22.4 | Tennessee Titans: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 19:10 | Tennessee Titans: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 64.7% | Tennessee Titans: N/A
Primary Running Back Rushing Yards (2025)
Cleveland Browns: 827 (Quinshon Judkins) | Tennessee Titans: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 73rd season (2025) | Tennessee Titans: N/A
Cleveland Browns: Multiple starters (Watson, Gabriel, Flacco) | Tennessee Titans: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 32nd | Tennessee Titans: 31st
Cleveland Browns: 6-9 | Tennessee Titans: 9-6
Cleveland Browns: 0 | Tennessee Titans: 0
Cleveland Browns: Lost 29-31 | Tennessee Titans: Won 31-29
Cleveland Browns: Below .500 | Tennessee Titans: N/A
Cleveland Browns: ~2,000 yards | Tennessee Titans: N/A
Cleveland Browns: ~15 TDs | Tennessee Titans: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 3 appearances | Tennessee Titans: 2
Cleveland Browns: Lost 3-31 | Tennessee Titans: N/A
Cleveland Browns: ~55% | Tennessee Titans: N/A
Cleveland Browns: ~82 | Tennessee Titans: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 61 years (1964) | Tennessee Titans: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 3-14 | Tennessee Titans: 1-15
Cleveland Browns: 16.7 | Tennessee Titans: 17.1
Cleveland Browns: 478 | Tennessee Titans: 464
Cleveland Browns: 45.2% | Tennessee Titans: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 3,964 (Deshaun Watson) | Tennessee Titans: N/A
QB Touchdown-to-Interception Ratio (2024)
Cleveland Browns: 1.69 (27 TDs / 16 INTs) | Tennessee Titans: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 3-14 (5th place, AFC North) | Tennessee Titans: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 6 seasons (Kevin Stefanski, since 2020) | Tennessee Titans: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 8 | Tennessee Titans: N/A
All-Time Head-to-Head Record (Since 1996)
Cleveland Browns: 29-35 | Tennessee Titans: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 6 | Tennessee Titans: N/A
Cleveland Browns: $230M (Watson) | Tennessee Titans: N/A
Offensive Points Per Game (2023-24 Season)
Cleveland Browns: 21.5 | Tennessee Titans: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 118.2 | Tennessee Titans: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 77 years (1964) | Tennessee Titans: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 28-32 (since 1996) | Tennessee Titans: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 56.3% | Tennessee Titans: N/A
Cleveland Browns: $57.5M (Deshaun Watson) | Tennessee Titans: N/A
Cleveland Browns: $3.2B | Tennessee Titans: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 544-689-10 (.441 win percentage) | Tennessee Titans: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 42-81-1 vs Steelers | Tennessee Titans: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 3 (2020, 2022, 2023) | Tennessee Titans: N/A
Cleveland Browns: Never won | Tennessee Titans: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 11-6 | Tennessee Titans: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 3 | Tennessee Titans: N/A
Cleveland Browns: $230M (Deshaun Watson) | Tennessee Titans: N/A
Cleveland Browns: $8.2M | Tennessee Titans: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 76 years (since 1950) | Tennessee Titans: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 2 (2020, 2022) | Tennessee Titans: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 0 appearances | Tennessee Titans: N/A
Cleveland Browns: .447 (515-638-11) | Tennessee Titans: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 8 titles | Tennessee Titans: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 6 appearances | Tennessee Titans: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 7 wins (16 games) | Tennessee Titans: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 1946 | Tennessee Titans: N/A
Conference Championships (pre-Super Bowl era & modern)
Cleveland Browns: 8 total | Tennessee Titans: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 5 seasons (Kevin Stefanski, 2020-present) | Tennessee Titans: N/A
2025 Defense Ranking (Yards Allowed/Game)
Cleveland Browns: 364.5 yards (22nd) | Tennessee Titans: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 379.8 yards (7th) | Tennessee Titans: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 3 appearances (2020, 2021, 2023) | Tennessee Titans: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 2 (Jim Brown, Otto Graham) | Tennessee Titans: N/A
Head Coach Regular Season Win Percentage
Cleveland Browns: 54.0% (Stefanski) | Tennessee Titans: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 22 | Tennessee Titans: N/A
Cleveland Browns: Never | Tennessee Titans: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 77 years (since 1946) | Tennessee Titans: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 67,431 | Tennessee Titans: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 13-33 | Tennessee Titans: N/A
Winning Percentage (last 10 seasons: 2015-2024)
Cleveland Browns: 46.3% | Tennessee Titans: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 5 seasons (Stefanski) | Tennessee Titans: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 11-6 (missed playoffs) | Tennessee Titans: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 1 (Deshaun Watson - 3x Pro Bowler career) | Tennessee Titans: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 9 | Tennessee Titans: 3
Cleveland Browns: 92.1 | Tennessee Titans: 68.9
Cleveland Browns: 354.1 | Tennessee Titans: 284.6
Cleveland Browns: 23.4 | Tennessee Titans: 28.1
Cleveland Browns: 3 | Tennessee Titans: 1
Cleveland Browns: 3 | Tennessee Titans: 0
Cleveland Browns: 2 | Tennessee Titans: 0
How to choose between Cleveland Browns and Tennessee Titans
Compare Cleveland Browns vs Tennessee Titans
Cleveland Browns vs Tennessee Titans — Structured Comparison Data
Machine-readable comparison dataset for Cleveland Browns vs Tennessee Titans. Contains 113 attribute comparisons, 5 FAQ pairs.
Cleveland Browns vs Tennessee Titans — Attribute Category Vocabulary
Taxonomy of attribute categories used to classify comparison data for Cleveland Browns vs Tennessee Titans.
Why are the Titans so bad compared to the Browns?
The Titans finished 3-14 in 2024 due to multiple factors: quarterback Will Levis struggled with a 68.9 passer rating, the team lacked established star power (0 Pro Bowl selections), and they were in the first year of a complete rebuild under new head coach Brian Callahan. The Browns, meanwhile, have Deshaun Watson, an established coaching system under Kevin Stefanski (year 3), and three Pro Bowl caliber players, resulting in a 9-8 playoff-contending record.
Is Deshaun Watson better than Will Levis?
Yes, significantly. Watson posted a 92.1 passer rating in 2024 compared to Levis' 68.9 rating—a 23-point gap. Watson is an elite NFL quarterback with experience in playoff situations, while Levis is a second-year quarterback still developing in a rebuilding offense. The statistical gap reflects both player development stage and team offensive support.
The Browns have the better short-term outlook (2026-2027) as playoff contenders with Watson, but the Titans could potentially develop better long-term if their rebuild produces a strong QB and their accumulated draft picks yield star players. However, the Titans' 3-14 finish suggests they are 2-3 years away from contention, while the Browns are competing now.
Do either team have a history of Super Bowl success?
Neither team has won a Super Bowl. The Cleveland Browns have never won one (last championship was 1964 before the Super Bowl era). The Tennessee Titans won one Super Bowl in the 1999 season (as the Oilers) but have not won since relocating to Tennessee in 1996, making both franchises championship-starved.
How much better is the Browns' defense compared to the Titans?
The Browns' defense allows 23.4 points per game versus the Titans' 28.1—a difference of 4.7 points per game. This 17% difference reflects both superior defensive talent and coaching. The Browns rank significantly better in most defensive metrics and generate more pressure on opposing quarterbacks.
How to Choose Between Cleveland Browns and Tennessee Titans
2024 Regular Season Record: Cleveland Browns has 9-8, while Tennessee Titans has 3-14.
Consider: Playoff Appearances (Last 5 Years)
Playoff Appearances (Last 5 Years): Cleveland Browns has 2 (2022, 2023), while Tennessee Titans has 0.
Consider: Starting QB Passer Rating (2024)
Starting QB Passer Rating (2024): Cleveland Browns has 92.1 (Deshaun Watson), while Tennessee Titans has 68.9 (Will Levis).
Consider: Offensive Yards Per Game (2024)
Offensive Yards Per Game (2024): Cleveland Browns has 354.1, while Tennessee Titans has 284.6.
Franchise Super Bowl Wins: Cleveland Browns has 0, while Tennessee Titans has 0.
Head Coach Tenure Start: Cleveland Browns has 2022 (Kevin Stefanski, 3rd year), while Tennessee Titans has 2024 (Brian Callahan, 1st year).
Consider: Pro Bowl Players on Roster (2024)
Pro Bowl Players on Roster (2024): Cleveland Browns has 3 (Watson, Chubb, Njoku), while Tennessee Titans has 0.