{"id":"cmrd8ptxn00715xvxjjrwv3mu","slug":"fly-io-vs-render)","title":"Fly.io vs Render","shortAnswer":"Fly.io offers global edge deployment with lower latency for distributed applications, while Render provides simpler onboarding and better pricing transparency for standard web apps. Fly.io excels for performance-critical apps, Render for developers prioritizing ease-of-use.","keyDifferences":[{"label":"Global Edge Deployment","winner":"a","entityAValue":"Yes - 30+ regions worldwide","entityBValue":"No - centralized US regions only"},{"label":"Startup Pricing Tier","winner":"a","entityAValue":"$0/month (pay-as-you-go, ~$0.15/GB bandwidth)","entityBValue":"$7/month minimum"},{"label":"Free Tier Available","winner":"tie","entityAValue":"Yes - $0.15/GB bandwidth, no time limits","entityBValue":"Yes - $7/month but with free tier features"},{"label":"Deployment Speed","winner":"a","entityAValue":"~30-60 seconds average","entityBValue":"~45-90 seconds average"},{"label":"Learning Curve","winner":"b","entityAValue":"Moderate - Requires Fly CLI familiarity","entityBValue":"Low - Git-based, similar to Heroku"},{"label":"Docker Support","winner":"a","entityAValue":"Native - Any Dockerfile supported","entityBValue":"Buildpack-first, Docker supported but secondary"},{"label":"Database Included","winner":"b","entityAValue":"PostgreSQL: $15/month (1GB), MySQL available","entityBValue":"PostgreSQL: $9/month (1GB), MySQL: $11/month"}],"verdict":"Choose Fly.io if you need global edge deployment, ultra-low latency for distributed users, or cost-effective scaling with Docker flexibility. Choose Render if you want the simplest possible deployment experience, prefer Heroku-like Git workflows, or need competitive database pricing with less operational overhead.","category":"software","entities":[{"id":"cmpp6evr201pyv4d8dtwolmhe","slug":"fly-io","name":"Fly.io","shortDesc":"Global edge deployment platform with distributed computing across 30+ worldwide regions.","imageUrl":null,"entityType":"products","position":0,"pros":["30+ global regions enabling sub-100ms latency for users worldwide","Native Docker support - deploy any containerized application","Pay-as-you-go pricing with true free tier (no credit card required)","PostgreSQL and MySQL databases with auto-scaling","Built-in DDoS protection and automatic SSL/TLS certificates"],"cons":["Steeper learning curve - requires Fly CLI and Docker understanding","Smaller community compared to Heroku/Render (limited third-party integrations)"],"bestFor":"Developers building performance-critical apps, real-time applications, APIs serving global users, and startups optimizing infrastructure costs."},{"id":"cmpp6e7lm01o8v4d8sxgqvc5l","slug":"render","name":"Render","shortDesc":"Developer-friendly PaaS platform with Git-based deployments and simplified infrastructure management.","imageUrl":null,"entityType":"products","position":1,"pros":["Heroku-like simplicity - Git push to deploy with zero Docker knowledge needed","Competitive database pricing ($9/month for 1GB PostgreSQL)","Native background jobs, cron jobs, and scheduled tasks","Generous free tier includes 750 hours/month of compute","Excellent documentation and responsive community support"],"cons":["US-only server locations result in higher latency for international users","Limited Docker customization compared to competitors"],"bestFor":"Indie developers, small teams, traditional web applications, and developers prioritizing simplicity over global performance optimization."}],"attributes":[{"id":"cmpp6exds01qfv4d83f9ccliq","slug":"global-data-center-regions","name":"Global Data Center Regions","unit":"count","category":"Infrastructure","dataType":"number","higherIsBetter":true,"values":[{"entityId":"cmpp6evr201pyv4d8dtwolmhe","valueText":"35+ regions","valueNumber":35,"valueBoolean":null,"winner":true},{"entityId":"cmpp6e7lm01o8v4d8sxgqvc5l","valueText":"2 regions","valueNumber":2,"valueBoolean":null,"winner":false}]},{"id":"cmpi7acex01bfachd8y4w5hct","slug":"starting-monthly-price","name":"Starting Monthly Price","unit":"USD","category":"Pricing","dataType":"number","higherIsBetter":false,"values":[{"entityId":"cmpp6evr201pyv4d8dtwolmhe","valueText":"Pay-as-you-go from $0","valueNumber":0,"valueBoolean":null,"winner":true},{"entityId":"cmpp6e7lm01o8v4d8sxgqvc5l","valueText":"$7/month","valueNumber":7,"valueBoolean":null,"winner":false}]},{"id":"cmpp6eykp01qpv4d8dlwsjk0u","slug":"free-monthly-credits","name":"Free Monthly Credits","unit":"USD","category":"Pricing","dataType":"number","higherIsBetter":true,"values":[{"entityId":"cmpp6evr201pyv4d8dtwolmhe","valueText":"$15","valueNumber":15,"valueBoolean":null},{"entityId":"cmpp6e7lm01o8v4d8sxgqvc5l","valueText":"Full free tier","valueNumber":null,"valueBoolean":null}]},{"id":"cmpp6e9rr01otv4d8khlaqe82","slug":"cold-start-latency","name":"Cold Start Latency","unit":"seconds","category":"Performance","dataType":"number","higherIsBetter":false,"values":[{"entityId":"cmpp6evr201pyv4d8dtwolmhe","valueText":"<50ms","valueNumber":50,"valueBoolean":null,"winner":true},{"entityId":"cmpp6e7lm01o8v4d8sxgqvc5l","valueText":"100-500ms","valueNumber":300,"valueBoolean":null,"winner":false}]},{"id":"cmpp6ezrz01qzv4d8yiysj620","slug":"maximum-concurrent-instances","name":"Maximum Concurrent Instances","unit":"instances","category":"Scaling","dataType":"number","higherIsBetter":true,"values":[{"entityId":"cmpp6evr201pyv4d8dtwolmhe","valueText":"100+","valueNumber":100,"valueBoolean":null,"winner":true},{"entityId":"cmpp6e7lm01o8v4d8sxgqvc5l","valueText":"30","valueNumber":30,"valueBoolean":null,"winner":false}]},{"id":"cmpp6f0fg01r5v4d8ahk2d39x","slug":"included-database","name":"Included Database","unit":null,"category":"Features","dataType":"text","higherIsBetter":null,"values":[{"entityId":"cmpp6evr201pyv4d8dtwolmhe","valueText":"PostgreSQL (paid add-on)","valueNumber":null,"valueBoolean":null},{"entityId":"cmpp6e7lm01o8v4d8sxgqvc5l","valueText":"PostgreSQL + Redis included","valueNumber":null,"valueBoolean":null}]},{"id":"cmpp6eb2o01p5v4d87bvmqwdy","slug":"supported-runtimes","name":"Supported Runtimes","unit":null,"category":"Compatibility","dataType":"text","higherIsBetter":null,"values":[{"entityId":"cmpp6evr201pyv4d8dtwolmhe","valueText":"Any Docker container","valueNumber":null,"valueBoolean":null},{"entityId":"cmpp6e7lm01o8v4d8sxgqvc5l","valueText":"6 native runtimes","valueNumber":null,"valueBoolean":null}]},{"id":"cmoe6lcbl0077ooj6ah9eb55a","slug":"setup-complexity","name":"Setup Complexity","unit":null,"category":"Ease of Use","dataType":"text","higherIsBetter":false,"values":[{"entityId":"cmpp6evr201pyv4d8dtwolmhe","valueText":"Moderate (CLI-heavy)","valueNumber":null,"valueBoolean":null},{"entityId":"cmpp6e7lm01o8v4d8sxgqvc5l","valueText":"Minimal (dashboard UI)","valueNumber":null,"valueBoolean":null}]},{"id":"cmqq54mni009vr0tb7va6qn6n","slug":"cpu-cost-per-hour","name":"CPU Cost Per Hour","unit":"USD per CPU-hour","category":"Pricing","dataType":"number","higherIsBetter":false,"values":[{"entityId":"cmpp6evr201pyv4d8dtwolmhe","valueText":"$0.0000228","valueNumber":0.0000228,"valueBoolean":null}]},{"id":"cmqpblmqw002l6alpqv3p3s02","slug":"global-regions-available","name":"Global Regions Available","unit":"regions","category":"Global Presence","dataType":"number","higherIsBetter":true,"values":[{"entityId":"cmpp6evr201pyv4d8dtwolmhe","valueText":"35+ regions","valueNumber":35,"valueBoolean":null}]},{"id":"cmqq54mo800a7r0tb7livkm8q","slug":"free-database-storage","name":"Free Database Storage","unit":"GB","category":"Database","dataType":"number","higherIsBetter":true,"values":[{"entityId":"cmpp6evr201pyv4d8dtwolmhe","valueText":"1 GB included free","valueNumber":1,"valueBoolean":null}]},{"id":"cmqq54mog00abr0tbrn2lll0d","slug":"docker-support","name":"Docker Support","unit":null,"category":"Deployment","dataType":"text","higherIsBetter":null,"values":[{"entityId":"cmpp6evr201pyv4d8dtwolmhe","valueText":"Native Docker requirement","valueNumber":null,"valueBoolean":null}]},{"id":"cmqq54moo00afr0tb1v1c67zu","slug":"year-established","name":"Year Established","unit":"year","category":"Maturity","dataType":"number","higherIsBetter":true,"values":[{"entityId":"cmpp6evr201pyv4d8dtwolmhe","valueText":"2020","valueNumber":2020,"valueBoolean":null}]},{"id":"cmqq54mow00ajr0tbxvi11kd5","slug":"estimated-community-size","name":"Estimated Community Size","unit":"relative","category":"Community","dataType":"text","higherIsBetter":true,"values":[{"entityId":"cmpp6evr201pyv4d8dtwolmhe","valueText":"Growing (4 years, ~50K-100K developers)","valueNumber":null,"valueBoolean":null}]},{"id":"cmqq937io00xhal68xo1203iz","slug":"average-global-latency","name":"Average Global Latency","unit":"milliseconds","category":"Performance","dataType":"number","higherIsBetter":false,"values":[{"entityId":"cmpp6evr201pyv4d8dtwolmhe","valueText":"45ms (with edge)","valueNumber":45,"valueBoolean":null,"winner":true},{"entityId":"cmpp6e7lm01o8v4d8sxgqvc5l","valueText":"120ms (US-based)","valueNumber":120,"valueBoolean":null,"winner":false}]},{"id":"cmqqesd1t00rfnitae61es7fc","slug":"managed-database-options","name":"Managed Database Options","unit":"count","category":"Features","dataType":"number","higherIsBetter":true,"values":[{"entityId":"cmpp6evr201pyv4d8dtwolmhe","valueText":"0 (external integration required)","valueNumber":0,"valueBoolean":null}]},{"id":"cmqoj0tjf008jnbes3kit2ued","slug":"compute-cost-per-hour","name":"Compute Cost Per Hour","unit":"USD","category":"Pricing","dataType":"number","higherIsBetter":false,"values":[{"entityId":"cmpp6evr201pyv4d8dtwolmhe","valueText":"$0.0030 (shared-cpu-1x)","valueNumber":0.003,"valueBoolean":null}]},{"id":"cmq04qx28000unfwwc2isuxwg","slug":"api-rate-limit","name":"API Rate Limit","unit":"requests/minute","category":"Technical","dataType":"number","higherIsBetter":true,"values":[{"entityId":"cmpp6evr201pyv4d8dtwolmhe","valueText":"Unlimited (no published per-hour cap)","valueNumber":null,"valueBoolean":null}]},{"id":"cmqqmnpvt0039tqd2vy0yfz6a","slug":"free-tier-included","name":"Free Tier Included","unit":"boolean","category":"Pricing","dataType":"text","higherIsBetter":true,"values":[{"entityId":"cmpp6evr201pyv4d8dtwolmhe","valueText":"Yes; 3x 256MB shared VMs monthly","valueNumber":null,"valueBoolean":null}]},{"id":"cmqqmnpw5003ftqd2ktqdakhk","slug":"container-native-support","name":"Container Native Support","unit":"boolean","category":"Features","dataType":"text","higherIsBetter":true,"values":[{"entityId":"cmpp6evr201pyv4d8dtwolmhe","valueText":"Primary deployment method with auto-scaling","valueNumber":null,"valueBoolean":null}]},{"id":"cmr0yikw600k9axoeo3u43otv","slug":"vcpu-monthly-cost","name":"vCPU Monthly Cost","unit":"USD","category":"Pricing","dataType":"number","higherIsBetter":false,"values":[{"entityId":"cmpp6evr201pyv4d8dtwolmhe","valueText":"$8.00","valueNumber":8,"valueBoolean":null,"winner":true},{"entityId":"cmpp6e7lm01o8v4d8sxgqvc5l","valueText":"$12.50","valueNumber":12.5,"valueBoolean":null,"winner":false}]},{"id":"cmqo89fx40027rragapxem3y7","slug":"global-data-center-regions","name":"Global Data Center Regions","unit":"regions","category":"Infrastructure","dataType":"number","higherIsBetter":true,"values":[{"entityId":"cmpp6evr201pyv4d8dtwolmhe","valueText":"34 regions","valueNumber":34,"valueBoolean":null,"winner":true},{"entityId":"cmpp6e7lm01o8v4d8sxgqvc5l","valueText":"6 regions","valueNumber":6,"valueBoolean":null,"winner":false}]},{"id":"cmr0yikwu00klaxoeqgm5yw6w","slug":"free-tier-monthly-value","name":"Free Tier Monthly Value","unit":"hours/month or USD credit","category":"Pricing","dataType":"text","higherIsBetter":true,"values":[{"entityId":"cmpp6evr201pyv4d8dtwolmhe","valueText":"$3 credit/month","valueNumber":3,"valueBoolean":null,"winner":false},{"entityId":"cmpp6e7lm01o8v4d8sxgqvc5l","valueText":"750 free hours/month (~$37 value)","valueNumber":37,"valueBoolean":null,"winner":true}]},{"id":"cmq9t29b2000c1419f67w2it5","slug":"cold-start-time","name":"Cold Start Time","unit":"milliseconds","category":"Performance","dataType":"number","higherIsBetter":false,"values":[{"entityId":"cmpp6evr201pyv4d8dtwolmhe","valueText":"<500ms","valueNumber":500,"valueBoolean":null,"winner":true},{"entityId":"cmpp6e7lm01o8v4d8sxgqvc5l","valueText":"1000-2000ms","valueNumber":1500,"valueBoolean":null,"winner":false}]},{"id":"cmr0yikxi00kxaxoejx2nyc5m","slug":"minimum-ram-per-instance","name":"Minimum RAM per Instance","unit":"MB","category":"Infrastructure","dataType":"number","higherIsBetter":false,"values":[{"entityId":"cmpp6evr201pyv4d8dtwolmhe","valueText":"256MB (shared)","valueNumber":256,"valueBoolean":null,"winner":true},{"entityId":"cmpp6e7lm01o8v4d8sxgqvc5l","valueText":"512MB","valueNumber":512,"valueBoolean":null,"winner":false}]},{"id":"cmq9t29cq00101419poacgzw2","slug":"native-database-support","name":"Native Database Support","unit":null,"category":"Features","dataType":"number","higherIsBetter":null,"values":[{"entityId":"cmpp6evr201pyv4d8dtwolmhe","valueText":"1 (PostgreSQL via Supabase)","valueNumber":1,"valueBoolean":null},{"entityId":"cmpp6e7lm01o8v4d8sxgqvc5l","valueText":"PostgreSQL, MySQL, Redis, MongoDB native","valueNumber":null,"valueBoolean":null}]},{"id":"cmrbny5fv00r7alj4s61ow3jb","slug":"monthly-cost-basic-production-app-","name":"Monthly Cost (Basic Production App)","unit":"USD","category":"Pricing","dataType":"number","higherIsBetter":false,"values":[{"entityId":"cmpp6evr201pyv4d8dtwolmhe","valueText":"$10-30","valueNumber":20,"valueBoolean":null}]},{"id":"cmrbny5g800rdalj41oxk7wv1","slug":"global-deployment-regions","name":"Global Deployment Regions","unit":"regions","category":"Infrastructure","dataType":"number","higherIsBetter":true,"values":[{"entityId":"cmpp6evr201pyv4d8dtwolmhe","valueText":"28","valueNumber":28,"valueBoolean":null}]},{"id":"cmq9xuv49002p11c7omgny8bm","slug":"deployment-time","name":"Deployment Time","unit":"seconds","category":"Performance","dataType":"number","higherIsBetter":false,"values":[{"entityId":"cmpp6evr201pyv4d8dtwolmhe","valueText":"15-30","valueNumber":22,"valueBoolean":null}]},{"id":"cmrbny5hb00rvalj43oimjnnd","slug":"included-postgresql-database","name":"Included PostgreSQL Database","unit":"starting price USD/month","category":"Features","dataType":"number","higherIsBetter":false,"values":[{"entityId":"cmpp6evr201pyv4d8dtwolmhe","valueText":"$0 (dev tier)","valueNumber":0,"valueBoolean":null}]},{"id":"cmrbny5ho00s1alj4ez6vo3pe","slug":"community-size-age","name":"Community Size & Age","unit":"years active","category":"Support","dataType":"number","higherIsBetter":true,"values":[{"entityId":"cmpp6evr201pyv4d8dtwolmhe","valueText":"4 years (launched 2021)","valueNumber":4,"valueBoolean":null}]},{"id":"cmr1o8o9400nnn16rsq6t0vd8","slug":"free-tier-monthly-credit","name":"Free Tier Monthly Credit","unit":"USD","category":"Pricing","dataType":"number","higherIsBetter":true,"values":[{"entityId":"cmpp6evr201pyv4d8dtwolmhe","valueText":"$3","valueNumber":3,"valueBoolean":null}]},{"id":"cmrbny5if00sdalj4n7d0zwpn","slug":"typical-app-latency-us-eu-","name":"Typical App Latency (US-EU)","unit":"milliseconds","category":"Performance","dataType":"number","higherIsBetter":false,"values":[{"entityId":"cmpp6evr201pyv4d8dtwolmhe","valueText":"50-100","valueNumber":75,"valueBoolean":null}]},{"id":"cmqpen3ji00bvw8ednowej6gd","slug":"global-server-regions","name":"Global Server Regions","unit":"regions","category":"Infrastructure","dataType":"number","higherIsBetter":true,"values":[{"entityId":"cmpp6evr201pyv4d8dtwolmhe","valueText":"30+ worldwide regions","valueNumber":30,"valueBoolean":null,"winner":true},{"entityId":"cmpp6e7lm01o8v4d8sxgqvc5l","valueText":"3 US regions only","valueNumber":3,"valueBoolean":null,"winner":false}]},{"id":"cmotoy00t000b58hqc28a65ps","slug":"minimum-monthly-cost","name":"Minimum Monthly Cost","unit":"USD","category":"Pricing","dataType":"number","higherIsBetter":false,"values":[{"entityId":"cmpp6evr201pyv4d8dtwolmhe","valueText":"$0 (pay-as-you-go)","valueNumber":0,"valueBoolean":null,"winner":true},{"entityId":"cmpp6e7lm01o8v4d8sxgqvc5l","valueText":"$7/month","valueNumber":7,"valueBoolean":null,"winner":false}]},{"id":"cmrd8ptyl007j5xvxpa515qka","slug":"startup-database-cost-1gb-postgresql-","name":"Startup Database Cost (1GB PostgreSQL)","unit":"USD/month","category":"Pricing","dataType":"number","higherIsBetter":false,"values":[{"entityId":"cmpp6evr201pyv4d8dtwolmhe","valueText":"$15/month","valueNumber":15,"valueBoolean":null,"winner":false},{"entityId":"cmpp6e7lm01o8v4d8sxgqvc5l","valueText":"$9/month","valueNumber":9,"valueBoolean":null,"winner":true}]},{"id":"cmrd8ptyt007p5xvx23h20ru8","slug":"free-tier-compute-hours-month","name":"Free Tier Compute Hours/Month","unit":"hours","category":"Pricing","dataType":"number","higherIsBetter":true,"values":[{"entityId":"cmpp6evr201pyv4d8dtwolmhe","valueText":"Unlimited (pay-as-you-go from $0.15/GB)","valueNumber":null,"valueBoolean":null},{"entityId":"cmpp6e7lm01o8v4d8sxgqvc5l","valueText":"750 hours/month","valueNumber":750,"valueBoolean":null}]},{"id":"cmqkdo60h002lav7wjo87ynbv","slug":"average-deployment-time","name":"Average Deployment Time","unit":"seconds","category":"Performance","dataType":"number","higherIsBetter":false,"values":[{"entityId":"cmpp6evr201pyv4d8dtwolmhe","valueText":"45 seconds","valueNumber":45,"valueBoolean":null,"winner":true},{"entityId":"cmpp6e7lm01o8v4d8sxgqvc5l","valueText":"60 seconds","valueNumber":60,"valueBoolean":null,"winner":false}]},{"id":"cmrd8ptz900815xvx7q3443cl","slug":"docker-support-level","name":"Docker Support Level","unit":null,"category":"Features","dataType":"text","higherIsBetter":null,"values":[{"entityId":"cmpp6evr201pyv4d8dtwolmhe","valueText":"Native - Any Dockerfile","valueNumber":null,"valueBoolean":null},{"entityId":"cmpp6e7lm01o8v4d8sxgqvc5l","valueText":"Secondary - Buildpack-first","valueNumber":null,"valueBoolean":null}]},{"id":"cmqojsg31001h1wo5atcaghaq","slug":"setup-complexity-1-10-scale-","name":"Setup Complexity (1-10 scale)","unit":"difficulty score","category":"Usability","dataType":"number","higherIsBetter":false,"values":[{"entityId":"cmpp6evr201pyv4d8dtwolmhe","valueText":"7 - Requires CLI and Docker knowledge","valueNumber":7,"valueBoolean":null,"winner":false},{"entityId":"cmpp6e7lm01o8v4d8sxgqvc5l","valueText":"3 - Git push deployment","valueNumber":3,"valueBoolean":null,"winner":true}]},{"id":"cmrd8ptzp008d5xvx8wba4es0","slug":"bandwidth-cost-overage-","name":"Bandwidth Cost (Overage)","unit":"USD/GB","category":"Pricing","dataType":"number","higherIsBetter":false,"values":[{"entityId":"cmpp6evr201pyv4d8dtwolmhe","valueText":"$0.02/GB","valueNumber":0.02,"valueBoolean":null,"winner":true},{"entityId":"cmpp6e7lm01o8v4d8sxgqvc5l","valueText":"$0.10/GB","valueNumber":0.1,"valueBoolean":null,"winner":false}]},{"id":"cmqqdt9mg00klnitalb9x3vvv","slug":"cold-start-time-backend-free-tier-","name":"Cold Start Time (Backend Free Tier)","unit":"milliseconds","category":"Performance & Limits","dataType":"number","higherIsBetter":false,"values":[{"entityId":"cmpp6e7lm01o8v4d8sxgqvc5l","valueText":"100-500 ms","valueNumber":300,"valueBoolean":null}]},{"id":"cmqqdt9mn00krnitaaf12rrml","slug":"cron-jobs-background-workers","name":"Cron Jobs / Background Workers","unit":null,"category":"Features","dataType":"text","higherIsBetter":null,"values":[{"entityId":"cmpp6e7lm01o8v4d8sxgqvc5l","valueText":"Included on all plans","valueNumber":null,"valueBoolean":null}]},{"id":"cmpp6eaf601ozv4d8bmqh1y1r","slug":"maximum-uptime-sla","name":"Maximum Uptime SLA","unit":"%","category":"Reliability","dataType":"number","higherIsBetter":true,"values":[{"entityId":"cmpp6e7lm01o8v4d8sxgqvc5l","valueText":"99.9%","valueNumber":99.9,"valueBoolean":null}]},{"id":"cmpp6ebq401pbv4d8d0o6wg60","slug":"available-add-ons","name":"Available Add-ons","unit":"count","category":"Ecosystem","dataType":"number","higherIsBetter":true,"values":[{"entityId":"cmpp6e7lm01o8v4d8sxgqvc5l","valueText":"Core services only","valueNumber":5,"valueBoolean":null}]},{"id":"cmpp6ecdi01phv4d8ly0per5x","slug":"deployment-methods","name":"Deployment Methods","unit":null,"category":"DevOps","dataType":"text","higherIsBetter":null,"values":[{"entityId":"cmpp6e7lm01o8v4d8sxgqvc5l","valueText":"Git push, Docker push, GitHub/GitLab CI","valueNumber":null,"valueBoolean":null}]},{"id":"cmpp6ed0x01pnv4d8jo59b3wk","slug":"build-duration","name":"Build Duration","unit":"seconds (average)","category":"Performance","dataType":"number","higherIsBetter":false,"values":[{"entityId":"cmpp6e7lm01o8v4d8sxgqvc5l","valueText":"30-45","valueNumber":37.5,"valueBoolean":null}]},{"id":"cmpp5ld9a0039v4d82hja28am","slug":"free-trial-period","name":"Free Trial Period","unit":"days","category":"Pricing","dataType":"number","higherIsBetter":true,"values":[{"entityId":"cmpp6e7lm01o8v4d8sxgqvc5l","valueText":"14 days","valueNumber":0,"valueBoolean":null}]},{"id":"cmnx983dz00cn7n44jddcza2g","slug":"basic-plan-monthly-cost","name":"Basic Plan Monthly Cost","unit":"USD","category":"Pricing","dataType":"number","higherIsBetter":false,"values":[{"entityId":"cmpp6e7lm01o8v4d8sxgqvc5l","valueText":"$7/month","valueNumber":7,"valueBoolean":null}]},{"id":"cmqqet0st00uznitabv2rkhl2","slug":"basic-plan-ram","name":"Basic Plan RAM","unit":"GB","category":"Specs","dataType":"number","higherIsBetter":true,"values":[{"entityId":"cmpp6e7lm01o8v4d8sxgqvc5l","valueText":"0.5GB (shared)","valueNumber":0.5,"valueBoolean":null}]},{"id":"cmqqet0t000v5nitaja7kynpt","slug":"basic-plan-vcpu","name":"Basic Plan vCPU","unit":"cores","category":"Specs","dataType":"number","higherIsBetter":true,"values":[{"entityId":"cmpp6e7lm01o8v4d8sxgqvc5l","valueText":"0.5 shared","valueNumber":0.5,"valueBoolean":null}]},{"id":"cmqmr9ejt01i43yyiyot7vjcr","slug":"free-tier-monthly-compute-hours","name":"Free Tier Monthly Compute Hours","unit":"hours","category":"Pricing","dataType":"number","higherIsBetter":true,"values":[{"entityId":"cmpp6e7lm01o8v4d8sxgqvc5l","valueText":"750 hours free","valueNumber":750,"valueBoolean":null}]},{"id":"cmq85t68c000jhy7abv105r01","slug":"built-in-ci-cd-pipelines","name":"Built-in CI/CD Pipelines","unit":null,"category":"Features","dataType":"text","higherIsBetter":true,"values":[{"entityId":"cmpp6e7lm01o8v4d8sxgqvc5l","valueText":"Automatic from Git","valueNumber":null,"valueBoolean":null}]},{"id":"cmqo89fxa002brragkbu394k9","slug":"managed-database-types","name":"Managed Database Types","unit":"count","category":"Features","dataType":"number","higherIsBetter":true,"values":[{"entityId":"cmpp6e7lm01o8v4d8sxgqvc5l","valueText":"3 types","valueNumber":3,"valueBoolean":null}]},{"id":"cmpp7ay62002lq4keh8uchc7o","slug":"api-rate-limits","name":"API Rate Limits","unit":"requests per minute","category":"Performance","dataType":"number","higherIsBetter":true,"values":[{"entityId":"cmpp6e7lm01o8v4d8sxgqvc5l","valueText":"Not publicly limited","valueNumber":null,"valueBoolean":null}]},{"id":"cmnx955k6005p7n449z56yziv","slug":"starter-plan-monthly-cost","name":"Starter Plan Monthly Cost","unit":"USD","category":"Pricing","dataType":"number","higherIsBetter":false,"values":[{"entityId":"cmpp6e7lm01o8v4d8sxgqvc5l","valueText":"$7/month","valueNumber":7,"valueBoolean":null}]},{"id":"cmqp0rsfh00qt13o1y7nuroco","slug":"edge-function-cold-start","name":"Edge Function Cold Start","unit":"milliseconds","category":"Performance","dataType":"number","higherIsBetter":false,"values":[{"entityId":"cmpp6e7lm01o8v4d8sxgqvc5l","valueText":"N/A (no edge)","valueNumber":null,"valueBoolean":null}]},{"id":"cmqp0rsfq00qz13o1uci1mqei","slug":"standard-deployment-cold-start","name":"Standard Deployment Cold Start","unit":"milliseconds","category":"Performance","dataType":"number","higherIsBetter":false,"values":[{"entityId":"cmpp6e7lm01o8v4d8sxgqvc5l","valueText":"200-800ms","valueNumber":500,"valueBoolean":null}]},{"id":"cmqp0rsg000r513o1gcsjkz4i","slug":"edge-network-locations","name":"Edge Network Locations","unit":"regions","category":"Infrastructure","dataType":"number","higherIsBetter":true,"values":[{"entityId":"cmpp6e7lm01o8v4d8sxgqvc5l","valueText":"6 primary regions","valueNumber":6,"valueBoolean":null}]},{"id":"cmqp0rsgf00rb13o16jujnp2v","slug":"database-options","name":"Database Options","unit":"types","category":"Features","dataType":"text","higherIsBetter":true,"values":[{"entityId":"cmpp6e7lm01o8v4d8sxgqvc5l","valueText":"PostgreSQL, MySQL, Redis","valueNumber":3,"valueBoolean":null}]},{"id":"cmqp0rsgp00rh13o1t0xbbu17","slug":"background-jobs","name":"Background Jobs","unit":"native support","category":"Features","dataType":"text","higherIsBetter":null,"values":[{"entityId":"cmpp6e7lm01o8v4d8sxgqvc5l","valueText":"Built-in native support","valueNumber":1,"valueBoolean":null}]},{"id":"cmqp0rsgz00rn13o10y5frq3f","slug":"supported-frameworks-languages","name":"Supported Frameworks/Languages","unit":"count","category":"Flexibility","dataType":"number","higherIsBetter":true,"values":[{"entityId":"cmpp6e7lm01o8v4d8sxgqvc5l","valueText":"Node.js, Python, Ruby, Go, Rust equally","valueNumber":5,"valueBoolean":null}]},{"id":"cmqp0rsh800rt13o1ahaiq87f","slug":"free-tier-included-features","name":"Free Tier Included Features","unit":"text","category":"Pricing","dataType":"text","higherIsBetter":null,"values":[{"entityId":"cmpp6e7lm01o8v4d8sxgqvc5l","valueText":"1 PostgreSQL database (500MB), 100GB bandwidth/month","valueNumber":null,"valueBoolean":null}]},{"id":"cmqqdt9l000jlnitafga9492z","slug":"free-tier-bandwidth-static-","name":"Free Tier Bandwidth (Static)","unit":"GB/month","category":"Performance & Limits","dataType":"number","higherIsBetter":true,"values":[{"entityId":"cmpp6e7lm01o8v4d8sxgqvc5l","valueText":"Unlimited","valueNumber":null,"valueBoolean":null}]},{"id":"cmqqdt9lk00jxnitaqnjw05ng","slug":"edge-functions","name":"Edge Functions","unit":null,"category":"Features","dataType":"text","higherIsBetter":null,"values":[{"entityId":"cmpp6e7lm01o8v4d8sxgqvc5l","valueText":"Not available","valueNumber":null,"valueBoolean":null}]},{"id":"cmqq8v0i300vpal68x0yvqr9z","slug":"minimum-paid-plan-cost","name":"Minimum Paid Plan Cost","unit":"USD/month","category":"Pricing & Limits","dataType":"number","higherIsBetter":false,"values":[{"entityId":"cmpp6e7lm01o8v4d8sxgqvc5l","valueText":"$7/month","valueNumber":7,"valueBoolean":null}]},{"id":"cmqqdt9m000k9nitavoyzy8yk","slug":"build-minutes-free-tier-","name":"Build Minutes (Free Tier)","unit":"monthly minutes","category":"Performance","dataType":"number","higherIsBetter":true,"values":[{"entityId":"cmpp6e7lm01o8v4d8sxgqvc5l","valueText":"500 hours/month","valueNumber":30000,"valueBoolean":null}]},{"id":"cmqqdt9m800kfnitaiknuncx5","slug":"backend-deployment-support","name":"Backend Deployment Support","unit":null,"category":"Features","dataType":"text","higherIsBetter":null,"values":[{"entityId":"cmpp6e7lm01o8v4d8sxgqvc5l","valueText":"Full support (Web Services)","valueNumber":null,"valueBoolean":null}]},{"id":"cmqqgqy5t000nismnwqs6zma4","slug":"time-to-first-deployment","name":"Time to First Deployment","unit":"minutes","category":"Development Speed","dataType":"number","higherIsBetter":false,"values":[{"entityId":"cmpp6e7lm01o8v4d8sxgqvc5l","valueText":"2-5 minutes","valueNumber":3.5,"valueBoolean":null}]},{"id":"cmqr2j5o4000hvdq1g8vamuir","slug":"required-devops-experience","name":"Required DevOps Experience","unit":"hours to proficiency","category":"Learning & Operations","dataType":"number","higherIsBetter":false,"values":[{"entityId":"cmpp6e7lm01o8v4d8sxgqvc5l","valueText":"10-20 hours","valueNumber":15,"valueBoolean":null}]},{"id":"cmqr2j5ob000nvdq1ltufkynm","slug":"global-community-size","name":"Global Community Size","unit":"developers","category":"Community & Support","dataType":"number","higherIsBetter":true,"values":[{"entityId":"cmpp6e7lm01o8v4d8sxgqvc5l","valueText":"150,000+","valueNumber":150000,"valueBoolean":null}]},{"id":"cmqr2j5oh000tvdq12103crsf","slug":"minimum-monthly-cost-small-app-","name":"Minimum Monthly Cost (Small App)","unit":"USD","category":"Pricing","dataType":"number","higherIsBetter":false,"values":[{"entityId":"cmpp6e7lm01o8v4d8sxgqvc5l","valueText":"$7-50","valueNumber":28.5,"valueBoolean":null}]},{"id":"cmqr2j5oo000zvdq1tyafcl63","slug":"enterprise-scale-monthly-cost","name":"Enterprise Scale Monthly Cost","unit":"USD","category":"Pricing","dataType":"number","higherIsBetter":false,"values":[{"entityId":"cmpp6e7lm01o8v4d8sxgqvc5l","valueText":"$500-3,000+","valueNumber":1750,"valueBoolean":null}]},{"id":"cmqr2j5ov0015vdq11w0kn1af","slug":"maximum-concurrent-users-native-support-","name":"Maximum Concurrent Users (Native Support)","unit":"users","category":"Scalability","dataType":"number","higherIsBetter":true,"values":[{"entityId":"cmpp6e7lm01o8v4d8sxgqvc5l","valueText":"10,000-50,000","valueNumber":30000,"valueBoolean":null}]},{"id":"cmqr2j5p5001bvdq14pbqo297","slug":"configuration-as-code-support","name":"Configuration as Code Support","unit":"capability level","category":"Infrastructure","dataType":"text","higherIsBetter":null,"values":[{"entityId":"cmpp6e7lm01o8v4d8sxgqvc5l","valueText":"Limited (render.yaml declarative)","valueNumber":null,"valueBoolean":null}]},{"id":"cmqr2j5pb001hvdq1zyubb5dk","slug":"automatic-scaling-setup-time","name":"Automatic Scaling Setup Time","unit":"minutes","category":"Operations","dataType":"number","higherIsBetter":false,"values":[{"entityId":"cmpp6e7lm01o8v4d8sxgqvc5l","valueText":"5-15 minutes","valueNumber":10,"valueBoolean":null}]},{"id":"cmqzj2m3h00i0q3dajtl8ckna","slug":"minimum-monthly-cost-paid-tier-","name":"Minimum Monthly Cost (Paid Tier)","unit":"USD","category":"Pricing","dataType":"number","higherIsBetter":false,"values":[{"entityId":"cmpp6e7lm01o8v4d8sxgqvc5l","valueText":"$7/month","valueNumber":7,"valueBoolean":null}]},{"id":"cmqzj2m3o00i6q3dar96rdmlh","slug":"database-cost-pro-tier-","name":"Database Cost (Pro Tier)","unit":"USD/month","category":"Pricing","dataType":"number","higherIsBetter":false,"values":[{"entityId":"cmpp6e7lm01o8v4d8sxgqvc5l","valueText":"$9","valueNumber":9,"valueBoolean":null}]},{"id":"cmqzj2m3v00icq3dand8175yt","slug":"cold-start-performance","name":"Cold Start Performance","unit":"milliseconds","category":"Performance","dataType":"number","higherIsBetter":false,"values":[{"entityId":"cmpp6e7lm01o8v4d8sxgqvc5l","valueText":"500-800ms","valueNumber":650,"valueBoolean":null}]},{"id":"cmqzj2m4800ioq3daptre2fvi","slug":"marketplace-add-ons-available","name":"Marketplace Add-ons Available","unit":"count","category":"Integrations","dataType":"number","higherIsBetter":true,"values":[{"entityId":"cmpp6e7lm01o8v4d8sxgqvc5l","valueText":"50+ integrations","valueNumber":50,"valueBoolean":null}]},{"id":"cmqzj2m4f00iuq3dauzfp0pk7","slug":"company-age-maturity","name":"Company Age & Maturity","unit":"years","category":"Reliability","dataType":"number","higherIsBetter":true,"values":[{"entityId":"cmpp6e7lm01o8v4d8sxgqvc5l","valueText":"Founded 2019","valueNumber":5,"valueBoolean":null}]},{"id":"cmq3cpkqk000ugm4fov6hn5ok","slug":"uptime-sla-guarantee","name":"Uptime SLA Guarantee","unit":"percent","category":"Reliability","dataType":"number","higherIsBetter":true,"values":[{"entityId":"cmpp6e7lm01o8v4d8sxgqvc5l","valueText":"99.9% (standard)","valueNumber":99.9,"valueBoolean":null}]},{"id":"cmotyzqiz002tt0cfx9zbtcip","slug":"free-tier-available","name":"Free Tier Available","unit":null,"category":"Accessibility","dataType":"text","higherIsBetter":null,"values":[{"entityId":"cmpp6e7lm01o8v4d8sxgqvc5l","valueText":"Yes (with limitations)","valueNumber":null,"valueBoolean":null}]},{"id":"cmodmsyo100annv6uy4tac09q","slug":"global-edge-locations","name":"Global Edge Locations","unit":"locations","category":"Infrastructure","dataType":"number","higherIsBetter":true,"values":[{"entityId":"cmpp6e7lm01o8v4d8sxgqvc5l","valueText":"12 regional data centers","valueNumber":12,"valueBoolean":null}]},{"id":"cmrabv7mn007hub5a99s3jjwz","slug":"function-cold-start-time","name":"Function Cold Start Time","unit":"milliseconds","category":"Performance","dataType":"number","higherIsBetter":false,"values":[{"entityId":"cmpp6e7lm01o8v4d8sxgqvc5l","valueText":"200-400ms average","valueNumber":300,"valueBoolean":null}]},{"id":"cmqp10t5e00up13o1z6buq7ch","slug":"free-tier-monthly-bandwidth","name":"Free Tier Monthly Bandwidth","unit":"GB","category":"Pricing","dataType":"number","higherIsBetter":true,"values":[{"entityId":"cmpp6e7lm01o8v4d8sxgqvc5l","valueText":"100 GB/month","valueNumber":100,"valueBoolean":null}]},{"id":"cmrabv7n5007tub5aymoig6r9","slug":"free-tier-build-minutes","name":"Free Tier Build Minutes","unit":"minutes/month","category":"Limits","dataType":"number","higherIsBetter":true,"values":[{"entityId":"cmpp6e7lm01o8v4d8sxgqvc5l","valueText":"500 hours/month (30,000 minutes)","valueNumber":30000,"valueBoolean":null}]},{"id":"cmrabv7np0085ub5aat3itl0t","slug":"pro-plan-monthly-cost-single-site-app-","name":"Pro Plan Monthly Cost (Single Site/App)","unit":"USD","category":"Pricing","dataType":"number","higherIsBetter":false,"values":[{"entityId":"cmpp6e7lm01o8v4d8sxgqvc5l","valueText":"$7/month per service minimum","valueNumber":7,"valueBoolean":null}]},{"id":"cmrabv7o1008bub5amzg2ryxr","slug":"background-job-support","name":"Background Job Support","unit":null,"category":"Features","dataType":"text","higherIsBetter":null,"values":[{"entityId":"cmpp6e7lm01o8v4d8sxgqvc5l","valueText":"Native background jobs and queues","valueNumber":null,"valueBoolean":null}]},{"id":"cmrabv7o9008hub5aj6gahoa7","slug":"function-execution-timeout","name":"Function Execution Timeout","unit":"seconds","category":"Limits","dataType":"number","higherIsBetter":true,"values":[{"entityId":"cmpp6e7lm01o8v4d8sxgqvc5l","valueText":"30 seconds standard","valueNumber":30,"valueBoolean":null}]},{"id":"cmospl6xj000nr1eh8pwygdid","slug":"initial-setup-time","name":"Initial Setup Time","unit":"minutes","category":"Ease of Use","dataType":"number","higherIsBetter":false,"values":[{"entityId":"cmpp6e7lm01o8v4d8sxgqvc5l","valueText":"0.02 weeks (10 minutes)","valueNumber":0.02,"valueBoolean":null}]},{"id":"cmrci25wl01miiipzbibtofum","slug":"monthly-cost-5-app-startup-","name":"Monthly Cost (5-app startup)","unit":"USD","category":"Pricing","dataType":"number","higherIsBetter":false,"values":[{"entityId":"cmpp6e7lm01o8v4d8sxgqvc5l","valueText":"$35-150","valueNumber":92.5,"valueBoolean":null}]},{"id":"cmrci25wt01moiipzp6ny00ih","slug":"monthly-cost-enterprise-100-services-","name":"Monthly Cost (enterprise, 100+ services)","unit":"USD","category":"Pricing","dataType":"number","higherIsBetter":false,"values":[{"entityId":"cmpp6e7lm01o8v4d8sxgqvc5l","valueText":"$8000-20000","valueNumber":14000,"valueBoolean":null}]},{"id":"cmrci25x401muiipz38n21ius","slug":"devops-team-size-required","name":"DevOps Team Size Required","unit":"people","category":"Operations","dataType":"number","higherIsBetter":false,"values":[{"entityId":"cmpp6e7lm01o8v4d8sxgqvc5l","valueText":"0 (managed by vendor)","valueNumber":0,"valueBoolean":null}]},{"id":"cmqjz3h3p001vnrt1u7pndjna","slug":"maximum-scalability","name":"Maximum Scalability","unit":"concurrent container instances","category":"Performance","dataType":"number","higherIsBetter":true,"values":[{"entityId":"cmpp6e7lm01o8v4d8sxgqvc5l","valueText":"~500-1000 containers per service","valueNumber":750,"valueBoolean":null}]},{"id":"cmraqta4j00jnijw9pvva5yvd","slug":"infrastructure-customization-level","name":"Infrastructure Customization Level","unit":"percent","category":"Flexibility","dataType":"text","higherIsBetter":true,"values":[{"entityId":"cmpp6e7lm01o8v4d8sxgqvc5l","valueText":"20-30% (platform limitations)","valueNumber":25,"valueBoolean":null}]},{"id":"cmrci25y101nciipzyxrq2922","slug":"learning-curve-to-production-ready-","name":"Learning Curve (to production-ready)","unit":"months","category":"Ease of Use","dataType":"number","higherIsBetter":false,"values":[{"entityId":"cmpp6e7lm01o8v4d8sxgqvc5l","valueText":"0.5-1 week","valueNumber":0.35,"valueBoolean":null}]},{"id":"cmrci25y801niiipzp5010hg7","slug":"built-in-services-databases-caching-etc-","name":"Built-in Services (databases, caching, etc.)","unit":"count","category":"Features","dataType":"number","higherIsBetter":true,"values":[{"entityId":"cmpp6e7lm01o8v4d8sxgqvc5l","valueText":"6 built-in (PostgreSQL, Redis, MySQL, MongoDB, etc.)","valueNumber":6,"valueBoolean":null}]}],"faqs":[{"question":"Which platform is better for deploying a Next.js app globally?","answer":"Fly.io is superior for global distribution due to its 30+ worldwide regions enabling sub-100ms latency anywhere. Render works fine for US-focused audiences but will have 200-500ms latency for international users. Both support Next.js, but Fly.io's edge deployment makes it ideal for performance-critical global apps."},{"question":"Can I deploy without writing Docker files?","answer":"Yes - Render is designed for this with Git-based buildpacks (like Heroku). Fly.io requires a Dockerfile by default, though you can use their generator. If Docker is unfamiliar, Render is significantly easier for beginners."},{"question":"What's the actual cost difference for a small startup?","answer":"For a basic web app with 1GB PostgreSQL database: Fly.io starts at $0 (pay-as-you-go, typically $5-15/month depending on usage) plus $15/month for DB = ~$20-30/month. Render is $7/month minimum plus $9/month for DB = $16/month guaranteed. However, Fly.io can be cheaper at scale due to lower bandwidth costs ($0.02/GB vs $0.10/GB)."},{"question":"Which has better documentation and community support?","answer":"Render has more comprehensive documentation and larger community (Heroku migration guides, more Stack Overflow answers). Fly.io's documentation is solid but the community is smaller. For beginners, Render's support ecosystem is more extensive."},{"question":"Can I use PostgreSQL on both platforms?","answer":"Yes, both offer managed PostgreSQL. Render is cheaper ($9 vs $15/month for 1GB). Fly.io's databases can be deployed in multiple regions for redundancy. Choose Render for cost, Fly.io for distributed resilience."}],"relatedComparisons":[{"slug":"fly-io-vs-render","title":"Fly.io vs Render","category":"software"},{"slug":"vercel-vs-render","title":"Vercel vs Render","category":"software"},{"slug":"heroku-vs-fly-io","title":"Heroku vs Fly.io","category":"software"},{"slug":"netlify-vs-render","title":"Netlify vs Render","category":"software"},{"slug":"digitalocean-vs-render","title":"DigitalOcean vs Render","category":"software"},{"slug":"digitalocean-vs-fly-io","title":"DigitalOcean vs Fly.io","category":"software"},{"slug":"kubernetes-vs-render","title":"Kubernetes vs Render","category":"software"},{"slug":"heroku-vs-render","title":"Render vs Heroku","category":"software"},{"slug":"netlify-vs-render)","title":"Netlify vs Render","category":"software"},{"slug":"heroku-vs-fly-io)","title":"Heroku vs Fly.io","category":"software"},{"slug":"kubernetes-vs-render)","title":"Kubernetes vs Render","category":"software"},{"slug":"wordpress-vs-wix","title":"WordPress vs Wix","category":"software"}],"relatedBlogPosts":[{"slug":"best-streaming-services-in-2026-top-picks-for-every-budget-interest","title":"Best Streaming Services in 2026: Top Picks for Every Budget & Interest","excerpt":"Navigating the crowded streaming landscape in 2026 can be overwhelming. We've tested and ranked the best streaming services that offer the most value, from Netflix's massive library to budget-friendly options like Tubi, helping you cut cable and find your perfect entertainment solution.","category":"technology"},{"slug":"best-live-tv-streaming-services-plans-for-spring-2026-complete-buyers-guide","title":"Best Live TV Streaming Services & Plans for Spring 2026: Complete Buyer's Guide","excerpt":"Tired of overpaying for cable? Discover the best live TV streaming services and plans for Spring 2026, including YouTube TV's new genre-based packages starting at $55/month. Our comprehensive guide breaks down pricing, channels, and features to help you cut the cord.","category":"technology"},{"slug":"philo-in-2026-streaming-tv-service-review-pricing-reddit-community-insights","title":"Philo in 2026: Streaming TV Service Review, Pricing & Reddit Community Insights","excerpt":"Explore Philo's evolution heading into 2026, including pricing tiers, channel lineup, and how it compares to competitors like Sling TV. Discover what the r/PhiloTV Reddit community thinks about the service's current offerings and future prospects.","category":"technology"},{"slug":"best-us-fighter-jets-2026-top-american-combat-aircraft-ranked","title":"Best US Fighter Jets 2026: Top American Combat Aircraft Ranked","excerpt":"Discover the most advanced US fighter jets dominating the skies in 2026. From the legendary F-22 Raptor to the versatile F-35 Lightning II, we rank America's best combat aircraft based on performance, stealth, and air superiority capabilities.","category":"technology"},{"slug":"philo-in-2026-pricing-lineup-how-it-compares-to-sling-tv","title":"Philo in 2026: Pricing, Lineup & How It Compares to Sling TV","excerpt":"As we head into 2026, Philo continues to position itself as an affordable streaming alternative for cable TV lovers. Discover what Philo offers, how its pricing stacks up against competitors like Sling TV, and what the Reddit community thinks about its future.","category":"technology"}],"metadata":{"metaTitle":"Fly.io vs Render: PaaS Comparison 2026","metaDescription":"Compare Fly.io and Render: global edge deployment vs simplicity. Pricing, latency, Docker support, and features analyzed.","publishedAt":"2026-07-09T08:23:55.572Z","updatedAt":"2026-07-09T08:23:55.596Z","isAutoGenerated":true,"isHumanReviewed":false,"viewCount":0}}