BMW dominates in performance and handling with turbocharged engines and sport-tuned suspensions, while Cadillac emphasizes American luxury with larger interiors and more affordable entry prices. BMW averages $65,000-$120,000 while Cadillac ranges $35,000-$85,000, making Cadillac the budget-conscious choice.
BMW vs Cadillac — Side-by-side comparison on A Versus B
German luxury automaker known for performance-oriented sedans and SUVs with advanced turbocharged engines.
American luxury brand offering spacious sedans and SUVs with traditional luxury comfort and value pricing.
Starting Price. Engine Performance (M340i/CTS-V baseline). 0-60 mph (M340i vs CTS). Average Interior Space (Sedan). EPA Fuel Economy (330i/CT4). Warranty Coverage (Basic). Infotainment System (Latest)
Choose BMW if you prioritize dynamic handling, turbocharged performance, and cutting-edge technology—you'll pay more but get sport-sedan credentials and lower fuel consumption. Choose Cadillac if you value spacious American-style interiors, smoother ride quality, lower starting prices, and traditional luxury at a better value proposition.
BMW: Traditional integrated | Cadillac: N/A
BMW: XM plug-in redesigned | Cadillac: N/A
BMW: New 3-Series, refreshed 7-Series, ALPINA B7 | Cadillac: N/A
BMW: Sport-oriented handling | Cadillac: N/A
BMW: Silicon carbide inverters on i4 | Cadillac: N/A
BMW: 15+ models including new i3 sedan | Cadillac: N/A
BMW: iDrive 8.5 with gesture recognition | Cadillac: N/A
BMW: XM: 523 hp redesigned | Cadillac: N/A
BMW: i4: 301 miles with new tech | Cadillac: N/A
BMW: i4: 108 MPGe with silicon carbide tech | Cadillac: N/A
BMW: Nappa leather, advanced ambient tech | Cadillac: N/A
BMW: 5-star equivalent modern systems | Cadillac: N/A
BMW: 6+ models including redesigned X5 | Cadillac: N/A
BMW: i4 eDrive40 (18-inch wheels) | Cadillac: N/A
BMW: Premium traditional, physical controls, luxury materials | Cadillac: N/A
BMW: Quarterly scheduled updates | Cadillac: N/A
BMW: Level 2 with advanced driver assistance | Cadillac: N/A
BMW: BMW home charging with faster technology (2026) | Cadillac: N/A
BMW: 382 hp (B58 3.0L turbo) | Cadillac: N/A
BMW: Leather trim with high-quality plastics | Cadillac: N/A
BMW: 4.4 seconds (M340i) | Cadillac: N/A
BMW: 4 years / 50,000 miles | Cadillac: N/A
BMW: 301 miles (iX xDrive50) | Cadillac: N/A
BMW: 4 years / 50k miles | Cadillac: N/A
BMW: 16.5 cu ft (3 Series) | Cadillac: N/A
BMW: 382 hp (3-Series M440i) | Cadillac: N/A
BMW: 4.6s (3-Series M440i) | Cadillac: N/A
BMW: 3 models (i4, iX, i7) | Cadillac: 2 models
Average Reliability Rating (J.D. Power 2024)
BMW: 382 hp (M440i xDrive) | Cadillac: N/A
BMW: 0.15s (8-speed automatic) | Cadillac: N/A
BMW: 11.6 cu ft (3 Series) | Cadillac: N/A
BMW: 3.0L Twin-Turbo | Cadillac: 3.6L Naturally Aspirated
BMW: 12.3 curved | Cadillac: 10.2 standard
BMW: N/A | Cadillac: 3 years / 36,000 miles
BMW: N/A | Cadillac: 200,000+ (SuperCruise)
BMW: N/A | Cadillac: 235 hp (2.0L Turbo)
BMW: N/A | Cadillac: 404 hp (3.0L Turbo CT5-V)
Average Resale Value Retention (3 years)
Combined Fuel Efficiency (Mid-Size Sedan)
BMW: N/A | Cadillac: 655 hp (6.2L Supercharged V8)
BMW vs Cadillac — Structured Comparison Data
Machine-readable comparison dataset for BMW vs Cadillac. Contains 137 attribute comparisons, 5 FAQ pairs.
BMW vs Cadillac — Attribute Category Vocabulary
Taxonomy of attribute categories used to classify comparison data for BMW vs Cadillac.
Both score similarly in reliability ratings (BMW J.D. Power: 81/100, Cadillac: 79/100). However, Cadillac's simpler naturally aspirated engines typically require less complex maintenance, while BMW's turbocharged systems can be more expensive to repair. Long-term reliability depends on dealer service quality.
Cadillac SUVs (Escalade: 6,000 lbs) outperform BMW SUVs for towing. The BMW X5 offers 5,951 lbs, making Cadillac the better choice for serious towing needs. However, BMW sedans don't offer towing while Cadillac's CT4 sedan also lacks towing capacity.
BMW averages 58% 3-year resale value while Cadillac averages 52%, giving BMW a 6-point advantage. Premium turbocharged BMW models hold value better due to stronger market demand, though this varies by model and market conditions.
NHTSA and IIHS safety ratings are comparable between BMW (4.8/5.0 average) and Cadillac (4.7/5.0 average) models. Both include standard advanced driver assistance systems (ADAS), lane keeping assist, and adaptive cruise control across their lineups.
Which brand offers better warranty coverage?
Both BMW and Cadillac offer identical base warranties: 4 years/50,000 miles basic, 6 years/70,000 miles powertrain. BMW's extended warranty options are typically more expensive ($2,000-$3,500) compared to Cadillac ($1,800-$2,800).
Starting Price: BMW has $35,000, while Cadillac has $65,000.
Consider: Engine Performance (M340i/CTS-V baseline)
Engine Performance (M340i/CTS-V baseline): BMW has 382 hp, 3.0L Twin-Turbo, while Cadillac has 335 hp, 3.6L Naturally Aspirated.
0-60 mph (M340i vs CTS): BMW has 4.2 seconds, while Cadillac has 5.4 seconds.
Consider: Average Interior Space (Sedan)
Average Interior Space (Sedan): BMW has 105 cu ft, while Cadillac has 110 cu ft.
EPA Fuel Economy (330i/CT4): BMW has 28 mpg combined, while Cadillac has 24 mpg combined.
Warranty Coverage (Basic): BMW has 4 years/50,000 miles, while Cadillac has 4 years/50,000 miles.
Infotainment System (Latest): BMW has iDrive 8, 12.3" curved screen, while Cadillac has Cadillac User Experience, 10.2" touchscreen.