San Francisco 49ers vs Indianapolis Colts
The 49ers are a modern NFL powerhouse with 5 Super Bowl titles and a dominant defense, while the Colts are a historically significant franchise with 2 Super Bowl wins that has struggled with inconsistent quarterback play in recent years.
San Francisco 49ers vs Indianapolis Colts — Side-by-side comparison on A Versus B
NFL franchise based in San Francisco, California, competing in the NFC West division since 1946.
Historic franchise with 2 Super Bowl titles currently rebuilding with young talent
Super Bowl Championships. Recent Playoff Success (2019-2024). Head Coach Tenure & Stability. Franchise All-Time Win-Loss Record. 2024 Season Record. Hall of Famers Produced. Starting Quarterback Stability (2023-2024)
The 49ers are the superior franchise in 2024, with a dominant recent trajectory, elite coaching, and championship pedigree. Choose the 49ers if you value consistent excellence, innovative coaching systems, and a winning culture. Choose the Colts if you prefer a historic franchise with potential for rebuilding around young talent like Anthony Richardson, though they require patience given their current 8-9 record and playoff drought.
San Francisco 49ers: 13-4 | Indianapolis Colts: 8-9
San Francisco 49ers: 26.3 | Indianapolis Colts: 23.1
San Francisco 49ers: 18.2 | Indianapolis Colts: 24.7
San Francisco 49ers: 134.2 | Indianapolis Colts: 108.6
San Francisco 49ers: 259.8 | Indianapolis Colts: 287.3
San Francisco 49ers: 4 | Indianapolis Colts: 0
San Francisco 49ers: 71.4% | Indianapolis Colts: 56.3%
San Francisco 49ers: 5 | Indianapolis Colts: 1
San Francisco 49ers: 12 | Indianapolis Colts: N/A
San Francisco 49ers: 234.2 | Indianapolis Colts: N/A
San Francisco 49ers: 148.7 | Indianapolis Colts: N/A
San Francisco 49ers: 18.9 | Indianapolis Colts: N/A
San Francisco 49ers: 6 | Indianapolis Colts: N/A
San Francisco 49ers: 63.2% | Indianapolis Colts: N/A
San Francisco 49ers: $267M | Indianapolis Colts: N/A
San Francisco 49ers: 0 | Indianapolis Colts: N/A
San Francisco 49ers: 3.9 | Indianapolis Colts: N/A
San Francisco 49ers: 14 reserve/future deals | Indianapolis Colts: N/A
San Francisco 49ers: Excellent - Clean execution | Indianapolis Colts: N/A
San Francisco 49ers: 0-0 | Indianapolis Colts: N/A
San Francisco 49ers: 64.5% | Indianapolis Colts: N/A
San Francisco 49ers: 5 (1988, 1989, 1994, 1995, 2021) | Indianapolis Colts: N/A
San Francisco 49ers: Brock Purdy 2,167 yards | Indianapolis Colts: N/A
San Francisco 49ers: 19.0 | Indianapolis Colts: N/A
San Francisco 49ers: 75.0% | Indianapolis Colts: N/A
San Francisco 49ers: 69.4% (Brock Purdy) | Indianapolis Colts: N/A
San Francisco 49ers: Christian McCaffrey depth role | Indianapolis Colts: N/A
San Francisco 49ers: 80 seasons overall | Indianapolis Colts: N/A
San Francisco 49ers: 5 championships | Indianapolis Colts: 2
San Francisco 49ers: 12-5 (.706 winning %) | Indianapolis Colts: 8-9
San Francisco 49ers: 5 consecutive | Indianapolis Colts: 0 of 5
San Francisco 49ers: 3 | Indianapolis Colts: 0
San Francisco 49ers: 14 | Indianapolis Colts: 6
San Francisco 49ers: 7 seasons (Kyle Shanahan, 2017-present) | Indianapolis Colts: 2 seasons (Shane Steichen, 2023-present)
San Francisco 49ers: $8.1B | Indianapolis Colts: $3.8B
San Francisco 49ers: 641-618 | Indianapolis Colts: N/A
San Francisco 49ers: 1995 | Indianapolis Colts: N/A
San Francisco 49ers: Kyle Shanahan .606 (54-35) | Indianapolis Colts: N/A
San Francisco 49ers: 16 | Indianapolis Colts: N/A
San Francisco 49ers: 19 | Indianapolis Colts: N/A
San Francisco 49ers: 13 | Indianapolis Colts: N/A
San Francisco 49ers: 4,694 (Brock Purdy) | Indianapolis Colts: N/A
QB Touchdown-to-Interception Ratio (2024)
San Francisco 49ers: 3.44 (31 TDs / 9 INTs) | Indianapolis Colts: N/A
San Francisco 49ers: 12-5 (4th seed, NFC) | Indianapolis Colts: N/A
San Francisco 49ers: 8 seasons (Kyle Shanahan, since 2017) | Indianapolis Colts: N/A
San Francisco 49ers: .525 (586-529-16) | Indianapolis Colts: 43.8%
San Francisco 49ers: 12-5 (.706) | Indianapolis Colts: N/A
San Francisco 49ers: 7 appearances | Indianapolis Colts: N/A
San Francisco 49ers: 14 Hall of Famers | Indianapolis Colts: N/A
San Francisco 49ers: 107.2 (Brock Purdy) | Indianapolis Colts: N/A
San Francisco 49ers: 1st Place NFC West | Indianapolis Colts: N/A
San Francisco 49ers: 1 year (2024 won) | Indianapolis Colts: N/A
San Francisco 49ers: N/A | Indianapolis Colts: 24.3
San Francisco 49ers: N/A | Indianapolis Colts: 22.8
San Francisco 49ers: N/A | Indianapolis Colts: 108.2
San Francisco 49ers: N/A | Indianapolis Colts: 285.9
San Francisco 49ers: N/A | Indianapolis Colts: 2.1
San Francisco 49ers: N/A | Indianapolis Colts: 18
San Francisco 49ers: N/A | Indianapolis Colts: 7-6
San Francisco 49ers: N/A | Indianapolis Colts: 42.1%
San Francisco 49ers: N/A | Indianapolis Colts: .549
San Francisco 49ers: N/A | Indianapolis Colts: 13 appearances
San Francisco 49ers: N/A | Indianapolis Colts: 9 titles
AFC/NFC Championship Game Appearances (2000-2026)
San Francisco 49ers: N/A | Indianapolis Colts: 4 appearances
San Francisco 49ers: N/A | Indianapolis Colts: 6+ years (Frank Reich, 2018-present)
Consecutive Playoff Seasons (Best Streak)
San Francisco 49ers: N/A | Indianapolis Colts: 8 consecutive (2002-2009)
San Francisco 49ers: N/A | Indianapolis Colts: 370+ wins
How to choose between San Francisco 49ers and Indianapolis Colts
Compare San Francisco 49ers vs Indianapolis Colts
San Francisco 49ers vs Indianapolis Colts — Structured Comparison Data
Machine-readable comparison dataset for San Francisco 49ers vs Indianapolis Colts. Contains 72 attribute comparisons, 5 FAQ pairs.
San Francisco 49ers vs Indianapolis Colts — Attribute Category Vocabulary
Taxonomy of attribute categories used to classify comparison data for San Francisco 49ers vs Indianapolis Colts.
Why haven't the Colts made the playoffs recently?
The Colts have struggled with quarterback instability and inconsistent roster construction since Peyton Manning's departure in 2012. Anthony Richardson, the 2023 #1 pick, has dealt with persistent injuries limiting his development. The team went 8-9 in 2024 and has not won a playoff game since 2014, representing a 10-year competitive decline.
What makes the 49ers so dominant lately?
Kyle Shanahan's innovative offensive system, elite defensive talent (Nick Bosa won DPOY in 2023), and consistent roster management have created sustained success. The 49ers reached 3 Super Bowls in the last 5 seasons and maintain a top-tier defense consistently. Their quarterback, Brock Purdy, has been efficient when healthy, though durability remains a concern.
Which franchise has a better historical legacy?
The 49ers have 5 Super Bowl championships and a .555 winning percentage versus the Colts' 2 titles and .438 percentage. The 49ers produced 14 Hall of Famers (Joe Montana, Jerry Rice, Steve Young) while the Colts produced 6 (John Unitas, Peyton Manning, Eric Dickerson). The 49ers' dynasty era (1980s-1990s) outpaces the Colts' peak periods.
Is Anthony Richardson the future of the Colts?
Richardson has elite physical tools and potential as a franchise QB but has missed significant time to injury. In 2024, he played only 4 games due to shoulder problems. The Colts are banking on his development, but his durability remains uncertain. Gardner Minshew started most games in 2024 while Richardson recovered.
Who is more likely to win a Super Bowl in 2025?
The 49ers are among the favorites with odds around 8:1 (per major sportsbooks), while the Colts' odds exceed 75:1 due to their current 8-9 record and playoff drought. The 49ers' roster, coaching, and recent success make them far more likely Super Bowl contenders in the near term.
How to Choose Between San Francisco 49ers and Indianapolis Colts
Super Bowl Championships: San Francisco 49ers has 5 titles (1982, 1985, 1989, 1995, 2020), while Indianapolis Colts has 2 titles (2007, 1971 as Baltimore Colts).
Consider: Recent Playoff Success (2019-2024)
Recent Playoff Success (2019-2024): San Francisco 49ers has 3 Super Bowl appearances, 1 championship, while Indianapolis Colts has 0 playoff wins in last 5 seasons.
Head Coach Tenure & Stability: San Francisco 49ers has Kyle Shanahan since 2017 (7 seasons), while Indianapolis Colts has Shane Steichen since 2023 (2 seasons).
Consider: Franchise All-Time Win-Loss Record
Franchise All-Time Win-Loss Record: San Francisco 49ers has 511-410-16 (.555 winning percentage), while Indianapolis Colts has 535-686-13 (.438 winning percentage).
2024 Season Record: San Francisco 49ers has 12-5 (1st NFC West), while Indianapolis Colts has 8-9 (3rd AFC South, missed playoffs).
Hall of Famers Produced: San Francisco 49ers has 14 (Young, Montana, Rice, Lott, Walsh, others), while Indianapolis Colts has 6 (Manning, Unitas, Dickerson, Faulk, others).
Consider: Starting Quarterback Stability (2023-2024)
Starting Quarterback Stability (2023-2024): San Francisco 49ers has Brock Purdy consistent starter, while Indianapolis Colts has Anthony Richardson (injury-plagued), Gardner Minshew.