The San Francisco 49ers have won significantly more games historically (586 wins vs 395), made more Super Bowl appearances (6 vs 2), and currently have a stronger roster with a 12-5 record compared to the Browns' 3-14 record as of 2025. The 49ers are an elite NFC West contender while the Browns remain in rebuilding mode.
Cleveland Browns vs San Francisco 49ers — Side-by-side comparison on A Versus B
NFL team competing in AFC North known for defensive focus and recent offensive roster investments
NFL franchise based in San Francisco, California, competing in the NFC West division since 1946.
All-Time Win-Loss Record. Super Bowl Appearances. Super Bowl Wins. 2025 Season Record. Playoff Appearances (Last 10 Years). Hall of Fame Players. Head Coach Tenure Stability
The San Francisco 49ers are decisively the stronger franchise, with 5 Super Bowl championships, a .525 all-time winning percentage, and consistent playoff success. The Browns have not won a championship since 1964 and are currently in the midst of a significant rebuilding phase with a 3-14 record. Choose the 49ers if you want to follow a consistently competitive, elite NFC team with a proven quarterback and coach. Choose the Browns if you're a loyal supporter committed to building through a difficult rebuilding period, though near-term success is unlikely.
Cleveland Browns: 2 | San Francisco 49ers: 0
Cleveland Browns: 4.2 | San Francisco 49ers: 3.9
Cleveland Browns: 0 | San Francisco 49ers: 0
Cleveland Browns: Standard approach | San Francisco 49ers: 14 reserve/future deals
Cleveland Browns: Fair - Turnover issues | San Francisco 49ers: Excellent - Clean execution
Cleveland Browns: 4-2 | San Francisco 49ers: 0-0
Cleveland Browns: 27.3% | San Francisco 49ers: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 44.4% | San Francisco 49ers: N/A
Average Points Per Game vs This Opponent
Cleveland Browns: 18.1 | San Francisco 49ers: N/A
Cleveland Browns: Cleveland Browns | San Francisco 49ers: N/A
Leading Running Back Rushing Yards (2025)
Cleveland Browns: 35.5% | San Francisco 49ers: 64.5%
Cleveland Browns: Deshaun Gabriel 110 yards | San Francisco 49ers: Brock Purdy 2,167 yards
Cleveland Browns: 20.2 | San Francisco 49ers: 19.0
Cleveland Browns: 46.7% | San Francisco 49ers: 75.0%
Cleveland Browns: Quinshon Judkins 827 yards | San Francisco 49ers: Christian McCaffrey depth role
Cleveland Browns: 77 seasons overall | San Francisco 49ers: 80 seasons overall
Cleveland Browns: 11 | San Francisco 49ers: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 22.4 | San Francisco 49ers: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 19:10 | San Francisco 49ers: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 64.7% | San Francisco 49ers: N/A
Primary Running Back Rushing Yards (2025)
Cleveland Browns: 827 (Quinshon Judkins) | San Francisco 49ers: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 73rd season (2025) | San Francisco 49ers: N/A
Cleveland Browns: Multiple starters (Watson, Gabriel, Flacco) | San Francisco 49ers: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 32nd | San Francisco 49ers: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 6-9 | San Francisco 49ers: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 0 | San Francisco 49ers: N/A
Cleveland Browns: Lost 29-31 | San Francisco 49ers: N/A
Cleveland Browns: Below .500 | San Francisco 49ers: N/A
Cleveland Browns: ~2,000 yards | San Francisco 49ers: N/A
Cleveland Browns: ~15 TDs | San Francisco 49ers: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 3 appearances | San Francisco 49ers: N/A
Cleveland Browns: Lost 3-31 | San Francisco 49ers: N/A
Cleveland Browns: ~55% | San Francisco 49ers: 69.4% (Brock Purdy)
Cleveland Browns: ~82 | San Francisco 49ers: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 61 years (1964) | San Francisco 49ers: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 3-14 | San Francisco 49ers: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 16.7 | San Francisco 49ers: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 478 | San Francisco 49ers: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 0 wins | San Francisco 49ers: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 0 | San Francisco 49ers: 5 championships
Cleveland Browns: 2 | San Francisco 49ers: 13
Cleveland Browns: 3,964 (Deshaun Watson) | San Francisco 49ers: 4,694 (Brock Purdy)
QB Touchdown-to-Interception Ratio (2024)
Cleveland Browns: 1.69 (27 TDs / 16 INTs) | San Francisco 49ers: 3.44 (31 TDs / 9 INTs)
Cleveland Browns: 3-14 | San Francisco 49ers: 12-5 (4th seed, NFC)
Cleveland Browns: 6 seasons (Kevin Stefanski, since 2020) | San Francisco 49ers: 8 seasons (Kyle Shanahan, since 2017)
Cleveland Browns: 8 | San Francisco 49ers: 19
All-Time Head-to-Head Record (Since 1996)
Cleveland Browns: 29-35 | San Francisco 49ers: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 6 | San Francisco 49ers: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 8 | San Francisco 49ers: N/A
Cleveland Browns: $230M (Watson) | San Francisco 49ers: N/A
Offensive Points Per Game (2023-24 Season)
Cleveland Browns: 21.5 | San Francisco 49ers: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 118.2 | San Francisco 49ers: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 77 years (1964) | San Francisco 49ers: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 28-32 (since 1996) | San Francisco 49ers: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 2 | San Francisco 49ers: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 56.3% | San Francisco 49ers: N/A
Cleveland Browns: $57.5M (Deshaun Watson) | San Francisco 49ers: N/A
Cleveland Browns: $3.2B | San Francisco 49ers: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 544-689-10 (.441 win percentage) | San Francisco 49ers: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 42-81-1 vs Steelers | San Francisco 49ers: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 3 (2020, 2022, 2023) | San Francisco 49ers: N/A
Cleveland Browns: Never won | San Francisco 49ers: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 3-14 (.176) | San Francisco 49ers: 12-5 (.706)
Cleveland Browns: 8 Hall of Famers | San Francisco 49ers: 14 Hall of Famers
Cleveland Browns: 82.4 (Deshaun Watson) | San Francisco 49ers: 107.2 (Brock Purdy)
Cleveland Browns: 4th Place AFC North | San Francisco 49ers: 1st Place NFC West
Cleveland Browns: 38 years (1987) | San Francisco 49ers: 1 year (2024 won)
Cleveland Browns: 11-6 | San Francisco 49ers: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 2 appearances | San Francisco 49ers: 7 appearances
Cleveland Browns: $230M (Deshaun Watson) | San Francisco 49ers: N/A
Cleveland Browns: $8.2M | San Francisco 49ers: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 76 years (since 1950) | San Francisco 49ers: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 2 (2020, 2022) | San Francisco 49ers: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 0 appearances | San Francisco 49ers: 6
Cleveland Browns: .447 (515-638-11) | San Francisco 49ers: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 8 titles | San Francisco 49ers: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 6 appearances | San Francisco 49ers: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 7 wins (16 games) | San Francisco 49ers: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 1946 | San Francisco 49ers: N/A
Conference Championships (pre-Super Bowl era & modern)
Cleveland Browns: 8 total | San Francisco 49ers: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 5 seasons (Kevin Stefanski, 2020-present) | San Francisco 49ers: 7 seasons (Kyle Shanahan, 2017-present)
2025 Defense Ranking (Yards Allowed/Game)
Cleveland Browns: 364.5 yards (22nd) | San Francisco 49ers: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 379.8 yards (7th) | San Francisco 49ers: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 3 appearances (2020, 2021, 2023) | San Francisco 49ers: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 2 (Jim Brown, Otto Graham) | San Francisco 49ers: N/A
Head Coach Regular Season Win Percentage
Cleveland Browns: 54.0% (Stefanski) | San Francisco 49ers: N/A
Cleveland Browns: Never | San Francisco 49ers: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 77 years (since 1946) | San Francisco 49ers: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 67,431 | San Francisco 49ers: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 13-33 | San Francisco 49ers: N/A
Winning Percentage (last 10 seasons: 2015-2024)
Cleveland Browns: 46.3% | San Francisco 49ers: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 5 seasons (Stefanski) | San Francisco 49ers: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 11-6 (missed playoffs) | San Francisco 49ers: 12-5 (.706 winning %)
Cleveland Browns: 1 (Deshaun Watson - 3x Pro Bowler career) | San Francisco 49ers: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 42.1% | San Francisco 49ers: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 3 years (Kevin Stefanski) | San Francisco 49ers: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 40 wins | San Francisco 49ers: N/A
Division Titles (Last 25 Years: 1999-2024)
Cleveland Browns: 3 titles | San Francisco 49ers: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 9 | San Francisco 49ers: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 8 appearances | San Francisco 49ers: N/A
Cleveland Browns: $230M (5-year Deshaun Watson) | San Francisco 49ers: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 1 | San Francisco 49ers: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 3 | San Francisco 49ers: N/A
Regular Season Win Percentage (2020-2026)
Cleveland Browns: 47.6% | San Francisco 49ers: N/A
Cleveland Browns: Kevin Stefanski: 0 | San Francisco 49ers: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 32 years (1994) | San Francisco 49ers: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 17.6% | San Francisco 49ers: N/A
Starting Quarterback MVP Awards (Career)
Cleveland Browns: Deshaun Watson: 0 | San Francisco 49ers: N/A
Consecutive Playoff Appearances (2020-2026)
Cleveland Browns: 4 of 6 seasons | San Francisco 49ers: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 92.1 | San Francisco 49ers: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 354.1 | San Francisco 49ers: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 23.4 | San Francisco 49ers: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 2 | San Francisco 49ers: 5 consecutive
Cleveland Browns: 4 years (2020) | San Francisco 49ers: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 41-62 (.398 win %) | San Francisco 49ers: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 78 years (founded 1946) | San Francisco 49ers: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 2 (1964, 1965) | San Francisco 49ers: N/A
Cleveland Browns: $230M (Deshaun Watson, 2022) | San Francisco 49ers: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 85.5 | San Francisco 49ers: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 312.4 yards | San Francisco 49ers: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 348.1 yards | San Francisco 49ers: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 8.5-8.5 | San Francisco 49ers: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 20.1 points | San Francisco 49ers: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 5 players | San Francisco 49ers: N/A
Cleveland Browns: 0 titles | San Francisco 49ers: N/A
Cleveland Browns: N/A | San Francisco 49ers: 13-4
Cleveland Browns: N/A | San Francisco 49ers: 26.3
Cleveland Browns: N/A | San Francisco 49ers: 18.2
Cleveland Browns: N/A | San Francisco 49ers: 134.2
Cleveland Browns: N/A | San Francisco 49ers: 259.8
Cleveland Browns: N/A | San Francisco 49ers: 4
Cleveland Browns: N/A | San Francisco 49ers: 71.4%
Cleveland Browns: N/A | San Francisco 49ers: 5
Cleveland Browns: N/A | San Francisco 49ers: 12
Cleveland Browns: N/A | San Francisco 49ers: 234.2
Cleveland Browns: N/A | San Francisco 49ers: 148.7
Cleveland Browns: N/A | San Francisco 49ers: 18.9
Cleveland Browns: N/A | San Francisco 49ers: 63.2%
Cleveland Browns: N/A | San Francisco 49ers: 6
Cleveland Browns: N/A | San Francisco 49ers: $267M
Cleveland Browns: N/A | San Francisco 49ers: 3
Cleveland Browns: N/A | San Francisco 49ers: 14
Cleveland Browns: N/A | San Francisco 49ers: $8.1B
Cleveland Browns: N/A | San Francisco 49ers: 641-618
Cleveland Browns: N/A | San Francisco 49ers: 1995
Cleveland Browns: N/A | San Francisco 49ers: Kyle Shanahan .606 (54-35)
Cleveland Browns: N/A | San Francisco 49ers: 16
Cleveland Browns: N/A | San Francisco 49ers: 19
How to choose between Cleveland Browns and San Francisco 49ers
Compare Cleveland Browns vs San Francisco 49ers
Cleveland Browns vs San Francisco 49ers — Structured Comparison Data
Machine-readable comparison dataset for Cleveland Browns vs San Francisco 49ers. Contains 169 attribute comparisons, 5 FAQ pairs.
Cleveland Browns vs San Francisco 49ers — Attribute Category Vocabulary
Taxonomy of attribute categories used to classify comparison data for Cleveland Browns vs San Francisco 49ers.
How many times have these teams played each other?
The Browns and 49ers have played each other 8 times in the regular season since 1992, with the 49ers holding a 5-3 series advantage. They are in different conferences (AFC North vs NFC West) so matchups occur only every 4 years when divisions rotate.
Which team is more likely to contend for a championship soon?
The 49ers are immediate championship contenders for 2025-2026 with their 12-5 record, elite defense, and proven QB. The Browns are in a rebuilding phase and unlikely to contend for at least 2-3 years based on their current 3-14 record and quarterback inconsistency.
The San Francisco 49ers have won 5 Super Bowl championships (1982, 1985, 1989, 1995, 2024), while the Cleveland Browns have never won a Super Bowl despite making 2 appearances in 1980 and 1987. The 49ers won the most recent championship in February 2024.
Are the Browns making the playoffs in 2025?
No. With a 3-14 record as of end of 2025 regular season, the Browns finished last in the AFC North and are eliminated from playoff contention. They would need significant roster improvements and quarterback performance changes for 2026.
Which team has the better quarterback right now?
Brock Purdy of the 49ers is significantly outperforming Deshaun Watson of the Browns in 2025. Purdy has a 107.2 passer rating with a 23:8 TD-to-INT ratio, while Watson has an 82.4 rating with inconsistent play. Purdy is an MVP-caliber quarterback while Watson continues struggling to justify his contract investment.
How to Choose Between Cleveland Browns and San Francisco 49ers
All-Time Win-Loss Record: Cleveland Browns has 395-506-7 (.438 winning percentage), while San Francisco 49ers has 586-529-16 (.525 winning percentage).
Super Bowl Appearances: Cleveland Browns has 2 (1980, 1987), while San Francisco 49ers has 6 (1982, 1985, 1989, 1995, 2020, 2024).
Super Bowl Wins: Cleveland Browns has 0 championships, while San Francisco 49ers has 5 championships (1982, 1985, 1989, 1995, 2024).
2025 Season Record: Cleveland Browns has 3-14 (Last Place AFC North), while San Francisco 49ers has 12-5 (NFC West Leader).
Consider: Playoff Appearances (Last 10 Years)
Playoff Appearances (Last 10 Years): Cleveland Browns has 2 appearances (2020, 2023), while San Francisco 49ers has 7 appearances (2019, 2021, 2022, 2023, 2024, 2025).
Hall of Fame Players: Cleveland Browns has 8 (Jim Brown, Otto Graham, Paul Brown, Len Ford, Dante Lavelli, Lou Groza, Bernie Kosar, Dick Modzelewski), while San Francisco 49ers has 14 (Joe Montana, Jerry Rice, Steve Young, Steve Largent, Ronnie Lott, Rod Walsh, John Taylor, Tai Streets, Terrell Owens, Eric Wright, Bryant Young, Patrick Willis, Richard Sherman, Justin Smith).
Head Coach Tenure Stability: Cleveland Browns has Kevin Stefanski 4 years (hired 2020), while San Francisco 49ers has Kyle Shanahan 7 years (hired 2017).